QB Stats Through Two Years

[Aviano90]

I'd say that's damn good for a 3rd string rookie. Even though you will literally say anything to bash Prescott.

Well, just play by the same rules. If he doesn't think Dak played well against the Packers, so be it. It means that Romo only played well in 1 playoff game and that would be 2009 against Philly. We know all the stupid mistakes he made in 2014 against GB so that high passer rating, dink and dunk performance he put up was worthless as he stalled 3 drives with taking sacks and another by muffing a snap on 3rd down. He wasn't even good against Detroit and is lucky TWill took a short pass and turned it into a long TD or we would lose that game. The increased scrutiny is acceptable, it just goes both ways.

 

[G2]

Well, just play by the same rules. If he doesn't think Dak played well against the Packers, so be it. It means that Romo only played well in 1 playoff game and that would be 2009 against Philly. We know all the stupid mistakes he made in 2014 against GB so that high passer rating, dink and dunk performance he put up was worthless as he stalled 3 drives with taking sacks and another by muffing a snap on 3rd down. He wasn't even good against Detroit and is lucky TWill took a short pass and turned it into a long TD or we would lose that game. The increased scrutiny is acceptable, it just goes both ways.

Speaking of rookie seasons, don't get me started with 2006.

 

[renny]

Total Yards
Aaron Rodgers - 8,995
Peyton Manning - 8,009
Dak Prescott - 7,630
Carson Wentz - 7,534
Tony Romo - 7,345
Dan Marino - 7,332
Tom Brady - 6,780
Drew Brees - 5,627
Joe Montana - 5,532
Roger Staubach - 4,903
Troy Aikman - 4,789

Total TDs
Dan Marino - 71
Aaron Rodgers - 67
Dak Prescott - 57
Tony Romo - 57
Peyton Manning - 54
Carson Wentz - 51
Tom Brady - 48
Roger Staubach - 43
Joe Montana - 38
Drew Brees - 29
Troy Aikman - 21

Completion %
Dak Prescott - 65.2%
Tony Romo - 64.8%
Aaron Rodgers - 64.2%
Joe Montana - 64.0%
Tom Brady - 62.8%
Dan Marino - 62.2%
Carson Wentz - 61.5%
Roger Staubach - 61.4%
Drew Brees - 59.5%
Peyton Manning - 59.3%
Troy Aikman - 55.1%

Yards / Attempt
Roger Staubach - 8.7
Dan Marino - 8.5
Tony Romo - 8.3
Aaron Rodgers - 7.9
Dak Prescott - 7.4
Peyton Manning - 7.1
Joe Montana - 7.0
Carson Wentz - 6.8
Tom Brady - 6.5
Troy Aikman - 6.3
Drew Brees - 6.1

Interceptions
Dak Prescott - 17
Roger Staubach - 19
Aaron Rodgers - 20
Joe Montana - 21
Carson Wentz - 21
Dan Marino - 23
Tom Brady - 26
Drew Brees - 31
Tony Romo - 32
Troy Aikman - 36
Peyton Manning - 43

Passer Rating
Dan Marino - 104.5
Roger Staubach - 98.9
Aaron Rodgers - 98.5
Tony Romo - 96.5
Dak Prescott - 95.5
Carson Wentz - 88.8
Joe Montana - 88.2
Tom Brady - 86.0
Peyton Manning - 80.6
Drew Brees - 73.1
Troy Aikman - 62.0

W/L Record
Dan Marino - 21-4 (84%)
Roger Staubach - 20-4 (83%)
Tony Romo - 19-7 (73%)
Dak Prescott - 22-10 (69%)
Tom Brady - 22-10 (69%)
Joe Montana - 15-8 (65%)
Carson Wentz - 18-11 (62%)
Aaron Rodgers - 17-15 (53%)
Peyton Manning - 16-16 (50%)
Drew Brees - 10-17 (37%)
Troy Aikman - 7-19 (27%)

*sips tea* Mornin’.

He's top 5 in all those categories except 1, but he is always bashed even by Cowboys fans unbelievable. He also has a 65 percent completion rate over the games played.

