Bach;2665630 said:
You and your revisionist history is laughable. Jerry was and is the GM only because he gave himself that title. Jimmy and his staff built those Super Bowl teams and Jerry ran it into the ground once he left and had to come begging for someone like Parcells to turn it around for him. Once that was done and Parcells left, Jerry went right back to his old ways of hiring a puppet HC and micromanaging everything from the staff to personnel.
Hopefully with the scouting system in place now we'll have more success than we did when Jerry and Lacewell ran things. But as far as the coaching staff goes, Jerry is calling all the shots while basically just having a HC who is primarily just a coordinator with a bigger title, ala Gailey and Campo. Now that was really a recipe for success wasn't it? And now we're right back to that same old philosophy.
This argument could on forever so let me just make a few points then I'll move on.
1) Jimmy had no idea how to run an NFL offense. He had David Shula and Norv Turner handed to him. He also had Michael Irvin and a large handful of other guys like Herschel Walker already here.
He didn't trade Herschel to get that draft bounty. He traded him because Jerry wouldn't pay the guy what he wanted.
2) Jerry said day 1 he was going to manage things, from socks to jocks.
He micro-managed all along. Jimmy was a powerful head coach because he got what he wanted from Jerry 9 times out of 10 including a buyout so he could head off to fish in Florida. But the title was always GM for Jerry. And of course at the start he sat back and tried to learn what went on. He had never been in the business. He made a multitude of mistakes. But he was always GM. He always had final say and final authority and he always will. He has offered media members who sound like you, to come look at those contracts. They never take him up on it because like you they'd prefer to believe what they want.
3) A lot of what I am posting comes from Jerry's autobiographies but the rest comes from Jimmy's. He is just as self-preening as BP but he admits many aspects of what I have posted in those books, including how he didn't want Aikman. In fact he never drafted Irvin, didn't want Aikman and was talked into Emmitt after his 2 or 3 targeted defensive guys came off the board.
4) Jimmy never made a single trade or drafted a single player without Jerry there. He always was involved. Doesn't mean he fielded every call but he was always int he mix. He sit back in Highland Park ever. He was always in the middle of whatever the Cowboys did. The fact he trusted Jimmy as his football guy just meant he gave Jimmy personnel dept responsibilities but he never let Jimmy dictate anything to do with money. Jerry always decided every aspect of where the team practiced, held camp, et al.
As to the separate point and going forward, absolutely it is hopeful Jerry learned from Bill to "unlearn" the nonsensical front office philosophy he had under Jimmy of allowing coaches to rank players. Scouts build the board, then coaches beg for their guys they like.
You win by having a good scouting team in place. We have that now. If we continue to draft well we will win games, including playoff games, sooner rather that later.