This is exactly the kind of fan skepticism that this franchise has earned over the last 28 years.
You cannot trust what you see because the bottom has fallen out so many times.
They will have to prove it in January. They have lost all credibility at this point. While McCarthy can point to 3 straight 12 win seasons as being quite an achievement, and he has a point— we can point to when he was hired with the goal of getting this team over the hump in the postseason— and that has yet to happen.
So in essence, he has won some battles, but lost the wars. Until that changes— the skepticism will remain— and that is a direct result of this team’s underachievments.