would you trade our #2 for Culpepper??

superpunk

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,330
Reaction score
75
Bledsoe4MVP said:
Bledstudsoe

THAT !!!!!!!!


is what you need to stop. I like Bledsoe, I really do, but the homoerotic hero worship is tired and played out already. If you want to defend Bledsoe against the bashers, use facts, and a halfway reasonable argument. It'll go alot farther than "Bledstudsoe's deadly assassin arm" arguments.
 

joseephuss

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,041
Reaction score
6,920
Bledsoe4MVP said:
WE ALREADY HAVE ONE OF THE BEST QB's IN THE LEAGUE AND HE'S MUCH BETTER THAN CULPEPPER! PLEASE STOP WITH THESE STUPID THREADS!:mad:

Don't read them.

Bledose throws the ball better. I don't know about that. Culpepper completes a higher percentage of passes(64.4% to 57.3%), for more yards per attempt(7.73 to 6.64) and has a higher QB rating(91.5 to 77.3).

In 80 starts Culpepper has passed for 135 TDs and run for 29 more, which is 2.05 TDs per game.

In 187 starts Bledsoe has passed for 244 TDs and run for 8 more, which is 1.35 TDs per game.
 

Bledsoe4MVP

Benched
Messages
907
Reaction score
0
joseephuss said:
Don't read them.

Bledose throws the ball better. I don't know about that. Culpepper completes a higher percentage of passes(64.4% to 57.3%), for more yards per attempt(7.73 to 6.64) and has a higher QB rating(91.5 to 77.3).

In 80 starts Culpepper has passed for 135 TDs and run for 29 more, which is 2.05 TDs per game.

In 187 starts Bledsoe has passed for 244 TDs and run for 8 more, which is 1.35 TDs per game.

So your stats may say something....but how many superbowls has Culpepper been too? How many seasons has he gone without missing multiple games due to injury? How did he do last year without Randy Moss who makes any QB look like Joe Montana? How many times has he singlehandedly willed his team to victory???:mad:
 

1fisher

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,777
Reaction score
120
Juke99 said:
Perhaps but I'm sure your posts are just as good, if not better, than before your injury. :D

:laugh2: :laugh2: :laugh2:
 

Thick 'N Hearty

Active Member
Messages
2,359
Reaction score
0
Bledsoe4MVP said:
So your stats may say something....but how many superbowls has Culpepper been too? How many seasons has he gone without missing multiple games due to injury? How did he do last year without Randy Moss who makes any QB look like Joe Montana? How many times has he singlehandedly willed his team to victory???:mad:

Dude, you have a little Bledsoe milk running down your chin. Clean it up and carry on.
 

Eddie

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,092
Reaction score
5,862
Bledsoe4MVP said:
How did he do last year without Randy Moss who makes any QB look like Joe Montana? How many times has he singlehandedly willed his team to victory???:mad:


W???

Randy Moss got Kerry Collins and Norv Turner kicked out of Oakland.

Think before you preach.
 

ravidubey

Active Member
Messages
4,879
Reaction score
20
Eddie said:
I'd trade Dexter Coakley and a 4th rounder for Culpepper.

Ok, in all seriousness, we went a 3rd rounder for bench warmer Hensen. A 2nd seems very reasonable for Culpepper.

The only issue with Dante is his MASSIVE salary. Not sure we want to invest $100 mil on one player. We'll be back in the same boat as 2001 when Troy, Emmitt, and Michael's salaries were 60% of the team's salary cap ... and we had no money to bring in support other than minimum wage guys off the street.

Wouldn't the Vikings have to absorb the unamortized portion of his signing bonus? That would mean we could release him at any time without repurcussions beyond having paid his salary for the games he was on the roster.
 

WoodysGirl

U.N.I.T.Y
Staff member
Messages
79,281
Reaction score
45,652
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Culpepper says he's focusing on rehab, nothing else

ESPN.com news services


Rumors abound that Daunte Culpepper wants out of Minnesota and that the Vikings might be willing to make that happen.

On Thursday, the quarterback responded to the talk in an e-mail to ESPN's Andrea Kremer, saying he's focusing on his rehab and he refuses to waste his energy on the speculation.

