Not really.
The question could have been posed by the reporter, which of the THREE QUARTERBACKS - Leinart, Young, Cutler - do you think will be the best?
Maybe Clemens wasn't even brought into the discussion. And, remember, Jaws is not writing the article.
But I really don't see what the fuss is about.
Both Big and X Dawg cited articles to support their argument. If anything, the problem has more to do with Jaws being wishy washy than anyone "disapproving" the other poster.
Jaws said both - that Cutler was the top QB and that Clemens was the top QB.
I think that's what you call "talking out of both sides of your mouth."