Top 10 QBs right now

[goshan]

What a homer.

 

[big dog cowboy]

The usual suspects will always be in the top 5 or so. After that personal taste in QB's determine the rest of the top 10. But to put Vick in the top 10 is downright mind blowing. The "excitement" he brings to the game is fun to watch for a while. After that has worn off, it's clear he won't lead his team to a championship.

 

[TwoSteppinJJ]

But to put Vick in the top 10 is downright mind blowing. The "excitement" he brings to the game is fun to watch for a while. After that has worn off, it's clear he won't lead his team to a championship.

what he said ^

 

[justbob]

Drew Henson should be number one.

Any ranking without Henson at the top is ridiculous.

Did you forget --Quincy's BACK

 

[jsond]

bledsoe number 2 on this list

relax cowboy fans no need to lynch me but bledsoe at #2 is a joke. i like drew but c'mon

 

[The Answer]

Mine
1) Brady, simply put, dude is money and proven when it counts most
2) Payton WoManning, I hate him more than most but I'll admit he's dang good
3) Carson Palmer, This guy is the next truly great QB if he fully recovers he was unstoppable last year
4) Jake Delhomme, gets it done, more with grit than talent but done
5) Hasslebach, savy, moxie, gritty, I'd love a guy like this on our team
6) Drew Brees, at least was....but not sure he'll be the same again
7) Drew Bledsoe, the reason he's this low IMO is that he can't carry the team like the QBs above, he needs an OL and a running game, but deadly with them
8) McNubb, arguable IMO between DB and Mcnubb but I think Mcnubb's play is declining and he's MUCH less of a threat to run until he loses some weight
9) Trent Green, very similar to DB IMO, very very good but not quite elite
10) Rothlisberger, gets it done but I don't think he would thrive in a pass first offense and I don't think he could carry the team if he had to

The Answer respects your opinion, but I beg to differ about Bledsoe carrying a football team. Brees, Hasslebach and Manning all have superior olines and running backs.

Bledsoe carried New England early in his career and especially after Parcells and Curtis Martin were gone. He was New England's favorite son.

In Buffalo he led the team to 6 straight wins after a 3-6 start in 2004. Also set many franchise passing records in 2002.

Last year we could have easily been a 3 or 4 win team without him. 5 come from behind wins, and many frustrated defensive coordinators later...Bledsoe is the real deal!

Look out in 2006, many offensive records are in jeopardy!

~The Answer

 

[The Answer]

So discounting all those QBs because you dont think they played well enough in the playoffs, actually helps prop up Bledsoe who has not played well enough to even make the playoffs?

They all had teams better equipped to make the playoffs.....the fact that Bledsoe by himself kept the cowboys in contention warrants recognition as one of the games best!

~The Answer

 

[The Answer]

Rue Bledsoe at number 2!??

Dude - no offense - But Drew Bledsoe isn't even Top 15

Obviously you are a troll to make such an absurd statement.

Please enlighten The Answer as to the 14 other QB's that are better than Bledsoe.

~The Answer

 

[Doomsday]

The Answer's top 10 QB's playing right now:

1.) Tom Brady - 3 world titles in first 5 seasons speaks for itself, has a great defense and coach but can't argue what he brings to the table.
2.) Drew Bledsoe - 14 year veteran can still sling it with the best of them, puts up great numbers with lesser talent but finally appears to have the missing link: TO

~The Answer

Number 1 is debateable in my opinion but I could see a case being made for him. After that you lost me, the whole list becomes irrelevant.

 

[rdsknsbaby]

The Answer's top 10 QB's playing right now:

1.) Tom Brady - 3 world titles in first 5 seasons speaks for itself, has a great defense and coach but can't argue what he brings to the table.
2.) Drew Bledsoe - 14 year veteran can still sling it with the best of them, puts up great numbers with lesser talent but finally appears to have the missing link: TO
3.) Ben Rothlisberger - 15-1 as a rookie, outstanding performance in 3 straight road playoff games and a world title in his 2nd year.
4.) Jake Delhomme - The cajun sensation seems to be getting better each year, plays great in the big games.
5.) Peyton Manning - Can't ignore the numbers, but despite having phenomenal talent around him he still comes up short when it matters most.
6.) Donavan McNabb - Won a lot of games before TO, with TO and likely will after TO.
7.) Matt Hasslebach - From Brett Favre's understudy to a rock solid all around QB and a superbowl birth, can he do it again?
8.) Carson Palmer - Finally arrived in his 3rd season and has a very bright future if he can fully recover from a devestating injury.
9.) Trent Green - late bloomer has had a great running game to compliment his passing yards.
10.) Drew Brees - Going to make a lot of noise in NO with reggie bush if he is healthy. Chargers made a foolish mistake letting him walk.

