Rules on Eligibility Reporting

[Starstruck22]

that is not proof of what you claim. If this is the best you can do I am fine with that.

Look at the video at the end of the game. After the onside kick they show the whole interaction. It is what it is. Skipper reported brad allen acknowledged.

 

[The Quest for Six]

that is not proof of what you claim. If this is the best you can do I am fine with that.

SInce the ref crew is being demoted from playoff coverage and I expect there's going to be an apology statement to Detroit from the NFL head office by midweek..

 

[McKDaddy]

No evidence decker reported. Evidence for 70 pounding his chest and reporting. Give me a good reasons why 70 was doing that if decker reported. Makes no sense other than an orchestrated play to screw dallas and confuse refs.

So the ref got clear communication from a guy who never got within 8-10 yards of him while not being able to understand a guy who was 3 feet from him. A guy (68 - Decker) who himself, the QB & the head coach all said was to be the eligible player. Even the on air ref said the ref was looking at 70 while standing beside 68. Felt like he just called the wrong number.

 

[Starstruck22]

He points to and nods at 70.

of course he does.

 

[FuzzyLumpkins]

He points to and nods at 70.

and then announces it over the PA. the 500 lbs gorilla in the room.

 

[FuzzyLumpkins]

SInce the ref crew is being demoted from playoff coverage and I expect there's going to be an apology statement to Detroit from the NFL head office by midweek..

That is not proof either. It's okay it was a stupid thing to say in the first place.

 

[Dhragon]

Every morning show, and pregame show of a dozen ex headcoaches, and ex players ALL said the refs screwed up the call...

And NONE of them said anything about the more egregious call against Hendershot and tripping. So they are FAR from infallible. Also, I did not see them mention how utterly unfair it would have been to the Cowboys since they and the whole world was told only 70 was eligible not 68. And thirdly, I remember Aikman and Buck saying that there was multiple flags that could have been called on that play not just the infamous one in question.

 

[The Quest for Six]

That is not proof either. It's okay it was a stupid thing to say in the first place.

yeah the league always comes out and says the ref crew is being removed from playoff games right after they made a good call, yeah OK....

 

[Starstruck22]

So the ref got clear communication from a guy who never got within 8-10 yards of him while not being able to understand a guy who was 3 feet from him. A guy (68 - Decker) who himself, the QB & the head coach all said was to be the eligible player. Even the on air ref said the ref was looking at 70 while standing beside 68. Felt like he just called the wrong number.

That is assuming that decker reported. No proof of that whatsoever. All we have is 58 and 68 standing by the ref. (which is by design to confuse and no other purpose) are you really telling me that decker reported and that brad allen is so stupid that when he acknowledged skupper reporting he did not clarify? This make no sense and fabricated.

 

[Chasing6]

SInce the ref crew is being demoted from playoff coverage and I expect there's going to be an apology statement to Detroit from the NFL head office by midweek..

Ref crew was down graded for their performance. Including the leg whip called on the wrong team. Their grading has dropped them from the playoffs.

 

[FuzzyLumpkins]

yeah the league always comes out and says the ref crew is being removed from playoff games right after they made a good call, yeah OK....

Your claim was that all the national pundits agreed with you. I get you want this slightly less insipid argument in its place but can you try at least not to be disingenuous?

 

[viman96]

posted numerous videos on here

You are stuck on the Ref making a mistake. Do you think that removes the responsibility from Detroit running the play?

 

[Starstruck22]

yeah the league always comes out and says the ref crew is being removed from playoff games right after they made a good call, yeah OK....

The nfl is a clown show. The video tape does not lie. skipper reported and brad said okay you’re the guy. You can not overcome that hurdle. This crew has had a hx of issues and the nfl said it may remove them as that is going to to appease the masses like you that think the nfl did something wrong

 

[Chasing6]

Every morning show, and pregame show of a dozen ex headcoaches, and ex players ALL said the refs screwed up the call...

Everyone can have their own opinion. It was clear what Detroit was trying to do. There is no way for us to know why there was a miscommunication.

But having 3 line involved I am sure is a big part of it.

If 68 was reported and announced then we would have covered him.

 

[Starstruck22]

And NONE of them said anything about the more egregious call against Hendershot and tripping. So they are FAR from infallible. Also, I did not see them mention how utterly unfair it would have been to the Cowboys since they and the whole world was told only 70 was eligible not 68. And thirdly, I remember Aikman and Buck saying that there was multiple flags that could have been called on that play not just the infamous one in question.

I hate the officiating this year. This was one of the few games I saw absolutely nothing egregious.

 

[Chasing6]

You are stuck on the Ref making a mistake. Do you think that removes the responsibility from Detroit running the play?

Detroit also made a mistake sending 3 lineman to the Ref.

 

[The Quest for Six]

Your claim was that all the national pundits agreed with you. I get you want this slightly less insipid argument in its place but can you try at least not to be disingenuous?

I'll believe what I seen myself with my own eyes, common sense, and what the coaches, and players that played the game with their analysis over some guy with conspiracy theories about how its was all planned by Campbell to confuse the refs..

 

[Starstruck22]

Everyone can have their own opinion. It was clear what Detroit was trying to do. There is no way for us to know why there was a miscommunication.

But having 3 line involved I am sure is a big part of it.

If 68 was reported and announced then we would have covered him.

First, No miscommunication. Second, three linemen involved is either involved with them being on drugs or by design. No other explanation. And third, and lets not forget, Campbell is a cheater and win at any cost guy like Bellichick.

 

[The Quest for Six]

And NONE of them said anything about the more egregious call against Hendershot and tripping. So they are FAR from infallible. Also, I did not see them mention how utterly unfair it would have been to the Cowboys since they and the whole world was told only 70 was eligible not 68. And thirdly, I remember Aikman and Buck saying that there was multiple flags that could have been called on that play not just the infamous one in question.

I agree, there was some horrendous calls in the game, but this is about the end of the game egregious call

 

[Starstruck22]

Everyone can have their own opinion. It was clear what Detroit was trying to do. There is no way for us to know why there was a miscommunication.

But having 3 line involved I am sure is a big part of it.

If 68 was reported and announced then we would have covered him.

Exactly. It was by design. Campbell is a scumbag and will cheat to win. No other explanation. Occam's razor.