Is Dak now the 2nd Best QB in the NFC

[Hadenough]

Stafford winning a Superbowl doesn't vault him into any new stratosphere. Eli won 2 and he's mediocre.

Tell Brady Eli was mediocre. Eli was a slightly better than average QB except when he got into the playoffs. The dude played great. His brother Payton was great in regular season but wasn't the same in the playoffs.

 

[CowboyFrog]

Rodgers and Stafford have a combined 2 Super Bowl appearances.

So the people who are like: "everyone except Rodgers and Stafford sucks in the NFC", I'd say there's a huge likelihood that the one who plays in the Super Bowl next year from the NFC is someone who sucks. (according to this board)

But come on you will hear how the teams other than the SB ones were just not good....and then that same poster will be like "Why does Dak need all the talent to win"...its really fun to watch the logic here.

 

[BermyStar]

Tell Brady Eli was mediocre. Eli was a slightly better than average QB except when he got into the playoffs. The dude played great. His brother Payton was great in regular season but wasn't the same in the playoffs.

Doubt Brady would care as much about Eli as he would the Defensive Line, but I only watched the games.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Tell Brady Eli was mediocre. Eli was a slightly better than average QB except when he got into the playoffs. The dude played great. His brother Payton was great in regular season but wasn't the same in the playoffs.

What? He wasn’t great yet he has the same number of SBs as his brother lol.

 

[CowboyFrog]

Tell Brady Eli was mediocre. Eli was a slightly better than average QB except when he got into the playoffs. The dude played great. His brother Payton was great in regular season but wasn't the same in the playoffs.

I mean is your argument really that Eli was the reason they won? Do you think you would get one expert to say "Yeah I would take Eli over Payton" if he was starting a football team? If so ok but i think your choosing a very tough road to win an argument.

 

[LACowboysFan1]

Tell Brady Eli was mediocre. Eli was a slightly better than average QB except when he got into the playoffs. The dude played great. His brother Payton was great in regular season but wasn't the same in the playoffs.

Oh Eli played great?

Well let's check the stats:
Giants scored 21 and 17 pts.

First SB - Eli 55%, 2 tds, 1 int. 2 fumbles, 4 yds rushing. Wow, that's great? Nope.
Second SB - Eli 75%, 296 yards, 1 td. 1 rush for -1 yds. Good percentage and yards, but with only 1 td he didn't contribute much to the scoring. That's great? Nope again.

In 2007 the Pats scored 67 tds in the regular season, nearly 6,600 yards. Yet only scored 14 pts in the SB,

Eli didn't beat the Pats, his defense did....

 

[Hadenough]

What? He wasn’t great yet he has the same number of SBs as his brother lol.

Well that SB with the Broncos was evidence he was done. Played poor but that defense wasn't going to be denied.

 

[CT Dal Fan]

Eli Manning was garbage basically his entire career. An inconsistent turnover machine. If he didn't have the last name "Manning" his career would have gone down the Rex Grossman path. But the Giants saw greatness that simply wasn't there; and having a dominant defense carry Eli to two Super Bowls led New York to keep him longer than they should have.

 

[kumizi]

Rodgers, Murray, Prescott, and Stafford in that order.

OOOOFAH

 

[Hadenough]

Eli Manning was garbage basically his entire career. An inconsistent turnover machine. If he didn't have the last name "Manning" his career would have gone down the Rex Grossman path. But the Giants saw greatness that simply wasn't there; and having a dominant defense carry Eli to two Super Bowls led New York to keep him longer than they should have.

He was garbage until they would sneak into the playoffs. Knocked off one of the most dominant teams of the Era too.

 

[CowboyoWales]

Wilson to the Broncos, Brady gone, what's your thoughts, I'm not sure it even means anything!!

Dak's already been demoted at least two places since the thread was started. He's dropping off like one of his passes.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Well that SB with the Broncos was evidence he was done. Played poor but that defense wasn't going to be denied.

You could say the same thing about Eli. He too needed that great defensive line to get to the quarterback.

 

[Hadenough]

You could say the same thing about Eli. He too needed that great defensive line to get to the quarterback.

But he had a nice run of road wins throwing 8 tds to 1 int

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

But he had a nice run of road wins throwing 8 tds to 1 int

He did. He made some key timely throws. I take nothing away from him he earned those rings but even saying that he had a mediocre career.

 

[lwehlers]

prescott just went down the list of top nfc qbs with brady back again.

 

[5Stars]

Wilson to the Broncos, Brady gone, what's your thoughts, I'm not sure it even means anything!!

Fake news, the hour changed today. He is what he is, not going to get any better...clock just changed.

 

[Alexander]

3rd best. Brady is back.

 

[Captain-Crash]

brett hundley is the same guy as dak. so i guess brett is number 3 too?

 

[ICP]

Depending on what happens once free agency, the draft and trades are completed Dak might not even be the 2nd best QB in the NFC East

 

[Mannix]

So now he is better than Stafford?

NEVER has been better than Stafford.....and I'd take Garapalo over Dak any day of any week.