Breakdown of Garrett's record

[cowboyblue22]

4-21 against perineal powers.

wow that's ugly record

 

[Corso]

This post proves everything I've said.

Timeline for accountability for Garrett? "I don't have an answer."

But, if insert player name here has a bad year, doesn't that excuse Garrett for everything?

There's "nonsense" involved here. Along with excuses. Nothing more.

And thanks for proving everything I've said thus far. Well done.

 

[PA Cowboy Fan]

Yes, he did have a very very good QB! But- wouldn't you also "need to know" a few other things before passing judgment? For example, how was the salary cap managed? Were draft picks used wisely? How well did we handle free agency? Trades? What about contract decisions and dead money? etc...

Not really. I blame that on the FO. Of course listening to some the FO has been doing pretty well lately. I blame Garrett for his coaching decisions which are mediocre. I mean there's enough blame to go around but there is no doubt in my mind that we would have gotten further with a better coach. I mean you can make all kind of excuses about why we always underperform but I look at other teams that have young coaches and it doesn't seem to take them a decade to turn things around.

 

[Sydla]

That's a fair question, and I don't have an answer. I'll pose another question though- what if Dak takes a big step back this year, and the team suffers as a result? Do you fire the coach based on a bad record caused by poor QB play? There's some judgment involved here, and more nuance than the "Garrett Haters Support Group" likes to admit.

Yes I fire the coach.

 

[Sydla]

Yes, he did have a very very good QB! But- wouldn't you also "need to know" a few other things before passing judgment? For example, how was the salary cap managed? Were draft picks used wisely? How well did we handle free agency? Trades? What about contract decisions and dead money? etc...

Excuses after excuses after excuses.

How do you not see this?

 

[CATCH17]

Time has exposed Jason Garrett.

We know what he is and it’s not good enough. There is no debate to be had about the type of coach he is anymore. He’s had more then enough time to have playoff success and he just can’t do it.

No coach should ever have the leash that he has gotten.

 

[TwentyOne]

interesting breakdown of Garretts record I saw on reddit
worst- GB,NO, ATL. best-WASH

Alot of big bubbles with not alot of meaningfull message.

Next post please.

 

[TwistedL0g1k]

Excuses after excuses after excuses.

How do you not see this?

Whether they are excuses or relevant facts is in the eye of the beholder.

If a QB throws an interception, but the receiver ran the wrong route- is it an excuse to blame the interception on the receiver? Sometimes assigning blame requires a deeper analysis.

You understand the issues listed I'm sure, but we probably differ in how important we think they are/were. If I thought for one second that we had a championship caliber roster, but failed because of the head coach- my pitchfork would be at the front of the line!

 

[ufcrules1]

But he's also 1-2 in the playoffs.

His record in win and you get into the playoffs is terrible too.

 

[Diehardblues]

Yep. And you know Garrett was already weaseling his way into the head coaching job.

Jerry had already name Garrett” the future of the Cowboys”. I really can’t see any reason he’d need to “ weasel “ something that was already his to inherit.

 

[Zman5]

Wade is only Cowboy HC to have a losing record with Romo starting in a season.
1-5 in 2010

And JG had only 1 winning season(2014) as a HC with Romo starting.

 

[big dog cowboy]

And JG had only 1 winning season(2014) as a HC with Romo starting.

And JG had only 1 losing season (2015) as a HC with Romo starting and Romo actually only started 4 games that year and won 3 of them.

 

[Dre11]

I would like to see what his record against WINNING teams is. Thats where you separate the men from the boys imo. That and playoff record.

Then let’s look at all coaches against winning teams.

 

[fredp22]

Alot of big bubbles with not alot of meaningfull message.

Next post please.

your looking at the bubbles? ok

 

[Redball Express]

Very mediocre and it doesn't cover what all Cowboy fans should care about the most and that's playoff success.

what it also does not take into account is that his teams lack talent and the killer instinct.

This is not Garretts fault.

It is the fault of the players who underachieve..

collect their millions..

and leave the fans wanting.

Try to look at things globally more, brother.

I can insert Tony Romo into your formula and get your results.

There is another player who constantly failed the franchise year after year.

So try again with this topic and try to open your eyes.

Sorry..you hit a nerve with me.

Not being aggressive against you..

just the issues.

 

[CATCH17]

what it also does not take into account is that his teams lack talent and the killer instinct.

This is not Garretts fault.

It is the fault of the players who underachieve..

collect their millions..

and leave the fans wanting.

Try to look at things globally more, brother.

I can insert Tony Romo into your formula and get your results.

There is another player who constantly failed the franchise year after year.

So try again with this topic and try to open your eyes.

Sorry..you hit a nerve with me.

Not being aggressive against you..

just the issues.

It’s just a conversation. No need to apologize @Redball Express

I don’t care who’s fault it is or isn’t. He’s had more then enough time to get the job done and has never looked exceptional doing his job.

He’s provides structure and organization Mon-Sat.. Sunday he offers nothing but claps and try harders. He’s had his chance. It’s time for someone else.

 

[FuzzyLumpkins]

Very mediocre and it doesn't cover what all Cowboy fans should care about the most and that's playoff success.

i don't think you know what the meaning of the word mediocre is and it is adorable that you think you can tell Cowboys fans what they should care about.

 

[GMO415]

Owned by 9 teams?.....That's just great!

 

[Zman5]

And JG had only 1 losing season (2015) as a HC with Romo starting and Romo actually only started 4 games that year and won 3 of them.

It's pathetic that JG only had 1 winning season with players like Romo, Witten, TSmith, Dez, Lee, DWare, Demarco Murray, Frederick, Martin when in their prime.

 

[Sydla]

Whether they are excuses or relevant facts is in the eye of the beholder.

If a QB throws an interception, but the receiver ran the wrong route- is it an excuse to blame the interception on the receiver? Sometimes assigning blame requires a deeper analysis.

You understand the issues listed I'm sure, but we probably differ in how important we think they are/were. If I thought for one second that we had a championship caliber roster, but failed because of the head coach- my pitchfork would be at the front of the line!

No but the better QBs often rise up from a mistake like that and over a full season are very good. No one is infallible. Sometimes **** happens.

But 7 years in, it’s hard to continue to take the constant excuses seriously. Eventually a great coach rises up. Let me guess, you’ve pretty much already given him a pass in 2018 if he fails to make the playoffs because I suspect you think he’s got a young, flawed team with all new coaches, right?

Garrett has one playoff win. One.