Full disclosure - I am/was fully on board with the Smith draft pick, still am. At least it wasn't a TE !!!
Yes it was a risk at the time and it's multiplied now.
No, he will not play a down this year - and he should not, will not be rushed back because of his knee.
Now that everyone has had a day to calm down a bit after McClain's suspension - I am still very much of the opinion he needs to be released. Hopefully, Stephen and Jason/Will have been talking to Jerry and will get him to agree.
Yes, this franchise/Jones are infuriating at times with the decisions they make - but we all love this team in spite of that. McClain was a reclamation project that has not worked, yes he was a very good player when motivated and healthy i.e. not out of shape/fat. But this indiscretion is now affecting both the short term and to a small degree, long term plans the team had for this and next year. Can't have it.
I think we still have time to pick up a player as needed for training camp if they decide to go that route - this is what Will McClay earns his money doing. Smith is a "Futures" pick, and should not be in the equation for this year.
The bummer about all these suspensions on the defense and McFadden's elbow, is man, our schedule looks very favorable and we keep shooting ourselves in the foot ! I will be very upset if Jerry retains McClain on the team, we all know he will not be ready to play for another 2-3 games once he serves the suspension. So why do it ?
Interesting times my friends - even in the dark days of the off-season. And we aren't even talking D-line yet .....