Steve Young ranks the NFC QBs

[The Panch]

these rankings are so capricious, no one would have put Warner 3rd before last weekend.

Ugh, I would. He's the greatest postseason Quarterback of his generation.

 

[DallasDomination]

no disrespect to the other Qb's But WArner is the best QB in the playoffs right now.

 

[Hostile]

Gotcha. I didn't know you were counting this year.

No sweat.


I was for both QBs.

Romo...2006, 2007, & 2009...made the playoffs. Missed in 2008. 3 of 4 years.

 

[Hostile]

no disrespect to the other Qb's But WArner is the best QB in the playoffs right now.

Hottest? Yes. Best? No.

Love the guy. Wanted him in 2004 over Vinny so bad it hurt. Manning is easily the best.

 

[Jon88]

I'd take Tony over any QB in the NFL. He brings so much more to the table than great stats. Favre is 40 and still playing at a high level. Romo is younger than all those guys ranked above him.

 

[Hostile]

Romo's regular season record is 38-17 counting this year.

Ack. You are right. I forgot to add his and Brees for this year.

Thanks.

 

[Direwolf63]

Yeah? Who is Steve Young to talk? He hasn't proven jack **** either, unless of course you count winning a championship game that the refs guaranteed the 49ers in 94/95 vs. Dallas by calling one of the worst one-sided games Ive ever seen...or the fact that the NFL allowed the 49ers to circumvbent the cap illegally that year, by stockpiling free agents thay had no cap room for...or by letting the 49ers pay other players with under the table money that year to ***** the cap numbers. That's what it took that year to get the monkey off Steve Young's back. So he'a the last person to tell me about what it takes for a QB to win a Super Bowl.

Couldn't have said it better myself.

 

[DallasDomination]

Hottest? Yes. Best? No.

Love the guy. Wanted him in 2004 over Vinny so bad it hurt. Manning is easily the best.

I'll take Kurt over manning because come playoffs Kurt WArner comes to play. You can't say the same thing about Manning. he's had some below average outings and even some right out ugly games.

Warner in the playoffs all day IMO.

 

[ElGatoGrande]

Brees is better than Romo, just Steve's logic is flawed. Concussions. They're a *****.

^^^ THIS ^^^

but only if we are talking about accuracy. Some of the games I've watched of Brees were just amazing. He was throwing to WRs who were not open, but placed the ball perfectly for the WRs to make acrobatic catches.

Now, maybe if Romo had receivers as talented as the Saints receivers he could make the same throws,,, who knows?

 

[Cover 2]

I'd take Tony over any QB in the NFL. He brings so much more to the table than great stats. Favre is 40 and still playing at a high level. Romo is younger than all those guys ranked above him.

The only quarterback I would consider trading Romo for is Peyton, and neither team would make that trade. Plus since Romo's younger than Peyton I don't know if I would make that trade. Romo's the most underrated player in the NFL.

 

[dcfanatic]

Romo is going to have the best game of the four this weekend.

That's all that matters.

 

[TellerMorrow34]

Romo is going to have the best game of the four this weekend.

That's all that matters.

I completely agree DC. Romo is going to shine on Sunday.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

No way you rank Brees below any of those guys, dude. I like this list, but Romo is better than Warner when the latter is having one of this "off" days. And possibly better than Favre depending on the kind of day he's having.

But I take Brees any day of the week.

lol, been watching ESPN? Brees is as overrated as Idk, he is the most overrated player. Romo > Rodgers > Favre > Warner > McNabb (6 is brees)

Why is everyone overlooking Rodgers?

 

[Temo]

lol, been watching ESPN? Brees is as overrated as Idk, he is the most overrated player. Romo > Rodgers > Favre > Warner > McNabb (6 is brees)

Why is everyone overlooking Rodgers?

Agree on Rodgers.

Just no on everything else.

 

[Dhragon]

lol, been watching ESPN? Brees is as overrated as Idk, he is the most overrated player. Romo > Rodgers > Favre > Warner > McNabb (6 is brees)

Why is everyone overlooking Rodgers?

Because the parameters were ranking the NFC QBS still playing in the playoffs as of now. Rodgers is not playing anymore.

 

[ringmaster]

Yeah? Who is Steve Young to talk? He hasn't proven jack **** either, unless of course you count winning a championship game that the refs guaranteed the 49ers in 94/95 vs. Dallas by calling one of the worst one-sided games Ive ever seen...or the fact that the NFL allowed the 49ers to circumvbent the cap illegally that year, by stockpiling free agents thay had no cap room for...or by letting the 49ers pay other players with under the table money that year to ***** the cap numbers. That's what it took that year to get the monkey off Steve Young's back. So he'a the last person to tell me about what it takes for a QB to win a Super Bowl.

I still cringe at that no call pass interference on Sanders, it was so evident that a blind man could've called that.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

Because the parameters were ranking the NFC QBS still playing in the playoffs as of now. Rodgers is not playing anymore.

I didn't see where he said playoffs, sorry.. but if it is playoffs, 4 QB's left so.... Romo > Favre > Warner > Brees

 

[Seven]

Steve Young is a cat. Period.

 

[THUMPER]

Tony Romo's record in the post season is 1-2. So is Drew Brees. Brees has been starting in the NFL since 2002. That is a 4 year head start on Tony.

Tony has led 3 of his 4 teams to the playoffs. Tony's team has never finished last in their Division while he is the primary QB.

Brees has led 3 of his 8 teams to the playoffs. Brees' teams have finished last in their Division twice (2003 and 2008).

Tony's won - loss record is 38-17.

Brees won - loss record is 68-54.

Some will say it is because Brees puts up better stats. Romo threw more TDs in 2007 than Brees has in any season. Romo's INT % in 2009 is lower than in any season Brees played.

Not saying Brees is not a great QB. He is. The double standard applied is rather silly.

You beat me to it Hos!

 

[DFWJC]

That's 4 very good QBs, any way you slice it.