I absolutely miss it. It made having a movie night an "event" Get with friends/family, go out, stroll through the video store, grab some snacks, maybe some dinner (or order a pizza), and head home for a cozy movie night. It was great. Sure, the conveinance of just powering on your tv and renting a movie is great, but a movie night just lost some of it's magic. (Be kind. Please rewind!)
Definitely miss some of the simpler times. Though, you do wonder how much nostalgia plays a role?? If you could take a time machine back and spend a week, would you be hating the idea of running up to the video store, renting a VHS, and watching a movie on a tube TV in 240p? lol