Zaxor said:
it may surprise you that the oline sucks only a little if you get Bledsoe out of there instead of sucking massively with him in there
I don't understand how you can say this. Bledsoe was putting up Pro Bowl numbers and people had him at the top of the league, how much he was unappreciated, yada. Then Flo goes down and you know the rest.
If you give any special QB like Aikman, Staubach, or any HOF QB the weapons he needs around him which includes good RBs, WRs, TEs and the OL to make it all work then you have a special offense and likey a special team even if the defense is just above adequate and not even great.
I think Bledsoe is a special QB. Marino never won it all but he's one of the best QBs ever. Bledsoe might be thought of completely differently if he had never gotten injured and let Brady get the ball. I believe Bledsoe would still be in NE and have the accolades Brady has. Brady would likely be a very good to great QB somewhere else depending on the weapons he had beside him including obviously a good defense.
If you want to say Bledsoe is not a very mobile QB I highly agree. He does step up in the pocket and is a very good QB. But don't think he can beat the defensive line at times and still make a play. He's not McNair or McNabb. He's not a Vick or even a Quincy Carter from that aspect. But most winning teams have an OL that can protect the QB.
Why do you think we collapsed from 7-3 to 9-7? Teams figured out how to stop the offense and it was easy. Just overrun the OL and make Dallas win with the big play. And we could not do that with one or two receivers due to having to be in maximum protection; especially with no run either. And despite that we still were in every game except one and that games outcome was due to turnovers. What a great job Parcells and Zimmer did to keep this flawed team in it to the end.
The collapse of this team was caused by the breakdown of the OL. Glenn, Key, Witten, JJ, Barber and Bledsoe didn't fail because of their lack of ability.
There are reasons why Elway, Marino, Tarkento and others were considered "not great" and "flawed" because they never won it all (Elway finally threw off the burden just as Dallas threw off not a great franchise with the 71 team). Bledsoe is in the same league now. Great numbers, great arm with all the throws but can't win.
That's a mistake. IMO we are fortunate to have a big league QB who can win with his arm. We need a good OL and a safety along with improved play from our LBs with perhaps a very good vet LB thrown in there to be a very good team. This team could not only make the playoffs with those problems addressed but even surprise people and win a SB. I expect we are two years away from being a legitimate SB contender but.....
Bledsoe is good enough for us. We need to address other problems. Just my 19 cents.