Who Is The Best QB In The NFC East?

Wheeltax

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,399
Reaction score
993
I'm not saying Eli Manning is a bad or a bus driver QB, he clearly is neither of those things, but I don't like the pedestal he gets placed upon. Not just here, but everywhere. I don't think he's near the QB Peyton is, despite having more playoff success.
 

Wayne02

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,350
Reaction score
2,049
It counts the same for playoff games as it does for Super Bowls. Teams win SBs. Not to channel Jerry Jones here, but any one of 500 different QBs through history could have won the SB (and the requisite playoff games) with Seattle last year, because QB play isn't why they had that success. They have the right team, the right coaches, the right chemistry and atmosphere, and the right breaks that went their way. Very little to do with their QB.

I disagree, the QB play is very important to playoff success. I'm not saying that every QB has the same kind of team around him because that's clearly not the case, but to try and diminish what Russell Wilson did throughout the playoffs just because he had a great defense is absurd. He was smart with the football and consistently made plays on 3rd downs to keep drives alive, just because he didn't throw for 300 yards a night, doesn't negate the fact that he had a significant role to play if they were to continue winning games. Playoff success matters.
 

WPBCowboysFan

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,265
Reaction score
6,532
Look in the mirror. If your expression resembles the cluelessness Eli conveys then congrats, the shoe fits and you are a card carrier.

Like this?

eli.jpg


eli-manning-face.jpg
 

OhSnap

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,591
Reaction score
721
I'm not saying Eli Manning is a bad or a bus driver QB, he clearly is neither of those things, but I don't like the pedestal he gets placed upon. Not just here, but everywhere. I don't think he's near the QB Peyton is, despite having more playoff success.

Peyton can make a receiver look great but Eli needs a good receiver to look great.
 

dfense

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,109
Reaction score
6,542
If there has been one word to describe the NFC East division over the past several years, you’d be hard pressed to find one better suited than unpredictable. Maybe erratic or crazy. But unpredictable is best. All four teams are looking for stability which is often directly handed down from leadership. The leaders of a team are the GM’s office, coaches and of course, quarterbacks.

Since everyone loves to talk about quarterbacks the most, we’ll start there. All of these QB’s may be unpredictable but none of them are the same. They each have their unique characterization.

Eli Manning (New York Giants) is the only Super Bowl champion in this group. He’s a veteran with a rocket arm and he has more rings than his older brother named Peyton. Maybe you’ve heard of him?

Nick Foles (Philadelphia Eagles) is the young underdog. He seemed to master Chip Kelly’s college styled offense and came out of nowhere to steal Mike Vick’s job and he threw for 27 touchdowns and only 2 interceptions during the regular season. Wait what?

Robert Griffin III (Washington Commanders) is highly drafted and deemed by many to be the great QB of the future after his rookie season. However, a nasty injury and a little bit of over-publicity seemed to ground the seemingly “untouchable” QB in his second year. Will he return to first year form?

Tony Romo (Dallas Cowboys) is the brunt of everyone’s joke because apparently he always chokes in big games. Statistically, he’s been nothing short of spectacular, but that won’t change anyone’s mind until he wins the “big one.” Will the gunslinger finally break the curse?

It’d be very difficult to pick out one of these guys and say that they are undoubtedly the best in the division although Manning’s two rings probably makes the strongest case. With the division title being anyone’s to take for the past several years, all of these QB’s have the chance to take their teams to a level of division dominance.

Let’s take an in-depth look. http://dallascowboysnation.com/2014/04/best-qb-nfc-east/

Eli Manning has a rocket arm?
 

OhSnap

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,591
Reaction score
721
Eli Manning has a rocket arm?

No and I didn't write this just scraped it up off the internet floor. I think they writer meant to say "bottle rocket arm." Glad you caught that, it kinda helps your street cred.
 

PSU999

Member
Messages
81
Reaction score
5
Still Eli. He's the only proven winner with 2 rings and 2 SB MVPs.

Put a legitimate NFL-caliber O-Line in front of him and he's clearly the best of the group.
 
Top