Who is the most over rated player in Dallas Cowboys history

[maryquality]

Tony Romo

I would say Romo was underrated.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Sean Lee, Romo and Witten……

I’d probably say Romo. Never stepped up in a big moment and in retirement some fans sing his praises like he was Brady. He was not.

 

[J12B]

I would say Romo was underrated.

I would say Romo was evenrated

 

[PA Cowboy Fan]

I would say either Romo or Dak. Good QBs but not all time greats like some believe.

 

[StarMan2112]

Tony Romo

 

[acr731]

I would say Romo was underrated.

Although I was never a huge fan of his and always rode the fence in the arguments back at DC.com, after 8 seasons of Dak ball I need to say this - I think Romo gave the team a better chance to win than Dak. Both of them sucked in the postseason, but I admit I felt more confidence with Romo than I have with Dak.

 

[shabazz]

Tony Romo

Bite us newb............................j/k

 

[shabazz]

Tony Romo

A sphincter says what?

 

[Tabascocat]

Herschel Walker

He was overrated on the field which parlayed Dallas into three rings

 

[StarMan2112]

A sphincter says what?

I’m sorry, I was waiting for you to finish the sentence.

 

[ReverendFelcher]

That guy we get in trouble for talking about

 

[big dog cowboy]

And ZERO rings and NFC Championships

So that makes him the most overrated Cowboys player in history???

NO. Not even close.

 

[XXLMike]

Witten was like Eddie Murray ( mlb ) a compiler. he have 16 catches against the Raiders in a 34 to 10 blowout.

He’s overrated for sure .

Eugene, the no-hitter machine, Lockhart was also overrated.

La Roi Glover overrated

Marcellus Wiley overrated

Both Roy Williams severely overrated.

Charlie Waters was a tad overrated as well.

Demarcus Ware was an overrated Cowboy and borderline compiler- he never dominated a big team in a big spot in a big playoff game until he went to the Broncos.

But the most overrated of all time was Dez Bryant and the we them boys garbage.

 

[SwagSurfer]

Romo and Prescott. Both have their legion of Stan's but neither one of them have done anything exciting in the playoffs but crap the bed. Props to Romo, though for taking advantage and going into broadcasting.

 

[big dog cowboy]

Interpreted as: most career receiving yards by tight end

NAME...................REC YDS..GP.....REC......TRG.....AVG...REC YDS/G REC TD
1 Tony Gonzalez 15,127 270 1,325 1,862 11.4 56.0 111
2 Jason Witten 13,046 271 1,228 1,723 10.6 48.1 74

 

[acr731]

A sphincter says what?

 

[Swagger]

Romo and Prescott. Both have their legion of Stan's but neither one of them have done anything exciting in the playoffs but crap the bed. Props to Romo, though for taking advantage and going into broadcasting.

The reason why it's Prescott and not Romo is because the former has failed with better teams in the play offs.

 

[Coogiguy03]

Without a doubt Jason Witten.

That guy was a little above average at best. His last 3 or 4 years were terrible as he somehow slowed down.

Stats were always padded by garbage time.

I have to go through the comments about our beloved warrior, you may could have picked someone else. Seems like you're basing this off his last several years, may not be fair!

I do agree with his slowness. It was so damn painful seeing us have 3rd and 9 and we hit him with the safe 3 yard pass with him getting no YAC but only about 4 guys trying to take him down lol

 

[Coogiguy03]

D-law comes to mind

 

[gtb1943]

Witten was like Eddie Murray ( mlb ) a compiler. he have 16 catches against the Raiders in a 34 to 10 blowout.

He’s overrated for sure .

Eugene, the no-hitter machine, Lockhart was also overrated.

La Roi Glover overrated

Marcellus Wiley overrated

Both Roy Williams severely overrated.

Charlie Waters was a tad overrated as well.

Demarcus Ware was an overrated Cowboy and borderline compiler- he never dominated a big team in a big spot in a big playoff game until he went to the Broncos.

But the most overrated of all time was Dez Bryant and the we them boys garbage.

Glover was an excellent DT so you are full of crap there - only you would say he was over rated
Deware makes no surprise coming from someone so bereft of football judgement