Best Quartbacks in NFL History Tier List

[DFWJC]

Nah. Cincy lost because of Aaron Donald. Chase was open. Ramsey was on the floor. Donald just destroyed the interior OL of cincy.

And of course, “one of” the the better game-winning TD drives in Super Bowl history before then.
Team game, for sure

 

[kskboys]

Aaron Rodgers is the best pure passer in this era and he has only managed 1 super bowl. It takes a team and Marino didn't have many good ones.

Aaron has been choking when the chips are down for many many years. Great QB, but a poor finisher.

 

[Captain-Crash]

I'd just like to see this superstar QB playback when you could almost kill the QB after a play was over and mug his receivers.

 

[Insomniac]

Serious question .........Does Eli get voted into the HOF 1st ballot?

I wouldn't vote for him but...
1. He is really famous.
2. He played in New York.

He's going to get in.

 

[ESisback]

I wouldn't vote for him but...
1. He is really famous.
2. He played in New York.

He's going to get in.

Yep, and he’ll be the first (and only) HOFer to throw 27 INTs in one season! He was on a 6th seed 9-7 team that got healthy and hot at the perfect time, with an other worldly pass rush, and if not for a miracle catch by an unknown backup WR, off a desperation duck, he’d have gone home. Tony Romo was a better passer with bad luck and a lesser defense.

 

[kskboys]

Yep, and he’ll be the first (and only) HOFer to throw 27 INTs in one season! He was on a 6th seed 9-7 team that got healthy and hot at the perfect time, with an other worldly pass rush, and if not for a miracle catch by an unknown backup WR, off a desperation duck, he’d have gone home. Tony Romo was a better passer with bad luck and a lesser defense.

PManning threw 28 his rook year!!!!!!

Favre 29
Tarkenton 32
Stabler 28, 30
Luckman 31
Blanda 42!!!

Sorry, E, got to keep it accurate!!!!

 

[RS12]

Does whoever made the list acknowledge the change in defensive pass interference rule of 1978? If not delete thread.

 

[kskboys]

And of course, “one of” the the better game-winning TD drives in Super Bowl history before then.
Team game, for sure

Before this, SF vs Cincy was the best super bowl I'd ever seen. This one ranks right up there w/ it.

 

[quickccc]

Before this, SF vs Cincy was the best super bowl I'd ever seen. This one ranks right up there w/ it.

which Niners vs Cincy SB ? ... they faced each other twice in SBs
- One vs Ken Anderson
- another vs Boomer Esiason

- i never thought i'd enjoy and root for Eli Manning TWICE as i did when NYGiants beat Brady and the Pats in SBs

i never thought i'd root for the Oakland Raiders Twice as i did for vs Joe Thiesmann .....and another vs Ron Jaworski
Radas blowed them out ,, in both games respectively

 

[ESisback]

PManning threw 28 his rook year!!!!!!

Favre 29
Tarkenton 32
Stabler 28, 30
Luckman 31
Blanda 42!!!

Sorry, E, got to keep it accurate!!!!

Ok, ya got me! I’m not a stat monster, but I know he’s overrated, and can name 4 Dallas QBs who were better!

 

[StarChamber_33]

Even worse, Staubach also on the same tier.

Even worse, Steve Young on a higher tier than both Staubach and Aikman?? It's a safe assumption that this Baines guy isn't a Cowboys fan..

 

[phildadon86]

And of course, “one of” the the better game-winning TD drives in Super Bowl history before then.
Team game, for sure

Yeah. Kupp went off. But let’s not get crazy here. They had some serious help getting into the end zone.

 

[bigdnlaca]

Even worse, Steve Young on a higher tier than both Staubach and Aikman?? It's a safe assumption that this Baines guy isn't a Cowboys fan..

Young was great he just played in a better system where skill players racked a bunch of yac. He was fortunate to have Rice Taylor, Watters and Hearst.

I don’t think Young would have thrived as well in the 90s offense of the Cowboys compared to Aikman but I think he would have been good with Landry’s.

 

[Brooksey]

Marino, Elway and Favre over Drew Brees
Eli Manning needs to be removed from the list entirely

 

[JJHLH1]

Brady
.
.
.
everyone else

 

[StarChamber_33]

Brady
.
.
.
everyone else

Yep, Shady Brady and his cheating scandals rank at the top of the food chain on this pile of garbage, called "tier list".

 

[Nova]

Brady is not by himself in tier one. Not even close. There's prolly 5 Qb's in tier one. If all a person wants to do is count super bowls, then there's no reason to make a list anyway.

Hard disagree. From talent perspective, are their guys better? Maybe.

But 6 rings with the Pats, 1 with the Bucs, All time passing yards and td leader, most wins… no one comes close to this resume.

GOAT QB and it’s really hard to have a legit argument against him.

 

[JJHLH1]

Yep, Shady Brady and his cheating scandals rank at the top of the food chain on this pile of garbage, called "tier list".

Brady’s 35 career playoff wins will never be surpassed.

More than double the next best, Montana’s 16.

Brady deserves his own wing in the HOF.

 

[DFWJC]

Stafford will move another tier after this season.
5200 yards, 45 TDs, 13 ints
and win, win, win
jmo

Might not repeat though. That is so hard to do

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Moderator Edit: https://www.sogsports.com/best-quarterbacks-of-all-time-tier-list/

Interesting ........Marino with no ring on tier 2 and Aikman with three on tier 3, same as Eli Manning. As good as he is, P Mahomes on the list is a bit premature.

this is absolutely horrible