No he is not. The only thing that Sean has done is win a Superbowl with arguably the greatest QB of all time....I could have done that. With that same QB he has had 3 losing records and the last 2 seasons he has had the best team in the NFC with Drew Brees and has underachieved. Oh and dont forget his SB is tainted with the suspension for bounty gate.
Meanwhile JG has been dealing Mr Glass (Romo) since he has been named HC. Life after Mr Glass has not been any better. He had to replace Mr Glass with a 4th round rookie QB and JG did pretty good. Patyon with a better QB and team did no better. Zeke misses 6 games we still have a winning record; Payton has the best team in the NFC and players were not prepared in the biggest moment of their season that same year. And we know what JG did this season and how Sean once again had the best team in the NFC and most of the players are so mentally weak that they are still blaming the refs for losing the game when really it was coaching.
You live in a world of make believe if you think Payton is a good coach.
1. Brees isnt arguably the greatest QB of all time
2. Payton actually beat one of the Greatest QBs of all time in the Super Bowl
3. No you could not have done that
4. He has been able to get his team to multiple NFC CGs while Garrett hasnt gotten us to one
5. Garrett is now the longest tenured coach in the NFL, without a Super Bowl
6. Garrett struggles with in-game adjustments which costs us over and over against superior coaches
Shall i Continue, JG?