Top 20 NFL Quarterback rankings: Intangibles make the best leaders

[dadymat]

I dont have much faith in Rivers whatsoever. Norv Turner has more to do with that QB rating than Rivers does. When Norv leaves Rivers is going straight to the toilet.

agreed Norv even made Alex Smith look good....

 

[CATCH17]

i see what you did there.....:laugh1:

LT had a bad season last year, was nursing injuries and still had a better season than Barber....I love me some Barber but come on man LT is light years ahead of him.....and since we are comparing who did what with who..we are not talking about future we are talking about past and in the past Barber hasnt come close to LT

Barber was hurt too and even missed games.

When Barber is going he puts our offense on another level.


Plus he is a touchdown machine.


LT is obviously a better alltime back though but it would be hard to replace the toughness that Barber brings to this team when hes in the game.

 

[YosemiteSam]

I would put Rivers in Brees position. working with less I think he has done more. McFlabb is too high as well- I would put Warner over him.

Yeah... I don't agree.

LT + Sproles >>>>>>>>>>>>> + Bush + Deuce McAllister: Chargers

Coltson >> Vincent Jackson: Saints

Antonio Gates >>>>> Jermey Shockey: Chargers

 

[CATCH17]

Yeah... I don't agree.

LT + Sproles >>>>>>>>>>>>> + Bush + Deuce McAllister: Chargers

Coltson >> Vincent Jackson: Saints

Antonio Gates >>>>> Jermey Shockey: Chargers

Chargers Oline > Saints Oline

Chargers defense > Saints defense


Defense does help the offense BTW.


Rivers definetely has the better cast.

 

[dadymat]

Barber was hurt too and even missed games.

When Barber is going he puts our offense on another level.


Plus he is a touchdown machine.


LT is obviously a better alltime back though but it would be hard to replace the toughness that Barber brings to this team when hes in the game.

i know who and what MB3 is ....hes one of my favorite players....but i was referring to the players that put these 2 offenses where they got in the last 3 seasons.......not the next 3 seasons......:starspin

 

[jobberone]

I wouldn't trade anyone for LT right now. I hope for his sake I'm wrong but he looks about finished to me. I certainly wouldn't trade Barber.

Name five better RBs who still have his years left.

 

[juck]

Those ratings seem fair.