jsb357
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 7,803
- Reaction score
- 7,419
twitter stats....
Can we break it down into first half only and see how it compares?
twitter stats....
This is where much of the difference of opinion comes in.The best chance of winning is proficiency of your passing offense.
Every credible ex-player and coach who’s paid to cover this sport believes Dak is a damn good QB.
He’s universally recognized as a top 10 QB by those same analysts. The stats back that up as well.Have you ever noticed how nobody holds him up as an example of what they want in a QB though? Its always Russ, AR, TB, Mahomes etc. when they do clips about technique, arm talent, mastery of the game, etc..
Shouldn't we interpret that as where on the "good" scale they really believe he is.
He’s universally recognized as a top 10 QB by those same analysts. The stats back that up as well.
You don’t get rid of young, top 10 NFL QBs. Period. You hold onto them for dear life and try to build a great team around them.
Ummm....Dak's been on the team 5 years now......when does all his 'greatness' start????
He’s universally recognized as a top 10 QB by those same analysts. The stats back that up as well.
You don’t get rid of young, top 10 NFL QBs. Period. You hold onto them for dear life and try to build a great team around them.
C'mon. That's a little harsh.....but funny.Dak n dunk or is it dink n dak?
You’re one of the know-nothings I was referring to earlier. Don’t hurt yourself trying to understand this sport.Ummm....Dak's been on the team 5 years now......when does all his 'greatness' start????
You don’t give up a top 12 QB either.8-12 is what I see most say... and that's in a era where a lot of top 10 QBs are retiring. So it's not universal.
If you aren't convinced a QB can get you a SB, you should be shopping. No guarantee you find him but you gotta look. Maybe Dak could win one. But there is a lot of doubt that he can carry a team against top competition.
You're going to get Rockport on a tear again. He insists that 40m doesn't equal 40m when it comes to calculating cap space. I'll admit I don't understand how that is calculated, and frankly I don't care. But he seems to feel he's the expert there and will insult anyone who claims that a 40m contract will count 40m against the cap.
we don't care, dak deserves it. who cares if we never win as long as dak is paid. you troll40M is an average. Dallas can give him a huge signing bonus and spread that out over 5 years........ they can structure the contract so it doesn't sting for a year or 2 but that's just kicking the can down the road. This is what happened to Houston. They went "all in" and signed D Watson to a huge contract whose teeth didn't really sink in until 2021. Their plan didn't work and now they can't rebuild the team with that contract weighing them down.
We have too many issues to address to go "all in" this next season and re-sign Dak to a huge contract that gives a year or 2 of cap relief. We literally have 1 good player in our secondary at the moment.
So they didn't take him because they thought he was what was left over? They specifically took him because they knew they could "build a team around him".I don't agree. They did have a plan and Lynch and Cook were all part of the same plan. A lot of people call out Lynch and Cook but they were better prospects, then Dak. They didn't go to an All Pro team where all the stars lined up. If they had, who knows what might have happened. Dak started from day one that season so all of this, only when stuff amounts to nothing. He was the starter day one of his rookie season.
But the plan was always to draft a guy that you could build around. Romo was never the long term plan but at that point, he was the starter that might get you a championship and the Bridge.
You still don't get that a defense matters... do you?
Yes he's 1-2 in the playoffs, but you need a defense to compete in the playoffs otherwise we will certainly be bounced sooner if not later.
You’re one of the know-nothings I was referring to earlier. Don’t hurt yourself trying to understand this sport.
Its a Championship so certainly you need a team playing well as a whole.You don’t give up a top 12 QB either.
Top 12 QBs can win a Super Bowl with the right pieces around them. It’s been proven over and over and over again in this league. Certainly, but it is MUCH harder. The game is designed so that great QB's allow you more margin for error than average QB's. But when you say its been proven over & over that is an exagerration. Since 2000, Dilfer, Flacco, Eli twice & Peyton in Denver are the only winners that you could argue weren't top 10 QB's they year they won. Of those Flacco & Eli clearly played like a top QB during the playoffs. Otherwise, its a list of the elite QB's.
Incidentally, it’s also been proven that the most elite QBs ALSO need a great team around them to win a Super Bowl. So there’s that.
So they didn't take him because they thought he was what was left over? They specifically took him because they knew they could "build a team around him".
That's not how I remember the draft selection going. If you have some quotes and sources....?
{shrug}.
The difference there is that Coach Landry wasn't afraid to bring in a Staubach to compete. This team would never do that. See, that's the real problem with all of that. Morton was a good QB and he proved that in Denver by getting them to the Super Bowl but Staubach is arguably one of the greatest players to ever play in the NFL. I would hardly compare the two situations. It's not fair to Dak, if nothing else. But I do agree with you, it can't be done if you don't have the resources to build the team around him. I too, believe that.
The point that I was trying to make (I admit poorly) is that there is a damn big difference between a damn good QB and a real winning QB’s who win Super Bowls like Staubach, Bradshaw, Montana, Brady, et al.
I want Dak to be great but posting stats like many won't make him great. Look at Brady's stats in his last Super Bowl win, they were very average at best but with the game on the line, he was fabulous.