Qb rankings

kskboys

Well-Known Member
Messages
44,666
Reaction score
47,526
Exactly. He has been so bad he has to drop. For the same reason Brady and Rodgers should drop as welll.
Yup. If you are rating QBs as to how they are playing right now, Brady and Rodgers are not in the top 10.
 

Gangsta Spanksta

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,792
Reaction score
8,787
So now your back to cherry picking again?

How come you werent posting these kinds of rankings last year when Dak had a full season to show his stuff?

Your agenda is showing buddy.

I only posted a ranking here, after criticizing the OP for ranking Dak way too low. Perhaps reading the thread and having a full comprehension of what someone has said would do you some good before making claims. And since you say my agenda is showing, what exactly is my agenda? Why not spell it out? At least I'm not Crushing on anybody here.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
I only posted a ranking here, after criticizing the OP for ranking Dak way too low. Perhaps reading the thread and having a full comprehension of what someone has said would do you some good before making claims. And since you say my agenda is showing, what exactly is my agenda? Why not spell it out? At least I'm not Crushing on anybody here.

So where do you have Dak ranked as a QB in the NFL?
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
I think the NFL Ranking is pretty fair. I have to see more from Dak to see how good of a player he is without Amari Cooper, who made him better.

What is the NFL ranking?

Cooper didnt make him better he simply needed more to throw to than a bunch of scrubs. Dak was good before Cooper every got here. The guy has been in the NFL 6 years. I would think you would know by now where is on a list.
 

Gangsta Spanksta

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,792
Reaction score
8,787
What is the NFL ranking?

Cooper didnt make him better he simply needed more to throw to than a bunch of scrubs. Dak was good before Cooper every got here. The guy has been in the NFL 6 years. I would think you would know by now where is on a list.

The NFL.Com list that I linked to here at least two times already. Dak didn't have his best games before we traded for Cooper. A whole big thing was made about the Cooper trade was worth it because it revived Dak when he was in a downward trend. We've seen Cooper make adjustments before on some badly thrown passes. Dak's season premier game was horrid, several people thought that Dak has regressed. As stated before, just because someone ranks say #8 on year on a ranking list means that he ranks there the next year. That goes against the whole concept that players can improve or regress as well as age or become injury prone. Heck some people on here noted that Brady and Rodgers deserve to be lower on the list because of not being the same players that they once were. If you think it is unfair to rank Dak very low because he has been injured, then it is also unfair to automatically assume he is Top 10 in the league currently based on two games one of which he played very poorly in, the other which he just barely won against the worst team in the NFL. He certainly isn't as bad as the OP has made him out to be, but then I stand by my assertion that so far this season I wouldn't rank Dak above Hurts either.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
The NFL.Com list that I linked to here at least two times already. Dak didn't have his best games before we traded for Cooper. A whole big thing was made about the Cooper trade was worth it because it revived Dak when he was in a downward trend. We've seen Cooper make adjustments before on some badly thrown passes. Dak's season premier game was horrid, several people thought that Dak has regressed. As stated before, just because someone ranks say #8 on year on a ranking list means that he ranks there the next year. That goes against the whole concept that players can improve or regress as well as age or become injury prone. Heck some people on here noted that Brady and Rodgers deserve to be lower on the list because of not being the same players that they once were. If you think it is unfair to rank Dak very low because he has been injured, then it is also unfair to automatically assume he is Top 10 in the league currently based on two games one of which he played very poorly in, the other which he just barely won against the worst team in the NFL. He certainly isn't as bad as the OP has made him out to be, but then I stand by my assertion that so far this season I wouldn't rank Dak above Hurts either.

Ah yes, back to cherry picking. Seems all you got buddy. Gonna need more than that to take me on and prove Dak is average. I have 6 years of data on Dak.

Ranking Dak at all this season is pretty much a joke. But again, its all you got.

And please stop with the, you like Dak nonsense. You have been a Dak hating troll forever.
 

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind
Messages
57,108
Reaction score
35,171
whats so funny?

