firehawk350
Active Member
- Messages
- 2,108
- Reaction score
- 0
DragonCowboy said:buddy, read the rest of my posts. You didn't understand what I was getting at.
MB3 > Betts, are you kidding me? We're talking about running out of the LOS, not kick returning.
Under what circumstance is MB3 that much better??? Marion Barber has better totals, but the averages remain about the same. The reason for this being is JJ hasn't proven he can carry the load whereas Portis has proven he's more then capable. So are we to fault the back-up for the starter not being fragile? On averages, it's about even with 3.8 vs. 3.9 YPC with Barber having the slight edge. So it's roughly a draw, with a slight advantage going to Barber. Then you bring in #3 and Cartwright is EASILY the better #3. The only bit of real sustained action he saw is 100 yards in one of the games (forgot which one) which easily beat out Thompson who only got 149 yards all season on twice as many carries as Cartwright (199 yards). So Cartwright is easily much better then Thompson. Anyways, we win 2 out of 3 positions in a head to head. Combine that with a better o-line and you can see why most people would rank our RB corps above yours.