Erin Andrews is way hotter so give me Erin Andrews. Simple as that for me.
Pam looked a lot better in her younger days and that surely helped her get the gig in the first place, so I have no issue with the younger, hotter woman replacing her now. That's the business.
Men don't want to look at mediocre-looking, middle-aged women while watching football. There are no mediocre-looking, middle-aged cheerleaders for a reason.
As for who's better at the job... are you serious? They're sideline reporters! They're given info and they report it on TV. You guys act as if they're watching game film and reporting how often the defense is in a cover 3 vs a cover 2. As long as they look good and aren't stuttering on camera, they're doing just fine. Makes no difference if it's a vet like Pam Oliver or a youngster.
And Pam trying to criticize Erin for the Sherman interview is hilarious. Change the subject when you're in the midst of an epic, profanity-less tirade? I'm sure Erin's bosses are patting her on the back, not criticizing her. Sour grapes, Pam.