Well since he hasn't had time to coach even ONE game, he hasn't had a chance to "overshadow" anybody yet. But I'll tell ya what, I'd place my bets on McCarthy ANY day compared to Garrett.
As for "a handful of aged DL, two kickers, the misfit MIA Smith and" ??? You can't replace a whole team in just one off season, let alone before the draft no less!
And as for "NFCCG appearance, win and a sb appearance" plus a SB WIN, MM has been there/done that already.
Garrett has never even sniffed either one.
Like I said, I'll place my bets on McCarthy long before the likes of Garrett..
Miss the point much?
seriously to say hes better when he was fired from his last team and that team then became winner again without him and the organization and qb he left were saying the same things we say about Garett , and here all the talk about obvious change is so ridiculous because he hasn't done one thing we KNOW about that is different is all speculation, as the same holes would have needed to be filled give the same FAs were on defense and Will and Jerry most likely would have brought in the same players. think about the narrative most of the bad moves all seemed to be jerrys fault, bad Gm they say, UMM, Will and Jerry are still here and still making the decsions, we have zero idea that any of these players brought in this off season were influenced by MM or Nolan..Also to that perspective this team has brought in many great Players in the past and we've had some great regular seasons and have have division wins, first round byes with garett,, so until that CHANGES , ID SLOW THE PRASIES OF THE NEW STAFF UNTIL WE SEE THEM IN THE TRUE Heat OF BATTLES, IN LIVE GAMES WHEN THE CHIPS ARE DOWN..LETS SEE THIS OBVIOUS CHANGE OF PHILOSOPHY IN GAME PLANS, PLAY CALLING , AND WHEN THE GAME PLAN FALLS APART, HOW MANY OF THOSE GAMES DO WE WIN..Lets witness how a player havig horrible day is subbed in or who they use when a crucial player gets hurt..this doesnt happen in an off season yet every play or every game we will see posts about how things are so different, until they arent because those narratives will only change in the playoffs..
fans are joke , rip garret and praise MM before he does one tangible thing for this team.. like I said throw a stale cracker to a starving person and they would praise that cracker like it was homemade bread..
tap the breaks and lets see 2-3 seasons of actual change, if MM doesnt get us past a second round and at least one SB appearance and its pretty much the same . Fans wanted JG gone so badly now they are giving credit for every little move this off season to MM, lets see how long that lasts when the players have to execute an dont..we no longer have Garett to blame and in my view most of the big losses weve had in games that mattered, 80% of the blame fell squarely on the players, not the coaches..lets see if this changes.
Im glad we have a new direction and some new hope but that all it is at this point..