Well - I did say he didn't play well and you have to admit those teams were marginal. By that, what you said is correct, they could've won and I'm right in that they could've lost and they did. They also were going nowhere in the playoffs. Brady threw 3 INT's in two AFC Championship games and they were 100% his fault - and he won both games.
3 picks in Championship games and he got bailed out. Tony never got bailed out.
Secondly, - I love Romo but, you're right, he does not belong in the Hall Of Fame.
Finally - it's simply not fair nor correct to say he played bad in big games because then you have to define what is a big game. All the regular season games and late season games add up. He also played a flawless game against the Packers and arguably threw a game-winning TD that was taken away.
I don't think we are that far apart in our opinion of Tony other than I am saying it's a team game and he's never really caught a break.
Well think about this, rodgers won the SB, early on, then since that win, loses every year in the playoffs in big games lol,
but no one says he chokes, or cant win the big ones etc.
All because he won the one SB early on when they had a really good team and defense.
Tony had 2 chances to win a SB, 2007, and 2014 , and possibly 2006 , those were the only teams capable of going all the way, with the
competition they had.
In 2009 that team had no chance, as competition was just on another level.
In 2007, tony and whole team was overconfident, and did not take the giants seriously, having beat them 2 times already.
They thought they could just show up a play and win. Tony could have played better and so could have whole team.
Also JG and wade were the coaches lol.
2014 again close but played a little sloppy, JG's first playoff games, and he wasnt too good.
Tony played good, but I do question the throw to dez. It was a team loss though.
2006, this team was good, sloppy but good, and had they won the seattle game, no telling how far they go.
Cant blame tony , many mistakes led to that last second FG, so more of a team loss, but people just
remember that last play.
Without tony they would not even have been in the playoffs that year.
It takes more than a good QB to get to and do good in playoffs, you need players to step up, catching a ball on your helmet,
like peppers stripping murray, etc, and you need good coaches, good game plan, game mgmt, and play calling.
In all those years, with tony, except 2006, JG has been OC, asst HC, and then HC / OC. then HC.
So now we dump romo, and keep JG !
JG has been a factor in all the losses, and wins, and in the "big games" but he gets a pass.
Now the question is can Dak overcome JG and his losing ways?
So far the answer is no, he couldnt in 2016, and like tony went 13-3 then one and done in div round as top seed !!
Dak may overcome, he is very determined, but only time will tell.