"Because I am getting so many requests to comment about reported trade talks, I thought it best to make a clear statement that hopefully won't be misinterpreted. I have found over the years that 'people with knowledge of the situation' are usually the most ignorant, and 'anonymous sources' are usually synonymous with cowards who don't want to go on the record," Culpepper wrote.

"My position has been and continues to be that I am focusing on rehabilitating my knee so that I can come back and play the game I love at the highest level. Until I hear different from [Vikings owner Zygi Wilf] or the new 'triangle of authority' at the Vikings I plan on playing quarterback for Minnesota. Trying to delve into speculation, innuendo, rumor or anything else of this nature would be a waste of energy. I choose at this time to spend my energy on getting healthy."

The Star Tribune reported Thursday that the Vikings are gauging his trade value around the NFL.

A source told The Star Tribune that the Vikings began shopping Culpepper around the league after the quarterback asked that $10 million be added to his contract in 2006.
The newspaper reported that Wilf angrily turned down Culpepper's request and no substantive talks between the two sides has taken place since.

Culpepper, who is recovering from major knee surgery after tearing his anterior cruciate, medial collateral and posterior cruciate ligaments in a game against the Panthers on Oct. 30, parted ways with his longtime agent, Mason Ashe, last month.

Culpepper has been seldom seen around Minnesota since the injury, spending most of his time rehabilitating in his native Florida.

New coach Brad Childress, who was hired to replace the fired Mike Tice, tried to connect with Culpepper when they were both in town in January. But Childress had to settle for a 45-minute phone conversation, which he described as a "good flow on information back and forth" but declined to characterize the tone.

Further complicating Minnesota's offseason, Brad Johnson has also stressed his desire to remain a starter.

Wilf has said he plans to keep both of them. Due $6 million in bonuses in March, Culpepper is expected to be ready to participate in training camp -- but that's not a guarantee given the severity of his injury.

Information from The Associated Press was used in this report.


Link
 

superpunk

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,330
Reaction score
75
WoodysGirl said:
I have found over the years that 'people with knowledge of the situation' are usually the most ignorant, and 'anonymous sources' are usually synonymous with cowards who don't want to go on the record," Culpepper wrote.

That....is......AWESOME!!!!!!
 

Derinyar

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,231
Reaction score
959
If you can get Culpepper for a 2nd, I think you have to roll the dice. Its a reasonable gamble.
 

Bledsoe4MVP

Benched
Messages
907
Reaction score
0
Derinyar said:
If you can get Culpepper for a 2nd, I think you have to roll the dice. Its a reasonable gamble.

I repeat.....WE DON'T NEED QB, NOR IS IT A NEED RIGHT NOW.

If we are going to be trading 2nd round draft picks I'd rather have it be part of a deal to sign a guy like Bentley of Hutchison if they get tagged.:mad:
 

Alexander

What's it going to be then, eh?
Messages
62,482
Reaction score
67,294
Eddie said:
W???

Randy Moss got Kerry Collins and Norv Turner kicked out of Oakland.

Think before you preach.

The Raiders released Kerry Collins?

When did this happen?
 

Derinyar

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,231
Reaction score
959
Bledsoe4MVP said:
I repeat.....WE DON'T NEED QB, NOR IS IT A NEED RIGHT NOW.

If we are going to be trading 2nd round draft picks I'd rather have it be part of a deal to sign a guy like Bentley of Hutchison if they get tagged.:mad:
So you advocate never looking forward in any way? Bledsoe is a decent enough option. Culpepper is younger, and likely would be on the PUP list to start the year. Right now we have one QB who actually has more than a handful of legit NFL snaps, and hes only got one year on his contract and is approaching his mid 30's with a lot of hits on him.

IF you don't have a franchise level QB, then one can legitmately make an argument that its always a need. Culpepper could become a franchise QB for us for the next 5-7 years. If we can get that for a 2nd round pick, then its a good gamble. If your willing to bypass that because of your agenda with one player, then get yourself under control.
 

Bledsoe4MVP

Benched
Messages
907
Reaction score
0
Derinyar said:
So you advocate never looking forward in any way? Bledsoe is a decent enough option. Culpepper is younger, and likely would be on the PUP list to start the year. Right now we have one QB who actually has more than a handful of legit NFL snaps, and hes only got one year on his contract and is approaching his mid 30's with a lot of hits on him.

