The truth is that there are fans at both ends of the spectrum. There are fans on this site that complain, regardless of what the team does and we all know some of their names. Likewise, there are some cheerleaders on this site that think everything the organization does is pure gold and they have an excuse ready to explain away anything that would hint as negative towards the team, coaches, or players............again, we all know their names.
The truth of the matter is that this team is not as bad as the pessimist would have you believe and at the same time, this team is not nearly as good as the optimist would have you believe. This team in the middle, its not a bad team and its not really a good team............proof is in the pudding as they say.
Over the past 5 years, the cumulative regular season record of this team is 40-40...........doesn't get more down the middle than that fellas.
I'd argue that the optimists are much more frequently critical of aspects of the team than the pessimists are positive about aspects of the team, but maybe that isn't fair.
That 40-40 since 2011 is actually slightly above average (14 teams ahead of us). Adjusting somewhat for our schedule during that time, it puts us first in the NFCE for that period, but is also the lowest win percentage of any of the divisions in the league by a fair margin.
If you want to try to adjust for the quality of the teams themselves, we win 66% of the game we're favored to win (13 teams are better at that than we are) and win 28.6% of the games we're favored to lose (24 teams in the league win as underdogs at a higher rate). So we typically perform at the rate we're expected to perform.
All this during a period with a strapped cap an aging roster inherited in 2010.
So, overall, not good enough, but not as bad as it's generally made out to be. We've had a franchise QB during that time, and a franchise-worst defense for some of it. We lost a season to injury last year, but then all teams suffer from injuries. We've gotten the roster younger, and the cap healthier. And, overall, we've been outperforming the league average by a thin margin while doing it. Basically: nto great, but not terrible.