tyke1doe
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 53,664
- Reaction score
- 32,040
An excellent question. My opinion of the occupation is specific and based on concise definition. Here are the Merriam-Webster definitions I refer to:
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/journalist
journalist noun
1 a : a person engaged in journalism
especially : a writer or editor for a news medium
b : a writer who aims at a mass audience
_______________________________
This is what a sizeable number of people preclude makes basically anyone who writes a journalist. However, an individual must (in my opinion) practice journalism--of which the definition I recognize is this:
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/journalism
journalism noun
2 b : writing characterized by a direct presentation of facts or description of events without an attempt at interpretation
___________________________
Click the link for journalism's complete definition.
For me, I do not need someone's thoughts on any matter. Just report what has been stated by others or relay an event that occurs. I can interpret what has (hopefully) been provided to me as facts. Someone's opinion is not required. In my view, people relaying information to an audience and attaching their opinions provides commentary--not news.
Travis, along with many others with an audience, are conducting themselves no differently from anyone here on this site with one possible exception. Travis is getting paid handsomely for his contributions. Cha-ching.
So newspaper editorial writers and columnists aren't journalists?
Second, you do know that the presentation of facts and description of events - in and of itself - is also an exercise in interpretation, right?
Journalists/reporters pick and choose which details to include in a story, which facts to present in a story, and which to leave out. That is an exercise in INTERPRETATION!!!
Third, you chose definition 2b. The first definition is the most commonly used, which is why it first. The first definition says a person engaged in journalism and a writer who aims at a mass audience.
Fourth, dictionaries are notoriously slow in updating the lexicon of a culture. The Internet has changed the meaning of journalist just like the advent of radio and television expanded the meaning of journalist.
Fifth, the true definition of a journalist is found in the name itself. A person who records or journals the happenings of a society could be loosely considered a journalist.