IF you don't have a franchise level QB, then one can legitmately make an argument that its always a need. Culpepper could become a franchise QB for us for the next 5-7 years. If we can get that for a 2nd round pick, then its a good gamble. If your willing to bypass that because of your agenda with one player, then get yourself under control.

I have no problem looking forward to the future....when it's time to do so. Culpepper is only a few years younger and has spent half his career on the bench with injuries so far. I'd rather draft or sign a young prospect.

We have a franchise level QB right now and he's good for at least the next two years assuming his durability stays in tact. This move doesn't make sense, plain and simple...especially because Culpepper is a starting QB not a back up.

Besides there's already numerous articles surfacing today around the net that dispel this crazy RUMOR, because that's all it is. Culpepper has every intention on staying a Viking:

http://www.nfl.com/teams/story/MIN/9241189
 

5Stars

Here comes the Sun...
Messages
37,847
Reaction score
16,869
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
:lmao:

Methinks someone is afraid of Studpepper coming to Dallas, if that were to happen! I mean, what would she do if somehow CulStud were to beat out the current QB? :lmao2:
 

Derinyar

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,231
Reaction score
959
Bledsoe4MVP said:
I have no problem looking forward to the future....when it's time to do so. Culpepper is only a few years younger and has spent half his career on the bench with injuries so far. I'd rather draft or sign a young prospect.

We have a franchise level QB right now and he's good for at least the next two years assuming his durability stays in tact. This move doesn't make sense, plain and simple...especially because Culpepper is a starting QB not a back up.

Besides there's already numerous articles surfacing today around the net that dispel this crazy RUMOR, because that's all it is. Culpepper has every intention on staying a Viking:

http://www.nfl.com/teams/story/MIN/9241189
I'm sorry, Bledsoe right now is not a franchise QB. He was, or at least was close, earlier in his career. Right now he seems to be really good for about hlaf a season. I'll give him somewhat of a pass on last year, because of the second half line problems.

34 vs 29 is a large age difference in pro sports. One is in prime of the career the other is nearing the end of a career.

Culpepper is a starting calibur QB, but one who quite likely isn't going to be ready till at least the back half of the season, due to that horrible knee injury. So you look at him as either a backup or on the pup list for part of the season.

If you want to compare Culpeppers bad years to Bledsoe's career average, they are rather comperable, at least by yardage/QB rating. I just think that Culpepper likely wouldn't be an upgrade for this year, but how often for a 2nd round pick can you likely pick up someone who would be a big upgrade at QB for the next year
 

ghst187

Well-Known Member
Messages
15,722
Reaction score
11,572
Hostile said:
I'll take the bulk of his career over 1 partial season.

With every trade there is caveat emptor (buyer beware). I say no guts, no glory.

When he's right, this kid is a top 10 QB. I think he'll be right again.

I disagree, Culpepper looked great with Randy Moss and crappy without.
But heck, so did EVERY other backup QB that Minny plugged in to their offense, heck even Jeff George.
Once Randy left, the Vikings were HORRIBLE and Culpepper was HORRIBLE. Then he got hurt and all of a sudden Johnson gets the Vikings back to winning, the very same offense that Culpepper couldn't make work.
Plus, I'm not sure what we'd do with Culpepper, no way he's beating out Bledsoe or Brady Quinn when we draft him next year.
and also I can't stand Culpepper's stupid little dance, its horribly horribly gay.
 

Wolf2k5

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,565
Reaction score
1,246
Hostile said:
I'll take the bulk of his career over 1 partial season.

With every trade there is caveat emptor (buyer beware). I say no guts, no glory.

When he's right, this kid is a top 10 QB. I think he'll be right again.

BS to him being top 10 qb. i can name at least 10 qb's id rather have on my team than him. He doesnt have moss and i dont think he is as great a qb without a wr u can throw in his general direction and he'll catch it. moss made him look above average.

these qbs id rather have than him. no particular order. but just an example he not top 10 material. peyton, brady, palmer, brees, b roth (ignore super bowl tho lol) mcnabb, hasselbeck, Delhomme, t green, and bledsoe. hell id rather have randel el throwin the ball than him. no disrespect just think he overated for as much money we'd have to spend on him
 
Top