He's not that bad. Without Smith, it looks even worse. Fans can harp on penalties, but officiating has been awful and some of those calls were ridiculous. It's happening all over the NFL, specifically on the O line. All the numbers are up.
All I care about is this season and the staff isn't moving him to tackle. If he was as bad as some here suggest, McGovern would have replaced him. I trust the staff more than I trust the casual fan. If Smith was ready to go, I could see Collins in at RG and Steele at RT.