Not really sure what this even means. Skeptical about what exactly? How about when the team wins and beats a quality opponent, then they earn some respect? There have been enough blunders, bad trades, bad picks, bad losses, etc, to warrant some skepticism, as well as some very legitimate questions/concerns.
For example, the evil media hates us; they're against us; they just say negative things about the team to get "clicks". That is, until we beat the SB champs and bully on the NFL block. Next thing you know, the team is getting some love and are even ranked #1 in some people's power ranking. That's how it works.
I understand the frustration. And we all understand the team has floundered for a long time. Objectively stating the problems which includes those that are on the 'negative' side of the ledger are fine.
You and others don't have a monopoly on being frustrated. And by and large other than the obvious most of the negative posters don't have a lot of clues about the Xs and Os associated with those negatives. Most see a negative play and their response is predictable, loud and well....simple to be nice. Those you call homers see the problems and many try to see inside them as best as a fan can.
There aren't any homers nor any realists. There are just fans. But there are those who wish to be as negative as possible and some of them are not fans....not of the Cowboys....just themselves.
I'll tell you the same thing I harped on for awhile until it quietened down. You are welcome to your opinion up to the point all we hear is one negative post after another esp if they are blatantly trollish in appearance. You can be negative and still be constructive. A reasonable person can tell the difference.
One final thought for all. This site belongs to the owner. But he doesn't really 'own' anything unless this site is inhabited by enough Dallas Cowboys' fans. So the 'real' owners of this site are the members....every single one of you. The members make this site. And although the staff tries very hard to make it a reasonable environment for you all, only YOU, and I mean all of you, can make this the kind of site I know most of you want. So speak up, nicely, about your team both positive and negative, but make this a great site.