Manwiththeplan
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 14,268
- Reaction score
- 7,763
1. First of all, Jordan retired and came back to win three more. Two of his prime years were gone. Even Payton said he was 'easier' to guard when he came back, but he still won three. He rose and stayed on top. Lebron on the other lost after Cleveland after getting swept, both to the Celtics and Orlando. He clearly saw the writing on the wall. And the argument that the organization did nothing is not really sustained, simply by the fact that both season before he left Cleveland they were the number one team with over 60 plus wins. If Lebron made the finals and lost both those years one could argue the case, but he lost both times in the Eastern conference.
I'm very much aware of Jordan winning 3, retiring and winning 3 more and most of this has nothing to do with any of my points. And while I wouldn't argue that Cleveland did nothing, they clearly mad bad move after bad move. Allowing Carlos Boozer to hit free agency (I know this was an odd situation, but it could've been avoided), poor trades and poor draft picks every year. Did he have any player comparable to Scottie Pippen in Cleveland? What about James Worthy, Kevin McHale, Joe Dumars? Cleveland mad the finals purely because a weak eastern conference.
2. Second, if you actually look at Lebron's stats, his numbers drop when the play-offs come around. For example, 27 points a game average is below his regular season average. These are actual realities that people simply ignore, and they choose to go after obscure stats. Jordan's rises in play-offs and hits it's peak the finals. The NBA final averages aren't even close.
he averaged 27.1 ppg this season and 27.5 in the playoffs. knock him for not upping his game if you want, but don't say his numbers drop. Only thing down is assists.
3. Jordan played top teams, with established HoF in their prime, including Stockton and Malone and a Seattle team with Payton, a HoF PG, Kemp and guys like Schrempf and McMillan. They were definitely not cake-walk teams. Seattle beat a whole bunch of stack teams and their defense was absolutely phenomenal that year. The Blazers were not cake-walks either, breezing through their play-off runs. Plus, Jordan beat the defending champion Pistons at their peak.
Pistons weren't at their peak in 91' in large part thanks to not having Rick Mahorn and other role players like Lambieer and Aguire not being nearly as good. Some of this was offset by the improvement in Rodman, but not all. That Seattle team didn't stand a chance, they had a lot of good players, but they didn't have any great players imo. Payton had yet to peak, in 96' and Kemp was not much better than Blake Griffen is now. Now, none of these or the other teams were cake walks, but outside of Utah, I don't think any of them would be championship teams now.
4. If you take stats like 45 points per game in the playoffs, Jordan had in five what Lebron has his whole career, in this era. he has 7, along with Iverson. Wilt is at number 2 with 8 and Jordan is at 25 games with those numbers.
I honestly don't know what you're saying. How can you count the times anyone averaged 45 points per game? Do you mean 45 point performances? Either way, Lebron is not the scorer that Jordan was. You'll never hear me say other wise.
5. If one argues that Jordan had a cake-walk, Lebron has had it way easier. In a league that Lebron took his Cleveland team to the finals, people ignore the fact that both Dwight and Allen Iverson carried their teams to the finals in a pathetic Eastern conference. In fact, Howard, whose offensive game is utterly lacking and is an absolute nut-case, beat the 60 plus win team of Lebron. Allen Iverson's second leading scorer scored less than both Lebron's second and third leading scorer. This year, Lebron played the Bobcats essentially without Al Jefferson, meaning the worst team in the league a year prior, an aging Nets teams without Brook Lopez and a utterly-overrated Pacers team with a Center shooting multiple zero and 2 point games this playoffs. The West batters and bruises itself until it reaches the team. Plus, Jordan only played in one game seven in any of his championship runs, while it's a trademark of the Heat team.
Again, my intent wasn't to say Jordan had cake walks to the finals. There just wasn't a comparable team, in large part because they were so good. And I even said, in the east at least, there is also no comparable team to Miami, so......not sure why we need to rehash this.
6. This is without even taking into account stats like seven game series where the league has extended the number of games, giving more chances for things like play-off points.
I don't ever use totals in an argument because it skews towards games played. Also don't compare player ages, since it favors straight to HS players (i'll compare ages then)
7. If you look at Lebron's championship stats from 26-29 and compare them to Jordan's in the playoffs his first three championships, it's not even close. Jordan for example has 8 PPG more than him, beats Lebron in steals and assists, and the only thing Lebron bests him in rebounds by an insignificant margin and three point shooting, the latter only because he took way more. And as I said before, 3 point shooting has changed dramatically.
Since you didn't provide stats, I'll have to look this up when I get home, but I'd be curious to see how insignificant the rebounding edge is, versus Jordan's edge in assists and steals, since you didn't refer to them as insignificant. Again, points I'd concede any day of the week.
It's just the reality that rules were changed to create more Jordan's. Hand-checking is the single-biggest advantage a defender had against an offensive player, directing that player to a direction one wanted to go. What your talking about is a totally different game. You have 3 point shooters hanging out in the corners nowadays creating all this space. Grant was not joking when he said Jordan could average 40.
I'll have to look it up later, but across the league I don't think teams score as much as they did in the 80s, when the game was more about the fast break