Gurley isn't Richardson. Gurley is arguably the best RB prospect since AD himself. Kid is a beast.
A beast who has a nagging injury every year that either knocks him out of games or makes him miss the entire season.
I save the "beast" label to players that can stay on the field and play at a high level. That goes to Gordon.
Here's a great post from a Dolphins fan (I don't want to take the credit)
"Of course the "statistic" or I don't know if you want to call it that but whatever it is, the point that might trump all points is this.
1. Todd Gurley missed almost a half of a game in Week 1 of 2013 with a hip flexor injury which went on to affect him the whole year.
2. Gurley then took an ankle injury in Week 5 of 2013, missing half of the game as well as the following 3 games.
3. He missed almost a half a game in his Week 10 return from the ankle injury with "nausea that accompanied his return from injury".
4. Fast-forward to preseason 2014, there's rumor Gurley dealt with a knee injury during the preseason.
5. Then even though he hadn't played in a month due to suspension, he was seen wearing a huge elbow brace in his return against Auburn.
6. Finally he takes the ACL injury with 5 minutes left to play in the Auburn game in 2014.
When Todd Gurley returned from the ankle injury in 2013, the Bulldogs had him averaging less than 15 yards per carry after returning from injury, admitting they were trying to strike a balance between his impact and getting him to be healthy into the fourth quarter.
As of December 30th, 2013 his coach Mark Richt noted "He's still not where he was the first time he galloped down the field at Clemson (Week 1). Remember that vision and that look? I don't think he's there."
Gurley himself hinted that the Week 5 ankle injury was so bad it threatened to see him shelved the rest of the year: "I missed some games, but I could have been out the whole year. I guess I'm lucky I was able to come back and still play"
Four of Georgia's five losses in 2013 came with Todd Gurley out, sidelined for a significant chunk of the game, or limited due to injury concerns. The strained quad in Week 1 against Clemson caused him to sit the rest of the game after his 12th carry. They lost the game 35-38. Then they lost to Missouri (26-41) and Vanderbilt (27-41) while he sat out with the ankle injury. They lost to Auburn 38-43 with Gurley limited to 15 carries due to not wanting to wear him out.
How was the feel of Gurley's season to teammates? “I feel like this year sort of got taken from him because of the injuries,” (Jordan Jenkins).
How about some subtle hints from teammates that Gurley needs to prepare better if he wants to make it through the season healthier?
“The sky’s the limit for that guy,” offensive guard Chris Burnette said. “
Him having another year to train and get prepared, he’ll probably make this year and last year look like nothing.”Or...
Junior receiver Chris Conley plans to
make sure Gurley stays on top of things this offseason.
“
I’m not going to be letting up on him at all,” Conley said. “He’s going to be coming in here with me every day. Then I expect him to ball out. Kid’s an extreme talent.”How much was the "injury prone" label stuck onto Todd Gurley BEFORE he tore his ACL in 2014? Two things. Georgia took out an insurance policy on his behalf which pays up to $5 million should he get injured in a way that affects his draft status ("loss of value"), and another $5 million if he never plays again. You can also find articles dated August 2014 titled "Todd Gurley takes offense to being called injury-prone"."
Again, I don't see scouts overlooking this stuff. They do more thorough checks than the average fan and draft analyst.