NFC East top 10

[BouncingCheese]

Now I see why Campbell had such a hard time completing passes.

WOW... That is embarassing. I can't say much else besides that...

You sucks brandon lloyd.

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

Just wanted to bump to see how things changed (not a lot)

You can delete this if you want to de-clutter

 

[jterrell]

1. Ware
2. Osi
3. Romo
4. Westbrook
5. Witten
6. Eli
7. T.O.
8. Portis
9. TNew
10. Burress

Bottom line is the Giants own a super Bowl and you have to credit Eli and the Giants DL with their play in the playoffs. I left McNabb off because his injuries seem to limit him for stretches of each season and that knocks Philly out of the playoffs.

5 Cowboys
3 Giants
1 Eagle
1 Skin

That basically jives with the regular season finish.
Romo was not 3rd best at the end of the year or into the playoffs but he was the best overall player for much of the season so I can not drop him too far.

Any list is arguable but imho these 10 guys will all have Hall of Fame shots if they stay healthy and contribute at their current level long term.

 

[DallasDW00ds0n]

1. Ware
2. Westbrook
3. T. Cole
4. T.O.
5. Romo/Eli (Ill probably get flammed for that, but Eli did win it all)
6. Portis (anyone else feel like Portis has been a little off his game recently?)
7. Burress
8. Samuel
9. Landry
10. T. New

I think osi is a little bit overrated, theres no doubt his sacks were padded by the eagles game; bc winston justice is the biggest slob of all OLmen in the league. I just think were gonna see it this year without Strahan that Osi slips up a bit.

And Mcflab is a joke now. They dont even talk about him, all you hear Eagles fans talking about is Kolb.

 

[BourbonBalz]

LOL @ people criticising ES for being homer-ific.

Pot. Meet Mr. Kettle.

Every site has a bit of homerism on it, but there's more of it on ES than the rest of the sports sites on the web combined. And I'm not just talking about NFL sites. It includes all possible sports sites period.

 

[Pottsville Maroons]

K
1. Akers
2. Gramatica
3. Tynes
4. Suisham

I may be missing something, but where's Folk on the list?

 

[dargonking999]

I may be missing something, but where's Folk on the list?

That post was a little old. Back then Folk was fighting to oust Gramatica

 

[Redskins2008]

I am changing the format a little. I am ranking the top 4 players at each position. I count the O-line and D-line as units. I didn't include FB, because honestly, there aren't enough valid canidates to warrant a list. I will try not to be a homer with this list:

QB
1. McNabb
2. Romo
3. Manning
4. Johnson

(Campbell is not better than Brad johnson?)

RB
1. Westbrook
2. Portis
3. Jones
4. Barber III

WR
1. Owens
2. Burress
3. Glenn
4. Moss

(Moss is not better than Glenn)

TE
1. Shockey
2. Witten
3. Cooley
4. Smith

(You got Shockey as the best TE in NFL east? I got cooley and witten better than shockey)

Oline
1. Washington
2. New York
3. Philadelphia
4. Dallas

Dline
1. New York
2. Philadelphia
3. Dallas
4. Washington

LB
1. Ware
2. Fletcher
3. Kiwanuka
4. Trotter

CB
1. Newman
2. Sheppard
3. Madison
4. Henry

FS
1. Dawkins
2. Taylor
3. Hamlin
4. Demps

(I take ST over any FS in nfl east or nfl) R.I.P ST

SS
1. Williams
2. Wilson
3. Considine
4. Landry (default)

(I will not put Williams as number 1 SS in nfl east)
Landry will be number one SS or FS in the nfl east in few more year.

P
1. McBriar
2. Johnson
3. Feagles
4. Frost

K
1. Akers
2. Gramatica
3. Tynes
4. Suisham

overall you did good job

 

[DallasDomination]

overall you did good job

did you miss the part where He has the Dallas Oline at last place?

lost credability by that alone.

 

[dargonking999]

did you miss the part where He has the Dallas Oline at last place?

lost credability by that alone.

No, that was the reason why he did a good job

 

[AMERICAS_FAN]

How can you have Landry above anyone when he has not played a down in the NFL?

Because he's better than Jason Witten who has played on the NFL at a Pro-Bowl level and Felix Jones who will play at a pro-bowl level. Didn't you get that memo from the Dallas Cowboy Haters Union?