 

[renny]

Total Yards
Aaron Rodgers - 8,995
Peyton Manning - 8,009
Dak Prescott - 7,630
Carson Wentz - 7,534
Tony Romo - 7,345
Dan Marino - 7,332
Tom Brady - 6,780
Drew Brees - 5,627
Joe Montana - 5,532
Roger Staubach - 4,903
Troy Aikman - 4,789

Total TDs
Dan Marino - 71
Aaron Rodgers - 67
Dak Prescott - 57
Tony Romo - 57
Peyton Manning - 54
Carson Wentz - 51
Tom Brady - 48
Roger Staubach - 43
Joe Montana - 38
Drew Brees - 29
Troy Aikman - 21

Completion %
Dak Prescott - 65.2%
Tony Romo - 64.8%
Aaron Rodgers - 64.2%
Joe Montana - 64.0%
Tom Brady - 62.8%
Dan Marino - 62.2%
Carson Wentz - 61.5%
Roger Staubach - 61.4%
Drew Brees - 59.5%
Peyton Manning - 59.3%
Troy Aikman - 55.1%

Yards / Attempt
Roger Staubach - 8.7
Dan Marino - 8.5
Tony Romo - 8.3
Aaron Rodgers - 7.9
Dak Prescott - 7.4
Peyton Manning - 7.1
Joe Montana - 7.0
Carson Wentz - 6.8
Tom Brady - 6.5
Troy Aikman - 6.3
Drew Brees - 6.1

Interceptions
Dak Prescott - 17
Roger Staubach - 19
Aaron Rodgers - 20
Joe Montana - 21
Carson Wentz - 21
Dan Marino - 23
Tom Brady - 26
Drew Brees - 31
Tony Romo - 32
Troy Aikman - 36
Peyton Manning - 43

Passer Rating
Dan Marino - 104.5
Roger Staubach - 98.9
Aaron Rodgers - 98.5
Tony Romo - 96.5
Dak Prescott - 95.5
Carson Wentz - 88.8
Joe Montana - 88.2
Tom Brady - 86.0
Peyton Manning - 80.6
Drew Brees - 73.1
Troy Aikman - 62.0

W/L Record
Dan Marino - 21-4 (84%)
Roger Staubach - 20-4 (83%)
Tony Romo - 19-7 (73%)
Dak Prescott - 22-10 (69%)
Tom Brady - 22-10 (69%)
Joe Montana - 15-8 (65%)
Carson Wentz - 18-11 (62%)
Aaron Rodgers - 17-15 (53%)
Peyton Manning - 16-16 (50%)
Drew Brees - 10-17 (37%)
Troy Aikman - 7-19 (27%)

*sips tea* Mornin’.

Compare Wentz to those numbers against Prescott.

 

[Kevinicus]

I said his style of play, as far as TOs he didn't have a high rate they just happened at the worst times and were very memorable . He is the only guy I can think of where a player from a division rival goes to social media and blasts him as a choker or he makes his # 1 WR so ticked off that he leaves the game .

But yes you are right this happened at a low rate LOLOL

LOL, Wut? makes his #1 leave the game? Romo never did that. You care about what division rivals post on social media? What?

And they happened at the worst times no more than they did with other QBs. They're memorable (which really, there aren't very many that are), because it's your team and because the media made it out to be something much more than it was. You bought into the false narrative.

 

[Kevinicus]

Yep, sounds equally absurd the second time... I’m sure you were a big hit on the more previously “challenged” board.

What's worse is you actually have people using the hammer/nail smile when referencing his post....There's more than one person that thinks this nonsense.

 

[DFWJC]

LOL, Wut? makes his #1 leave the game? Romo never did that. You care about what division rivals post on social media? What?

And they happened at the worst times no more than they did with other QBs. They're memorable (which really, there aren't very many that are), because it's your team and because the media made it out to be something much more than it was. You bought into the false narrative.

That guy is right on the border of being block worthy. Some real ignorant stuff comes from him on occasion....specifically regarding Tony.
Don't take him seriously.

However, as much I love Romo, it's a hard argument to make if you're saying he is a HOF worthy as Warner. Can't agree with that brother.

 

[Hadenough]

So, we're going to judge a career, heavily, based on 13 and 6 games? Do you see the flaw in that line of thinking?

Kurt Warner had a passer rating over 100 4 times out of 13 (31%). Romo had a passer rating over 100 3 times out of 6 (50%). Side note: Kurt's team won when he had his worst performance (passer rating in the 50's). Romo's team lost when he had his best (over 140).
Romo had a 4:1 TD:Int Ratio. Warner had a 2.2:1 ratio.
Romo never had more than 1 INT (2 total - 1 every 1.5 games) Warner had 3 games with multiple Interceptions, including two with 3 (14 total - 1 every .93 games).
In 6 games - Romo was sacked 22 times.
In 13 games - Warner was sacked 19 times.

