Manwiththeplan
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 14,300
- Reaction score
- 7,800
Those young soldiers were way too nice for GoT....... I kept waiting for them to turn..... but they were just young boys sent off to fight someone else's war
Plus she was wrong....... the biggest mistake Rob made was beheading the Karstark elder..... that is why the Umbers and Karstarks betrayed Jon to beign with
Jon knows they need every man and woman united to fight the WW....... when the 2 children stood up to pledge their loyalty it made Jon look noble with his decision
Odds are, letting Lord Karstark live, still would have resulted in the red wedding occurring. In fact, the Umbers were slaughtered there as well. Really had more to do with marrying Talisa, had he not married her, then even as despicable as Walder Frey was, he would have still had a very large portion of his forces and could have continued after the Lannisters.