Who would you rather have Demarco Murray or Greg Hardy?

[Blackspider214]

Who would you rather have :

Demarco Murray or Greg Hardy?

My answer is Murray , we really dropped the ball here. However I think we could have easily had both with a restructure.

This off season feels slapped together.

Murray knows a lot about that

 

[KJJ]

Would rather have Murray than a player who's facing suspension and will likely be gone after one season. The Cowboys just turned the corner with a 12-4 season and were on the brink of possibly something special in 2015 and with Murray now in Philly that could change everything. Signing Hardy who may only play part of one season with the Cowboys may have some jumping for joy but not me. You don't build great teams by letting your best players walk and signing another player to a one year deal who has issues and is facing a suspension.

 

[ActualCowboysFan]

If Biff and KJJ are for it the smart money is against it.

 

[EST_1986]

Hardy without a doubt. This is a time where the perfect decision was made.

 

[Oh_Canada]

Who would you rather have :

Demarco Murray or Greg Hardy?

My answer is Murray , we really dropped the ball here. However I think we could have easily had both with a restructure.

This off season feels slapped together.

Lol. Are you serious?

 

[KJJ]

Lol. Are you serious?

I agree with him I don't see how losing Murray to Philly and signing Hardy who's facing a suspension to a one year deal makes the Cowboys a better team.

 

[Oh_Canada]

I agree with him I don't see how losing Murray to Philly and signing Hardy who's facing a suspension to a one year deal makes the Cowboys a better team.

Ummmm, a running back who coming off a 400 carry season is not a risk? He would be the first in history if he ran for 1200 yds after carrying that many times the year prior. Do you not think McFadden and a high pick can't do that?

 

[KJJ]

If Biff and KJJ are for it the smart money is against it.

If I'm against anything the smart money is to go with me I have plenty of archived posts that will verify it. What's smart about letting your MVP from last season go and allowing them to sign with your rival you've battled for the division title with for the past 2 seasons and sign an LB to a one year deal who's facing a suspension?

 

[esloan]

Hardy and a RB in the draft. No question, no doubt.

 

[big dog cowboy]

Who would you rather have :

Demarco Murray or Greg Hardy?

Hardy and it isn't close. Replacing a RB is light years easier than replacing a DL like Hardy.

 

[JoeBoBBY]

Murray is not worth that contract he got. He is a great player, great guy. But I aint paying him that much.....
AP? I pay AP.

 

[Dave_in-NC]

If I'm against anything the smart money is to go with me I have plenty of archived posts that will verify it. What's smart about letting your MVP from last season go and allowing them to sign with your rival you've battled for the division title with for the past 2 seasons and sign an LB to a one year deal who's facing a suspension?

I hated letting Murray walk. But RBs can be replaced easier than DEs. Hardy even though he might miss four games is still going to lift this defense way up. Lawrence showed at the end of the year to. We don't need 1800 yards to win. We do need to cut down the time QBs had to pick us apart.
We just added that piece.

 

[Sarge]

Hardy.

 

[Sarge]

I feel like it's always harder to find a pass rusher than a RB.

You feel that way because you are correct.

 

[The Quest for Six]

neither, one is a criminal and the other is way overpaid

 

[Rockport]

Who would you rather have :

Demarco Murray or Greg Hardy?

My answer is Murray , we really dropped the ball here. However I think we could have easily had both with a restructure.

This off season feels slapped together.

There's no doubt it would be Hardy. In order to win in the NFL you have to build the trenches first and have a better than average DE, QB, OL, DL.

 

[Gameover]

Murray and Hardy >>>>>>> healthy and productive Sean Lee

Lee's contract is the monkey wrench in all of this.

 

[NeonNinja]

It's Hardy. You can like Murray and everything, but take the elite rusher every single time.

 

[Fletch]

Who would you rather have :

Demarco Murray or Greg Hardy?

My answer is Murray , we really dropped the ball here. However I think we could have easily had both with a restructure.

This off season feels slapped together.

You just said it. Murray already dropped/fumbled the ball. Must have been a key situation.

 

[SilverStarCowboy]

Who would you rather have :

Demarco Murray or Greg Hardy?

My answer is Murray , we really dropped the ball here. However I think we could have easily had both with a restructure.

This off season feels slapped together.

Hardy for certain. DE impacts the game on a higher level and elite RBs are easier to come by than stand out DEs. Especially when considering availability in the FA Market and NFL Draft.

You love Murray but there are plenty of RiBs available right now.