CZ POLL Are you happy with Mike McCarthy as the Head Coach of the Dallas Cowboys?

[DaleMc]

No, MM cannot seem to have his teams prepared for big games and he continues to produce undisciplined teams year after year. Sure, three 12 win seasons in a row is impressive but crapping the bed in the post season is depressing. I don't see MM being able to take this team further than this and that is not good enough.

 

[Rayman70]

for anyone that answered YES...I will personally escort you off the board.

 

[big dog cowboy]

The level of which the Cowboys got outcoached last Sunday should give everyone reason for concern.

Add it to his playoff history in Dallas and

 

[Beast_from_East]

Fat Mike was not hired to win division titles, we were doing that with Clappy.

Fat Mike was hired to do what Clappy never could do, advance the team in the playoffs.

He has failed.

Fire his arse.

 

[efh313]

This one was tough. There were mistakes, but three 12-5 seasons is nothing to sniff at. I truly believe that having a boss that micromanages and “holds your hand” is detrimental to any job, especially the HC of our Dallas Cowboys. For that reason I say yes and pray that Jerry FINALLY learns a lesson…
There will be no championship without a culture change. Period.

 

[G2]

Whatever coaching changes occur, lower your bar of expectation because it will NOT be an instant success.

 

[Section446]

Never liked him to begin with...

 

[zeke21]

Was happy (very) when he first signed and I think he was an improvement over the clapper.. but he isn't going to cut it. The reasons for me are his inability to manage the clock, the inability to fix our penalty issues.. the inability to have the team 'ready' in big games (we have heard that excuse before)..

And the fact that he got outcoached against GB.. no hiding from it.. he got a bath. I will acknowledge he was a great coach.. he has a SB and deserves credit but he hasn't been able to do the job. He lied to get the gig and nothing much has changed.

Time for a fresh start (and yes I've voted no consistently before the disaster)

 

[raven55]

I laughed at the coach and the team, i knew just like a great deal if you buy a lemon you get a lemon

 

[CowboysInPurgatory]

36 wins out of this team in the last three regular seasons, nothing to sneeze at, so credit has to go to Mike for that but the offensive line, the defense, running game and penalties needs fixing

Great draft pick on taking Mazi Smith in the first round to stop the run! It would have been dumb to trade out or sign another veteran run stopper. Maybe we could bring back Taco! HA

 

[morat1959]

This is the same reason why I voted for him to stay!

Tom Landry would have been waiting tables in a restaurant if he had Dak as QB.

Maybe Tom, Vince, Don, Chuck and the Bill’s would have worked together.

 

[jgboys1]

Maybe Tom, Vince, Don, Chuck and the Bill’s would have worked together.

They still wouldn’t be able to get Dak to play well in a playoff game.

 

[morat1959]

They still wouldn’t be able to get Dak to play well in a playoff game.

I was talking about in the restaurant if Dak was their QB! Lol

 

[The Quest for Six]

Great draft pick on taking Mazi Smith in the first round to stop the run! It would have been dumb to trade out or sign another veteran run stopper. Maybe we could bring back Taco! HA

Will McClay makes the draft pick, not the head coach....and one year doesn't make a career...

 

[cityochamps]

That isn't the goal. The Cowboys could have went 17-0 in each of the last 3 seasons. That isn't the goal either. It's not what he was hired to do.

Additionally he embarrassed the entire franchise (and fan base) with the way each of the last 3 seasons ended.

Ok let me see if I understand you correctly, Keep firing really good coaches who's team lead the league in scorring, was 3rd in the league in passing and recieving and won 12 games including winning the NFCE until you get to your goal 17-0 or win the Super Bowl. Now that's embarrassing.
You should be asking what happened to our defense and how we went from one of the best in the league to a 9th place overall finish.

 

[CowboysInPurgatory]

Will McClay makes the draft pick, not the head coach....and one year doesn't make a career...

Sure did for Taco....Will McClay "makes the draft picks" meaning he calls the players after Jerry and Stephen approve. We all know that

 

[DallasEast]

A 'no vote' in my first poll on the topic.

 

[jgboys1]

 

[quickccc]

Ironically the HC, play caller and QB are on the same boat, and face same storm.

They will have great Win numbers in regular season, ..put up great No.1 offense stats.. but come time
when it's flat out " Do or Die " stakes on the line. They are gonna come up empty and we'll be sent home.

And much more easier to replace the HC than a MVP-like regular season starting QB.

Measure HC McCarthy's pluses vs minuses and what do we have ..?

 

[The Quest for Six]

Sure did for Taco....Will McClay "makes the draft picks" meaning he calls the players after Jerry and Stephen approve. We all know that

Rod Marinelli wanted Taco....