NFC East top 10

[MarionBarberThe4th]

(Only 2 more months)
Taking everything into account. Injuries(McNabb) age(Strahan) miscellaneous (T.O)

1. Westbrook
2. Romo
3. Portis
4. Newman
5. Ware
6. Osi Umenyiora
7. Shawn Andrews
8. Chris Snee
9. Laron Landry
10. Mcnabb

 

[elitetrackstar]

1. S.Andrews 2. Portis 2. Dawkins 2. Westbrook 5. Trotter 5. Ware 7. Umenyiora 8. T.Owens 8. Newman 10. Witten

 

[tunahelper]

How can you have Landry above anyone when he has not played a down in the NFL?

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

How can you have Landry above anyone when he has not played a down in the NFL?

Would you rather have him for the next 10 years or Dawkins for the next 2?

 

[CrazyCowboy]

(Only 2 more months)
Taking everything into account. Injuries(McNabb) age(Strahan) miscellaneous (T.O)

1. Westbrook
2. Romo
3. Portis
4. Newman
5. Ware
6. Osi Umenyiora
7. Shawn Andrews
8. Chris Snee
9. Laron Landry
10. Mcnabb

To make it legit.....T.O. has to be in it.

 

[superpunk]

This is pretty tough to do - because you start to make a list, and it's basically Cowboys and Eagles players, and Osi Umenyiora.

I'd go McNabb, Ware, and Westbrook for top three.

After that, some amalgamation of Andrews, Romo, Witten, Newman, Dawkins, Snee, and Umenyiora.

 

[cobra]

1. Portis
2. Taylor
3. Moss
4. Cooley
5. Samuels
6. Ware
7. Springs
8. McNabb
9. Betts
10. Westbrook






Oh, sorry. I thought this was ES.

 

[AtlCB]

1. Portis
2. Taylor
3. Moss
4. Cooley
5. Samuels
6. Ware
7. Springs
8. McNabb
9. Betts
10. Westbrook






Oh, sorry. I thought this was ES.

If this were ES, you would get flamed for having Ware, McNabb, and Westbrook in your list.

 

[cobra]

If this were ES, you would get flamed for having Ware, McNabb, and Westbrook in your list.

No, no. See, their inclusion would be proof there that I am *not* a homer. The responses would be "I would have had all Commanders but I'm a homer; your list looks pretty realist and objective as proved by the presence of Ware, McNabb and Westbrook."

 

[Vintage]

LOL @ people criticising ES for being homer-ific.

Pot. Meet Mr. Kettle.

 

[AsthmaField]

No, no. See, their inclusion would be proof there that I am *not* a homer. The responses would be "I would have had all Commanders but I'm a homer; your list looks pretty realist and objective as proved by the presence of Ware, McNabb and Westbrook."

Bullseye. That's their MO alright.

 

[Green28]

Little twist here...All Under-30 team

Skins
Cooley
Moss
Portis
Taylor
Washington (edit)
Campbell
Rocky?????? (edit)
(Landry)

Boys
Romo
Witten
Ware
Newman
R. Williams
McBriar (edit)
Carpenter?????
(Spencer)

Giants
Osi
Shockey
Eli??
(Ross)

Eagles
Sheppard
Brown
Westbrook
Andrews

 

[Vintage]

Little twist here...All Under-30 team

Skins
Cooley
Moss
Portis
Taylor
Campbell
(Landry)

Boys
Romo
Witten
Ware
Newman
Carpenter?
(Spencer)

Giants
Osi
Shockey
Eli?

Eagles
Sheppard
Brown
Westbrook
Andrews

What has Carpenter done to prove being on the all under 30 team of that list?

Marcus Washington isn't 30 yet....I'd have him on it over Carpenter.

 

[Green28]

What has Carpenter done to prove being on the all under 30 team of that list?

Marcus Washington isn't 30 yet....I'd have him on it over Carpenter.

Carpenter was my olive branch. I'll add MW.

 

[superpunk]

You pretty much listed every team's starters or potential starters - under 30.

Bravo on the age research. Where's Isaiah Stanback?

 

[cobra]

How come Matt McBriar is not on the all NFC Under 30 list?????

 

[Green28]

You pretty much listed every team's starters or potential starters - under 30.

Bravo on the age research. Where's Isaiah Stanback?

Not even close, friend. I listed Pro-bowl potential players under 30.

 

[Green28]

How come Matt McBriar is not on the all NFC Under 30 list?????

Added him. He's great.

 

[Vintage]

Not even close, friend. I listed Pro-bowl potential players under 30.

He was joking.

He doesn't think Stanback should actually be included.

Also, I know you are speculating....but none of Landy/McIntosh/Carpenter/Spencer should be on the list. If its all under 30 teams, none have shown enough to warrant selection to the list.

 

[superpunk]

Not even close, friend. I listed Pro-bowl potential players under 30.

That's clearly why Campbell, Landry, Spencer, Carpenter and Eli were included in this list.

Your all under-30 team has one defensive lineman, 3 QBs, and 2 offensive linemen. Just some random collection of average to stellar players who happen to be under 30.