Okay. let's go year-by-year. (sydney brown isn't a starter yet, and Dean hasn't shown he can be -- so, it's more lie 14/22. Not a good percentage.) Cox, Graham, and Kelce were all draft picks MORE THAN A DECADE AGO. The Eagles are old and their depth SUCKS. Any injury on oline, wr, lb, safety, or te1 -- they are playing with scrubs.
2022 -- They got Davis, who averaged 20 snaps and was not impressive. Nobody else of note
2021 -- Smith and Dickerson. Solid, WR2 and Guard.No pro bowls though
2020 -- All busts but Hurts.
2019 -- All busts but an ok Rb (miles sanders)
2018 -- A very good year. Goeddert, Maddux, Sweat, Mailata (this year is keeping them afloat)
2017 -- Bust city unless you count Rasoul Douglas.
2016 -- Wentz and a guard who they let go.
2015 -- Jordan Hicks?? Lol
2014 -- ummmm... i don't recognize any of these guys
2013 -- Lane Johnson, Zach Ertz, Jordan Poyer -- good draft.
So, I count 2 above average drafts (2018, 2013) and one solid draft (2021) in the past DECADE. 5 absolute busts, and then one year that's a bust outside of Hurts.
Wanna compare the Cowboys? Eagles have what, two regular pro bowlers? Three if you count Ertz. In a decade.
If 3 out of your 14 drafted starters come from more than a decade ago, you are NOT adept at drafting replacements. Which is what this argument is about