You honestly can’t see the humor? Russell Wilson is having a rough year in Denver and is clearly on the decline. He was on the decline in Seattle. All Justin Fields can do is run go check out his passing numbers. He’s looking like a bust. Ryan Tannehill got benched a few weeks ago in a game. Tennessee will likely be looking for a new QB during the offseason. Mac Jones hasn’t played well and got benched last week. Although Daniel Jones has shown some improvement no way is he ahead of Dak. Trevor Lawrence has been inconsistent in Jacksonville and doesn’t look like near the QB he was made out to be coming out of college. No one who has a clue about football would rank any of those QBs ahead of Dak. You’re the only one who took exception to my post. Lol
 

Acceptablename

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,339
Reaction score
1,566
1. Mahomes
2. Allen
3. Rodgers
4. Brady
5. Jackson
6. Burrow
7. Herbert
8. Hurts
9.F Lawrence
10. Stafford
11. Murray
12. Carr
13. Wilson
14. Garropolo
15. Cousins
16. Tannehill
17. Fields
18. Tua
19. Fields
20. Jones (nyg)
21. Jones (ne)
22. Dak
23. Goff
24. Mariota
25. Pickett
26. Wentz
27. Brissett
28. Wilson
29. Ryan
30. Walker
31. Mills
32. Dalton

Factoring in overall qb ability, age and contract.
Dak is better then all the guys up to Stafford.
 

Gangsta Spanksta

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,792
Reaction score
8,787
Ah yes, back to cherry picking. Seems all you got buddy. Gonna need more than that to take me on and prove Dak is average. I have 6 years of data on Dak.

Ranking Dak at all this season is pretty much a joke. But again, its all you got.

And please stop with the, you like Dak nonsense. You have been a Dak hating troll forever.

Geez ;) Do a lot of circular conversations? We were talking about this season, so far, Dak hasn't been "top 10" or even "top 5" like some of the homers have made him out to be. We are also talking about a dynamic week to week rating while you are talking about a static rating where Dak is always in the Top 10, no mater what. And just because it hurts your feelings that Dak is being ranked, because of his woes, that wouldn't stop a league wide ranking from happening. The ranking had Dak ranked as NR last week because of his injury. Only a homer would rank him #8 as soon as he comes back, but only had some questionable games so far this season. My opinion of Dak has gone up and down at various stages of his career. In 2016 I thought him and wentz were going to be the future big names in the league, but he doesn't fall in that Tier. Right now I don't think he is the future of the Dallas Cowboys, he isn't in his prime anymore and now he is getting injured a lot. I can be honest about my opinion of the guy. I don't hate Dak but then again at least I don't have a man crush either.
 

Arkyvarminter

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,466
Reaction score
1,862
You honestly can’t see the humor? Russell Wilson is having a rough year in Denver and is clearly on the decline. He was on the decline in Seattle. All Justin Fields can do is run go check out his passing numbers. He’s looking like a bust. Ryan Tannehill got benched a few weeks ago in a game. Tennessee will likely be looking for a new QB during the offseason. Mac Jones hasn’t played well and got benched last week. Although Daniel Jones has shown some improvement no way is he ahead of Dak. Trevor Lawrence has been inconsistent in Jacksonville and doesn’t look like near the QB he was made out to be coming out of college. No one who has a clue about football would rank any of those QBs ahead of Dak. You’re the only one who took exception to my post. Lol
LOL hell.....Trevor is in a terrible situation...Lets see how many rings does Russell have?... As for players being benched their not making 40 million a year. Jerry wouldn't pull Dak if he was really stinking it up and he's really stunk it up...U want to bet that Trevor doesn't go somewhere else and perform? Dak can't get it done so why not?
 

KJJ

You Have an Axe to Grind
Messages
57,108
Reaction score
35,171
LOL hell.....Trevor is in a terrible situation...Let’s see how many rings does Russell have?... As for players being benched they’re not making 40 million a year. Jerry wouldn't pull Dak if he was really stinking it up and he's really stunk it up...U want to bet that Trevor doesn't go somewhere else and perform? Dak can't get it done so why not?

It doesn’t matter what situation Trevor Lawrence is in he’s in his second season and still isn’t playing consistently. I’ve watched some of his games and he’s missing throws to wide open receivers. Troy Aikman was in a terrible situation when he arrived in Dallas but he still made a lot of great plays. Andrew Luck turned a terrible Colts team into a playoff contender in one season. You’re still caught up with the hype Trevor Lawrence had coming out of college. He hasn’t come close to living up to it. As for Russell Wilson it doesn’t matter that he has a championship ring that was years ago. LOL! He’s not the same player he was 8 years ago. ..get real! Everyone thought he would make Denver a championship contender and it hasn’t happened because he’s not the same player. This is why Seattle moved on from him. As for Dak he didn’t stink it up last week. He played very well in the second half leading us to a win. You need to try opening your eyes.
 
Top