It's not out of bounds to question whether, at his point, Henson will make it or not.
But, to write him off at this point is typical fan reaction that shows they know nothing about developing an NFL QB. These same fans would have written off good QBs like Trent Green and Matt Hasslebeck after their first couple of seasons in the league.
I like Henson a lot and am pulling for him as hard as I can for one simple reason. We MUST have a good, young QB for this franchise to move to the next level. If we don't get the next good, young QB we will remain nothing more than a middle of the road franchise.
I do fear whether Henson's unorthodox mechanics will limit his ability to be consistently effective in the NFL. The fact is he has a very good arm, good size and athleticism, but his passes tend to sail on him and he's not consistently accurate due to his inconsistent footwork and mechanics.
We can try and ignore this problem and act like it's not a big deal, but as any QB coach and analyst will tell you, mechanics are very, very important in a QB's ultimate success.
As for Romo, that's a joke. The guy is an undersized, average arm, former UFA who hasn't taken a snap in 3 years and is a better golfer than he is a QB. If anyone thinks he is our future, I'm sorry to say they are living in a dreamworld. The guy is a career back-up at best.
As for the rookie from Yale, I am intrigued by him a little bit, but come on, he's not taking a roster spot from Henson.