No, I never said that at all. If I understand NYC, his issue with McFadden is his running style, and how it translates into the Pros. Your point about him only being a Soph. and improving as he gets older is what I was trying to address. While I think your correct in certain aspects, I don't think it will change what NYC has issue with and that is the running style of McFadden.
Myself, I don't worry about his strength to much but I do worry about his upright running style and the fact that I don't see a lot of wiggle in his game. He appears to be more of a one cut back IMO. He has speed, no question but I don't see a lot of Reggie Bush in him. Whomever compared him to Dickerson, to me, was closer to the mark. In fact, a guy we currently have on the team that kinda reminds me of him is Tyson Thompson. He has the same kind of upright style and tremedous acceleration. McFadden is probably a tougher runner, IMO, but the do have simular running styles, from what I've seen, thus far.