Aikman: "If I were Tony, I'd want to play this week"

Well from Tony's earlier speech you could tell he has his bags packed, decision already made, etc. so Jerry just wants his shiny coin to stay shiny so he can trade him and dump the contract in the off-season.

I'm fine with that if that is indeed the thinking. Just have a backup available so that this decision doesn't negatively impact your starter and risk him to unnecessary injury.

A guy like Mark Sanchez, maybe?
;)
 
Earlier in the season it made no sense to play Tony. It makes sense to play him now, however. It would give him some reps and help him shake the rust off. Even quality veterans are rusty after not having played a while. The sole reason to play him is to get him ready in case Dak is injured in the playoffs and Tony needs to come in and lead the team. Yes, it's try playing Tony risks getting him injured, but if he were injured it would be way better to have that happen in a game that doesn't count so that we can get Sanchez ready to back up Dak. It risks ruining his trade value of he's injured, but his trade value isn't that high anyway as an older, oft-injured quarterback. It's likely we release him anyway instead of trading him.

Play him. Give him one last hurrah for the team he carried so long, and get him ready for the playoffs.

I have a feeling that Tony's last hoorah with the Cowboys was when he got hurt in preseason. Since getting hurt against the Eagles last year in the 2nd game of the season he has played 1 full game against Miami that was not too impressive. He had 2 TDs but also 2 ints with a QBR of 60.8 and then he followed that up with a few quarters of play (before getting hurt again) against Carolina with 0 TDs and 3 ints and a QBR of 4.9. The next time we see him is against the Seahawks in preseason where he is in for a few plays before getting hurt again. Are you noticing a trend? Personally I think Romo is done and we will be lucky if we can get anyhting for him in the offseason. We better keep 3 QBs active in the playoffs because if Dak gets hurt then I would not be very surprised if Romo went down with an injury pretty quickly.
 
So would you and alot of other people on this board.
Ummmno because unlike some Romo fans we support the team. If Tony had to go in for the playoffs we would root for him to win a SB like we always have. Unfortunately he's never come close. No sense wasting him in a meaningless game
 
Last edited:
So would you and alot of other people on this board.
exactly....much more important to protect our backup rather than our starter as well as secure that conditional 4th rounder we're going to get in next years draft. Besides, backups taking every opportunity to be as prepared as possible is overrated. /s
 
exactly....much more important to protect our backup rather than our starter as well as secure that conditional 4th rounder we're going to get in next years draft. Besides, backups taking every opportunity to be as prepared as possible is overrated. /s

Atleast you admit it.
 
I just get a kick out of some. I still can't get over it. We're 13-2 have the #1 seed locked up. We have a brand new young QB that's taken the league by storm and there are still some Cowboy fans that are miserable.
 
It's not hogwash. I know how I feel, you don't. Maybe you're looking in the mirror and seeing something you don't like. I'm fine.

LOL right. You are "a picture is worth a thousand words" kinda guy.

I've read your posts and know where you stand on things and there is no doubt in my mind that if Romo did play this Sunday and got hurt, a small part of you would be down right giddy.

And you wouldn't be alone either.
 
LOL right. You are "a picture is worth a thousand words" kinda guy.

I've read your posts and know where you stand on things and there is no doubt in my mind that if Romo did play this Sunday and got hurt, a small part of you would be down right giddy.

And you wouldn't be alone either.
And on to ignore you go. Say high to Matt for me.
 
I'm sure Tony want to play.
It's just not smart to play him.

What's not smart is suiting him up as the backup and not allowing him to sharpen up his game a little incase he's needed in the playoffs. If the team is so fearful of him being injured that they're terrified to give him a few snaps to try and work off some rust he shouldn't be the backup QB. He won't be here next season and the last memory we'll have of him is laying on the field with a broken back in Seattle. Two of the worst moments of his career happened in Seattle.
 
Atleast you admit it.
I've heard of spontaneous human combustion, that would really fire up the team.

Get real, this is about the 2016 Cowboys and having every component of the team, including Romo, being as prepared and ready as possible.
 
Given his recent track record of injury, how can you blame anyone who thinks it's likely to happen again?
I don't blame anyone for considering the possibility. I do blame anyone for using that belief as a discussion defense because it's weak.

In my opinion, Romo will play on another team next year. However, the discussion defense tactic infers that Romo cannot leave Dallas because he *will* suffer a *debilitating injury* playing elsewhere, which is a possibly but not a certainty.

Additionally, the discussion defense tactic is used whenever the possibility of Prescott suffering a temporary or season ending injury is introduced into conversation, *validating* that Romo's re-introduction into the offense would be meaningless since he would get knocked off the field immediately. Could happen but there is only one way of knowing that is a certainty.

Conversely, the discussion defense tactic has been employed but quickly followed up by inferences that Romo's re-introduction into the offense would be fruitless because he would be the cause of a regular season or post season loss because of an *expected* interception(s) or fumble(s)--which is illogically based since he would not be physically capable of doing either IF he were sidelined immediately after taking the field. Again, there is only one way to validate such concern.

The Romo Concern is just one of a several past, present, and most likely future arguments that are fueled by resentment and fear. It's an unnecessary slight against him. It's an unnecessary discussion affiliation for Prescott. While it does wield power within media discussion because the media uses it for personal gain, it should not factor among public opinion in my sole opinion. Why? It should have played out a long long LONG time ago. It definitely should have played out once the franchise decided to not disrupt *team chemistry*. And yet, it lives on today. And robustly so.
 
I've heard of spontaneous human combustion, that would really fire up the team.

Get real, this is about the 2016 Cowboys and having every component of the team, including Romo, being as prepared and ready as possible.

Oh I agree.

But it still doesn't make the original point not true, and that's sad.
 
I just get a kick out of some. I still can't get over it. We're 13-2 have the #1 seed locked up. We have a brand new young QB that's taken the league by storm and there are still some Cowboy fans that are miserable.

Why are you assuming they're miserable? Because their view differs from yours?

I swear, I'm not sure that straw-men feel more at home anywhere in the world than they do on these forums.
 
Back
Top