Based simply on stats, are these 2 QB's similar?

[Kaiser]

Player 1: Bachelors and Masters completed in four years.

Player 2: Couple of Florida State Social Science classes.

Player 1 is Dak Prescott.

Player 2 is Jameis Winston.

 

[Ken]

Those stats aren’t that similar.

at all. lol

one was #1 overal pick...one was 4th round.

Stupid thread.

 

[Super_Kazuya]

Godwin, Evans, brate and Howard. He isn't saddled with trash

Only a Dak slobberer would act like there is any kind of comparison between the rosters. Dak had a stacked offense on Day one. Winston was a number one pick who went straight to the worst team in the league.

If Dak was drafted by Tampa Bay he would be in the XFL right now... well wait, their season is canceled.

 

[phildadon86]

Going simply on stats, would you say these 2 QB's are very similar based on their first 4 years in the league:


QB #1

1,922 attempts 1,183 completions 62% Comp % 14,628 Yards 88 TD's 58 Int's 189 rushes 794 Yards 9 TD's


QB #2

2,071 Attempts 1,363 Completions 65.8% Comp. % 15,778 Yards 97 TD's 36 Int's 241 rushes 1,221 yards 21 TD's




In my opinion solely looking at stats (keeping in mind QB #1 had a very bad 5th year and those stats aren't factored into this) these 2 QB's stats are very similar.


QB #1 is about to be released and QB #2 is looking for $35+M/year in a new contract.


QB #1 is Jameis Winston

QB #2 is Dak Prescott

Lol so let’s just leave out the bad 5th year. And the stats still aren’t even close. Are you ok?

 

[HanD]

Only a Dak slobberer would act like there is any kind of comparison between the rosters. Dak had a stacked offense on Day one. Winston was a number one pick who went straight to the worst team in the league.

If Dak was drafted by Tampa Bay he would be in the XFL right now... well wait, their season is canceled.

I could care less what we do with Dak. But these two aren't that similar. Winston always had Evans. Last year he had great talent around him,better receing talent than Dak and had a terrible year. Dak has improved or remained steady each year. Winston not only is up and down but is a risk off the field.

Let's be fair when comparing support staff. You made it seem like Winston was playing with hurns a rookie Gallup and twill

 

[Hawkeye0202]

I do think Winston is the more gifted passer
But those nasty turnovers.
That is why he's looking for a job
Leads all QBs by a mile in total turnovers during his career.

Not important ..........

 

[cowboyec]

dumb.

stop hating your QB.

 

[roughneck266]

I don't believe this is going to end the way you thought it would. More than 2X the TD's??

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Going simply on stats, would you say these 2 QB's are very similar based on their first 4 years in the league:


QB #1

1,922 attempts 1,183 completions 62% Comp % 14,628 Yards 88 TD's 58 Int's 189 rushes 794 Yards 9 TD's


QB #2

2,071 Attempts 1,363 Completions 65.8% Comp. % 15,778 Yards 97 TD's 36 Int's 241 rushes 1,221 yards 21 TD's




In my opinion solely looking at stats (keeping in mind QB #1 had a very bad 5th year and those stats aren't factored into this) these 2 QB's stats are very similar.


QB #1 is about to be released and QB #2 is looking for $35+M/year in a new contract.


QB #1 is Jameis Winston

QB #2 is Dak Prescott

the TD to interception ratio for QB1 is bad. really bad. QB2 seems to be much better. here is QB3

2042 attempts, 1313 completion, 64.2%, 15760, 121TD , 34 int's

and I find it funny, in one thread people don't want Dak based on this past year performance. claiming he was 8-8 and ignoring previous years. in this thread, you excuse Winston's lack of performance and his last year as an anamoly.

I guess whatever that suits the argument.

also, tell me about their leadership ability? how many come backs did Winston have? how many wins? how about his maturity? how has he gotten better? has he improved or not?

again, the goal is not to win the spreadsheet math for cap...its about winning superbowls and getting to playoffs. which one will give you a better chance at the position?

its not about wasting $25 mill a year.....to say I saved 10 mill on the cap....its about spending that extra 10 and getting a chance to go to playoffs and make a run.

 

[Super_Kazuya]

I could care less what we do with Dak. But these two aren't that similar. Winston always had Evans. Last year he had great talent around him,better receing talent than Dak and had a terrible year. Dak has improved or remained steady each year. Winston not only is up and down but is a risk off the field.

Dak has not improved, if we are being objective his rookie year still remains his best year. And your deflection is a joke, having Mike Evans alone does not offset having an offensive line stocked with future HOFers and one of the best RBs in the league. I'll say it again since you struggle with reading: Only a Dak slobberer would act like there is any kind of comparison between the rosters. Dak had a stacked offense on Day one. Winston was a number one pick who went straight to the worst team in the league. If Dak was drafted by Tampa Bay he would be in the XFL right now.

 

[G2]

58 INTs would get Prescott dragged out into the street and beaten.

 

[DoctorChicken]

Only a Dak slobberer would act like there is any kind of comparison between the rosters. Dak had a stacked offense on Day one. Winston was a number one pick who went straight to the worst team in the league.

If Dak was drafted by Tampa Bay he would be in the XFL right now... well wait, their season is canceled.

I’m not a big Dak fan but he’s better than Winston. By a long shot.

Winston had Arians as his coach last year, a known QB whisperer, legitimately good threats at WR and TE, yet managed to throw 30 picks.

The dude can’t even see. He had Lasik surgery a few weeks ago.

 

[Kaiser]

Not important ..........

Sure, I never see Cowboy fans mention interceptions at all.

On a related note, I was in a coma from 2016 to 2014 when Tony Romo was starting.

 

[cowboyec]

based on the stats....they are completely NOT similar.

 

[DFWJC]

Only a Dak slobberer would act like there is any kind of comparison between the rosters. Dak had a stacked offense on Day one. Winston was a number one pick who went straight to the worst team in the league.

If Dak was drafted by Tampa Bay he would be in the XFL right now... well wait, their season is canceled.

You have a point regarding what Dak walked into vs Winston....at least in the first 2-3 years.
By last year, I think the weapons around Winston were strong, and his line wasn't terrible either.

 

[DFWJC]

Sure, I never see Cowboy fans mention interceptions at all.

On a related note, I was in a coma from 2016 to 2014 when Tony Romo was starting.

Yet his TD-int ratio was very good

Winston, on the other hand.....abysmal.

 

[G2]

Weird Tampa doesn't want Winnie....

 

[Aviano90]

Man I hope the NFL season gets cancelled. Fans need a break from it.

 

[Super_Kazuya]

It should also be pointed out, since the OP is filled with raw totals, that Winston produced the numbers he did in 8 fewer games than Dak. Which means he certainly would have exceeded Dak in all of the passing totals (and more interceptions likely).

 

[DFWJC]

58 INTs would get Prescott dragged out into the street and beaten.

let alone 30 in ONE YEAR from last year that was not included in this comp