Honorable mentions: Dante Culpepper, Brett Favre, Jake Plummer, Mark Bulger and Kurt Warner.

Please provide you top 10 QB rankings and base it on their PRESENT accomplishments, the team/talent around them, and proven ability, not future potential or past successes.

Thanks

~The Answer

HAHAHAHAHA :laugh2: :laugh1: :laugh2: :laugh1:


I cannot believe you put Drew Bledslow at number 2. If i was a cowboys fan i would still disagree with this asinine statement. wow.




My Top 10

1. Tom Brady
2. Mark Brunell... JK JK Peyton Manning
3. Big Ben
4. Carson Palmer
5. Donovan McNabb
6. Trent Green
7. Jake Delhomme
8. Drew Brees
9. Jake Plummer
10. Kurt Warner

 

[Bob Sacamano]

a post that pimps Bledsoe, I wonder who started it...hmmm

 

[Bob Sacamano]

HAHAHAHAHA :laugh2: :laugh1: :laugh2: :laugh1:


I cannot believe you put Drew Bledslow at number 2. If i was a cowboys fan i would still disagree with this asinine statement. wow.




My Top 10

1. Tom Brady
2. Mark Brunell... JK JK Peyton Manning
3. Big Ben
4. Carson Palmer
5. Donovan McNabb
6. Trent Green
7. Jake Delhomme
8. Drew Brees
9. Jake Plummer
10. Kurt Warner

I think Bledsoe definitely belongs in the top 10, esp. over Donovan, Plummer and Warner

 

[The Answer]

I think Bledsoe definitely belongs in the top 10, esp. over Donovan, Plummer and Warner

It's nice to see we agree with something, where do you have Bledsoe?

The Answer would like to see summerisfunners official top 10 list, please feel free to add to the discussion.

~The Answer

 

[Bob Sacamano]

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Jake Delhomme
4. Carson Palmer
5. Ben Roth
6. Matt Hasselback
7. Drew Bledsoe
8. Trent Green
9. Mark Brunell
10. Brett Favre

 

[The Answer]

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Jake Delhomme
4. Carson Palmer
5. Ben Roth
6. Matt Hasselback
7. Drew Bledsoe
8. Trent Green
9. Mark Brunell
10. Brett Favre

Fair enough....The Answer respects your list. And at least you don't have Michael Vick among your top 10...

~The Answer

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Fair enough....The Answer respects your list. And at least you don't have Michael Vick among your top 10...

~The Answer

I'd prefer Quincy to Vick

 

[Aryma]

1. Manning
2. Brady
3. Palmer
4. Hasselbeck
5. Bledsoe
6. Green
7. Delhomme
8. Brees
9. Brunell
10. Plummer

 

[austintodallas]

1. Manning
2. Brady
3. Bledsoe

 

[Zaxor]

1 Tom Brady
2 Trent Green
3 Brett Favre
4 Carson Palmer
5 Ben Roethlisberger
6 Jake Delhomme
7 Peyton Manning
8 Matt Hasselbeck
9 Drew Brees
10 Donovan McNabb
11 Byron Leftwich
12 Jake Plummer
13 Steve McNair
14 Eli Manning



15 -21 (in any order you would like) Drew Bledsoe Mark Brunell Kurt Warner Aaron Brooks Brad Johnson Michael Vick Kerry Collins



22 Trent Dilfer
23 Marc Bulger
24 Gus Frerotte
25 Chris Simms
26 Joey Harrington
27 David Carr
28 Kyle Orton
29 Josh McCown
30 Kyle Boller

 

[the kid 05]

That was my point- any QB cannot be really evaluated untill he has had at least 4-5 playoff games.

So whats your evaluation on Dan Marino?