Do you want the Cowboys to sign Dak Prescott to another long term deal?

zrinkill · Thursday at 9:28 AM

HailstateCowboy said:
Jerry Jones and co. just suck when it comes to roster / salary cap management.

We finally agree on something.

HailstateCowboy · Thursday at 9:30 AM

zrinkill said:
We finally agree on something.

Good deal.

kskboys · Thursday at 9:32 AM

Just because it is extremely difficult to find a good QB does not mean you should overpay one who isn't getting it done. I was just reading the latest coach's polls about Dak, and he was put in the tier 2 category, the one where he doesn't put the team on his back and will them to win. That's almost word for word what they said.

After reading the article, I'm just not sure there is huge money out there for Dak on another team. There are only so many Clev Browns and DALL Cowboys out there who will overpay a player.

zrinkill · Thursday at 10:02 AM

kskboys said:
Just because it is extremely difficult to find a good QB does not mean you should overpay one who isn't getting it done. I was just reading the latest coach's polls about Dak, and he was put in the tier 2 category, the one where he doesn't put the team on his back and will them to win. That's almost word for word what they said.

After reading the article, I'm just not sure there is huge money out there for Dak on another team. There are only so many Clev Browns and DALL Cowboys out there who will overpay a player.

This.

HailstateCowboy · Thursday at 10:09 AM

kskboys said:
Just because it is extremely difficult to find a good QB does not mean you should overpay one who isn't getting it done. I was just reading the latest coach's polls about Dak, and he was put in the tier 2 category, the one where he doesn't put the team on his back and will them to win. That's almost word for word what they said.

After reading the article, I'm just not sure there is huge money out there for Dak on another team. There are only so many Clev Browns and DALL Cowboys out there who will overpay a player.

You can say that all day. But everyone knows the Cowboys will always catch hell because everyone hates "America's Team". The talking heads, other coaches and players. Whatever. The fact is this - Dak is absolutely a top 10 QB. I mean just look at his stats for last year. And we've already determined that the GB game was a sh!tshow by the entire team - not just Dak. So he is a "tier 2" QB? You know as well as I do that he is not. Speaking of polls - did you see the poll this week from NFL players saying Josh Allen is the most overrated QB in the league. That's all you need as evidence about the validity of polls.

There are teams out there that would absolutely pay Dak 60 million a year and would have a drunk fest celebrating that deal. So we will see what Jerry wants to do when the time comes. Again, the question I ask and the one no one can answer. If you let Dak walk, who in the ever living hell do you bring in that gives you a better chance at success? Regardless of whether you can bring someone in for 20 million less a year and spend that money elsewhere. Who? If you look closely, the options will scare the sh!t out of you.

zrinkill · Thursday at 10:11 AM

HailstateCowboy said:
If you let Dak walk, who in the ever living hell do you bring in that gives you a better chance at success?

Someone that can get us the number one pick in the draft so we can have our pick of QB's

HailstateCowboy · Thursday at 10:19 AM

zrinkill said:
Someone that can get us the number one pick in the draft so we can have our pick of QB's

So let me get this right. So we have a top 10 franchise QB and you are willing to tank the team for a year or two hoping that you land a QB in the freaking draft? Are you kidding me? Go back and look at the top QBs taken in the draft and see what the batting average has been. I have high expectations for this past draft QBs - but if you take the last 10 or 15, you would be much better off with Dak than 80% of those guys. Prove me wrong. Your strategy would lead to at least a 50/50 chance you send Dallas into the sh!thole for a decade.

zrinkill · Thursday at 10:23 AM

HailstateCowboy said:
Prove me wrong.

They have been doing it for 29 years

HailstateCowboy said:
send Dallas into the sh!thole for a decade.

They cannot send them where they are already at.

All those great regular season wins we have had with Romo and now Dak does not matter if they cannot get it done in the playoffs.

Tired of seeing this any time we face a good team.

Bullflop · Thursday at 10:26 AM

If truth be told, I'm strongly in favor of the Cowboys drafting a QB early in the 2025 draft. :flagwave:

Dak has performed well, albeit, although a bit limited. It's forgivable, in lieu of a true GM. :huh:

I honestly feel that the combination of a half-assed FO and lack of a sound philosophy hurt us!

big dog cowboy · Thursday at 10:36 AM

Just checked on this and see 25 votes for 'Do not care' and find that extremely puzzling.