Correct me if I'm wrong but didn't Romo have a 6 interception game against Buffalo?

 

[Kevinicus]

Correct me if I'm wrong but didn't Romo have a 6 interception game against Buffalo?

Not in the playoffs. And it was 5.

 

[Hadenough]

Not in the playoffs. And it was 5.

Yeah I couldn't remember but I do remember the Cowboys won that game. I will say Romo was fun to watch up until tgeinjuries then I would cringe every time he took a hit and then watch closely how he was reacting getting up.

 

[Kevinicus]

Yeah I couldn't remember but I do remember the Cowboys won that game. I will say Romo was fun to watch up until tgeinjuries then I would cringe every time he took a hit and then watch closely how he was reacting getting up.

He actually got injured about the same rate throughout his entire career, it's just the last few were of the variety that caused him to miss more time.

 

[DogFace]

If you were using it to define specifically how’d they be the next year after they retired, as we’re doing with Dak. This isn’t his eulogy, this is projecting for 2018.

That’s where I don’t think you’re fully understanding the op. It was meant to show Dak’s career is of to a good start and the two year start is evidence of him likely having a good career.

Anyway, to your point—do you feel taking 1/4 of his career stats, the second half of last season, is a good indicator of how he will likely play this season?

If yes explain why.

 

[OceanPanther]

As we know, stats can be used to prove almost anything etc.. I'd be curious to know,, what was the teams record the year before the QB arrived. How many were true rookies for their first two years used here ,, If some one was an overall number one draft pick, the team that drafted him was probably really really bad, for example Troy Aikman..

 

[Blackrain]

These Romo loving dorks are just here to build up Romo and tear down Dak. Just ignore the idiots. They will never come to terms their hero couldn’t get the job done. Let them live in denial. When Romo gets passed over year after year for the HoF you can get an annual laugh as they whine about it.

I hear ya brother it just gets tiresome hearing them continually trying to magnify his career while they take potshots at Dak Who did nothing but try and do his job well. One of these guys even said Romo was the greatest QB in Cowboy history . What a hoot !!

 

[Blackrain]

Yes, let's pretend that Dak didn't play terribly while the Cowboys fell behind 21-3 despite getting the ball first, didn't throw a momentum-killing interception and stupidly stop the clock at the end of the game. He played a mediocre game at best and Elliott was the reason they came back, not Dak. All of the things Dak "accomplished" during the playoffs? Is that a joke? The only thing he's accomplished is a tie for the worst playoff winning percentage in NFL history: .000. Talk about making no sense.

I guess we should also pretend that Garrett could get the players substituted after a extra week to prepare and Butlers penalty didn't kill a drive .

 

[Aviano90]

I hear ya brother it just gets tiresome hearing them continually trying to magnify his career while they take potshots at Dak Who did nothing but try and do his job well. One of these guys even said Romo was the greatest QB in Cowboy history . What a hoot !!

They think he is the Chuck Norris of QBs.

 

[Jake]

While you're dissecting Dak's flaws, just be glad the Cowboys failed in their attempts to move up twice during that draft and had to settle on Dak in the 4th round.

Otherwise, we'd have gotten Paxton Lynch or Connor Cook.

 

[Jake]

Dan Marino CARRIED that team. He wasn't a bus driver. They barely ran the ball.

And no, it wasn't remotely as talented of an offense as what Dak inherited.

The 1982 Dolphins lost the Super Bowl. Marino was drafted in 1983, and made his only SB appearance in 1984.

To say he didn't inherit a good team is factually incorrect. That his only SB appearance was two years after their previous one (without him) speaks volumes.

 

[G2]

Correct me if I'm wrong but didn't Romo have a 6 interception game against Buffalo?

5 and a fumble.

 

[HungryLion]

Well, just play by the same rules. If he doesn't think Dak played well against the Packers, so be it. It means that Romo only played well in 1 playoff game and that would be 2009 against Philly. We know all the stupid mistakes he made in 2014 against GB so that high passer rating, dink and dunk performance he put up was worthless as he stalled 3 drives with taking sacks and another by muffing a snap on 3rd down. He wasn't even good against Detroit and is lucky TWill took a short pass and turned it into a long TD or we would lose that game. The increased scrutiny is acceptable, it just goes both ways.

Anyone saying that Dak didn’t play well in the playoffs against the Packers, is an idiot.

Flat out idiot.

Dak isn’t the only reason the offense didn’t score the first few drives. There were a few bonehead plays and a penalty by other players that weren’t Dak’s fault.