Who is the best WR complement to CeeDee?

[CalPolyTechnique]

Golden reminds me of Cooks […]

That’s a good comp for Golden.

 

[cnuball21]

Preach. If you stack these guys up to previous draft classes they fall short. The value starts in round 2 at WR.

No blue chippers for sure…but still a lot of good players in the 1st 2 rounds that could help their rookie year.

Our WR room is laughable.

 

[stinkface]

Someone who has a big catch radius who can also block. The Ohio State WO might be the guy, but he would have to be a round 2 guy, unless he blows up the combine.

 

[Mr_437]

No blue chippers for sure…but still a lot of good players in the 1st 2 rounds that could help their rookie year.

Our WR room is laughable.

I agree. I think I give the current WRs more of a pass due to McCarthy, but I support adding better talent to this group.

 

[cnuball21]

I agree. I think I give the current WRs more of a pass due to McCarthy, but I support adding better talent to this group.

I can’t give them a pass…Tolbert has had a few years now and isn’t more than a 3 at best.

The scheme didn’t ask him or others to do much and no one could step up opposite of Lamb.

WR2 is a red light need for me.

 

[Mr_437]

I can’t give them a pass…Tolbert has had a few years now and isn’t more than a 3 at best.

The scheme didn’t ask him or others to do much and no one could step up opposite of Lamb.

WR2 is a red light need for me.

That's one perspective and I get it. I look at a guy who has gotten better every year, and doubled his production from last season. It's hard to get open when the CB knows the route your running.

I tend to believe the red light is the run game, which, will open up bigger passing windows and create 1 on 1s for the WRs. Just a difference in perspectives.

 

[CalPolyTechnique]

That's one perspective and I get it. I look at a guy who has gotten better every year, and doubled his production from last season. It's hard to get open when the CB knows the route your running.

I tend to believe the red light is the run game, which, will open up bigger passing windows and create 1 on 1s for the WRs. Just a difference in perspectives.

I tend to see it that way too. I think his numbers would have been even better had he had Dak back there for a full season. That said, I wouldn’t bat an eye if we took Egbuka and slotted him as #2 and Tolbert #3.

 

[dacopacabana]

Well Jerry already used a 4th, so technically this team already drafted a WR in the 2025 draft.

 

[cnuball21]

That's one perspective and I get it. I look at a guy who has gotten better every year, and doubled his production from last season. It's hard to get open when the CB knows the route your running.

I tend to believe the red light is the run game, which, will open up bigger passing windows and create 1 on 1s for the WRs. Just a difference in perspectives.

That’s fair…but I’ve seen enough to think he’s completely upgradable and isn’t good enough in comparison to the NFC contenders #2s.

 

[RS12]

 

[Mr_437]

^^^CeeDee's route tree on display, can Burden coexist with Lamb?

 

[J-man]

I personally wouldn't be zeroing in on rd 1 WR's. I think it's more likely they wait until rd 3 or after. In JJ's mind he fixed the WR issue by trading our 4th for Mingo.

 

[starfan1]

I think a trade down and get an additional pick is in order but I like the kid out of Miami (restrepo). Hes a great route runner and i think would compliment CeeDee well. The problem is we could also use a RB,OT and DT.

 

[Manwiththeplan]

Stephon Diggs...

 

[J-man]

I'd be looking more at guys like Elic Ayomanor, Isaiah Bond, Jalen Royals, Savion Williams, Xavier Restrepo etc...someone who may be there in rd 3 or perhaps 4, if we make a trade for a 4th, which I think is very possible.

 

[CalPolyTechnique]

I can’t give them a pass…Tolbert has had a few years now and isn’t more than a 3 at best.

The scheme didn’t ask him or others to do much and no one could step up opposite of Lamb.

WR2 is a red light need for me.

Disagree on this one.

Tolbert had a really good year considering who he was playing with at QB. Receiver and TE numbers for the team were down across the board including CeeDee.

I think Tolbert can be a quality #2-3 with Dak. We do need more talent at the position and possibly a #2 starter type.

 

[cnuball21]

Disagree on this one.

Tolbert had a really good year considering who he was playing with at QB. Receiver and TE numbers for the team were down across the board including CeeDee.

I think Tolbert can be a quality #2-3 with Dak. We do need more talent at the position and possibly a #2 starter type.

Sure, he probably plays better with Dak.

But how do you feel about him compared to Smitty, Addison, Deebo, Jameo etc as a #2? Those are our top NFC competitor #2s.

 

[Cowboyny]

I'd be looking more at guys like Elic Ayomanor, Isaiah Bond, Jalen Royals, Savion Williams, Xavier Restrepo etc...someone who may be there in rd 3 or perhaps 4, if we make a trade for a 4th, which I think is very possible.

Are they any better then what we already have? They need a legitimate #2 starting receiver.

 

[Cowboyny]

Sure, he probably plays better with Dak.

But how do you feel about him compared to Smitty, Addison, Deebo, Jameo etc as a #2? Those are our top NFC competitor #2s.

People just don't get it, it's laughable to compare our #2 receiver against the contenders. Tolbert isn't even close to these players and never will.

 

[J-man]

Are they any better then what we already have? They need a legitimate #2 starting receiver.

I think at least a couple of those guys would hopefully be upgrades. And would make a nice addition to the WR room that would help complement CD and the passing attack.