HailstateCowboy · Thursday at 10:38 AM

Bullflop said:
If truth be told, I'm strongly in favor of the Cowboys drafting a QB early in the 2025 draft.
Dak has performed well, albeit, although a bit limited. It's forgivable, in lieu of a true GM.

How are you going to do that when Dallas will win 10 or 11 games this year? Dallas is not going to be in the running for the top draft QBs in 2025. You want to win playoff games or go to the SB in the next few years? Get a legit GM and have Jerry stay out of everything except the check writing. That is the only winning formula.

HailstateCowboy · Thursday at 10:40 AM

big dog cowboy said:
Just checked on this and see 25 votes for 'Do not care' and find that extremely puzzling.

It's probably not that they don't care. It's because they realize there isn't a clear cut option that works. The Cowboy issues are much deeper than the starting QB.

Bullflop · Thursday at 10:51 AM

HailstateCowboy said:
How are you going to do that when Dallas will win 10 or 11 games this year? Dallas is not going to be in the running for the top draft QBs in 2025. You want to win playoff games or go to the SB in the next few years? Get a legit GM and have Jerry stay out of everything except the check writing. That is the only winning formula.

If you think the Cowboys might get another GM to replace Jerry when he's the one in control, I have a bridge in California to sell you! :grin:

There's anything but a guarantee that this team will win 10 or 11 games, when the upcoming schedule is one that will challenge any team.

If you know someone with the wherewithal to prevent Jerry from staying on as the Cowboys GM in the upcoming year, good luck with that.

zrinkill · Thursday at 11:45 AM

HailstateCowboy said:
The Cowboy issues are much deeper than the starting QB.

I agree with that too ....... but his playoff performances are a problem.

Only father time will solve our biggest problem.

RodeoJake · Thursday at 11:56 AM

I can't say I fall into any of the 3 options for sure. Dak has the talent, but against talented teams he seems to get lost in his own head when things start going badly. He should be gathering his teammates and pumping them up instead sitting by himself with his head down. That old saying about when the going gets tough...comes to mind.

triplets_93 · Thursday at 11:57 AM

zrinkill said:
The difference is ........ That D coordinator (who decided to play a completely different style of defense for that one game) is no longer here.

Dak is still here and wants to be paid the highest ever .......... for "the brotherhood"

Dak is so noble!
They'll be a Statue of him somewhere.

triplets_93 · Thursday at 12:02 PM

HailstateCowboy said:
It's probably not that they don't care. It's because they realize there isn't a clear cut option that works. The Cowboy issues are much deeper than the starting QB.

The Jonses don't really care.
What they do care about, the Bottom Line, it will be strong regardless of whether Dak, or some other person is the QB.
Jerry, always selling the sizzle. And he's a Master of it.

HailstateCowboy · Thursday at 12:06 PM

zrinkill said:
I agree with that too ....... but his playoff performances are a problem.

Only father time will solve our biggest problem.

Yep - and that's unfortunate. And Jones Jr. may take this thing for another 30 years.

dmq · Thursday at 12:43 PM

My opinion has changed on this. I say yes because he beats up on the NFC East and it would be hard to replace his production in the draft. Obviously, we haven’t been able to find a replacement yet.

HailstateCowboy · Thursday at 12:48 PM

Bullflop said:
If you think the Cowboys might get another GM to replace Jerry when he's the one in control, I have a bridge in California to sell you!

There's anything but a guarantee that this team will win 10 or 11 games, when the upcoming schedule is one that will challenge any team.

If you know someone with the wherewithal to prevent Jerry from staying on as the Cowboys GM in the upcoming year, good luck with that.

Not saying there will be a new GM or Jerry will be leaving. Just saying that is where the primary problem lays by a mile - not with Prescott as your QB.

Do you want the Cowboys to sign Dak Prescott to another long term deal?

Do you want the Cowboys to sign Dak Prescott to another long term deal?

No

Yes

Do not care

Cowboy Fan

Member

Well-Known Member

Cowboy Fan

Member

Cowboy Fan

Member

Cowboy Fan

Cowboys Diehard

THE BIG DOG

Member

Member

Cowboys Diehard

Cowboy Fan

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Member

If I'm so pretty, why am I available?

Member