Breakdown of Garrett's record

[Diehardblues]

It is not Jerry’s fault for the lack of Garrett’s success. It is Jerry’s fault for the lack of the teams succes. Mostly by keeping Garrett and this staff.
At he made some staff changes, but not the guy at top.

Garrett is a product of Jerry’s dysfunction.

Garrett’s success is directly related to the roster, coaching staff and front office which is Jerry’s responsibility as GM.

Garrett is responsible for Game Day gaffs.

 

[TwistedL0g1k]

Now stooping so far as to grasp at unproveable hypotheticals about what an actually accomplished coach could or couldn't do with this roster.

Excuse me, but this is exactly what you are doing too. You are hypothesizing that a different coach could have created a different outcome.

Clearly we do not share the same opinion as to the cause of our lack of success in recent history. I contend the blame lies mostly with the front office, you believe the cause is the coaching.

 

[Diehardblues]

Whereas Garrett has been handed every job he's received rather than having earned them.

True. That’s not his fault Jerry is a fool.

 

[CowboyRoy]

Garrett never had a losing season or record with his starting QB.

I would agree both HC are not as good as we should have. But then we’re not taking into considerations the constraints Jerry placec on us.

In all fairness at least Wade was a proven Coord and had some HC experience coming in.

I dont consider the term "losing season" to hold much weight when the coach was 8-8 for 3 years and 9-7 last year was virtually 8-8 with a win against 3rd stringers.

 

[Diehardblues]

Excuse me, but this is exactly what you are doing too. You are hypothesizing that a different coach could have created a different outcome.

Clearly we do not share the same opinion as to the cause of our lack of success in recent history. I contend the blame lies mostly with the front office, you believe the cause is the coaching.

Its all connected.

 

[Diehardblues]

I dont consider the term "losing season" to hold much weight when the coach was 8-8 for 3 years and 9-7 last year was virtually 8-8 with a win against 3rd stringers.

Because those facts don’t fit your narrative.

 

[CowboyRoy]

It is not Jerry’s fault for the lack of Garrett’s success. It is Jerry’s fault for the lack of the teams succes. Mostly by keeping Garrett and this staff.
At he made some staff changes, but not the guy at top.

Wade Phillips and Jason Garret. Those have been our coaches fo the last decade or more. That is all you have to know about how poorly Jones is at picking coaches.

 

[Stash]

Excuse me, but this is exactly what you are doing too. You are hypothesizing that a different coach could have created a different outcome.

I answered the question presented to me. But I'd don't run to an unproveable hypothetical excuse for proven failure.

Clearly we do not share the same opinion as to the cause of our lack of success in recent history. I contend the blame lies mostly with the front office, you believe the cause is the coaching.

Clearly.

And clearly, you'll use any excuse to absolve Jason Garrett of any and all blame for anything that affects the record and performance of this team.

Maybe you're Jerry Jones in disguise?

 

[CowboyRoy]

Because those facts don’t fit your narrative.

The narrative that Garrett is good because he hasnt had a losing season is as week as it gets. If you consider 8-8 something as proof that Garrett has what it takes then that is pretty pathetic.

The fact is that Garrett has had a playoff caliber roster EVERY year he has been a head coach here. Minus the years that Romo was injured. And I would say in most of those years the NFC EAST was there for the taking.

 

[Stash]

Because those facts don’t fit your narrative.

And your use of the term "losing season" wasn't done intentionally to suit your own narrative?

Come on now...

 

[Sydla]

Excuse me, but this is exactly what you are doing too. You are hypothesizing that a different coach could have created a different outcome.

Clearly we do not share the same opinion as to the cause of our lack of success in recent history. I contend the blame lies mostly with the front office, you believe the cause is the coaching.

So wait.

Are you saying Garrett got the most possible out of some of his teams? And that no coach could have done a better job?

 

[Diehardblues]

Wade Phillips and Jason Garret. Those have been our coaches fo the last decade or more. That is all you have to know about how poorly Jones is at picking coaches.

But we had Bill with no better results. Our problem goes deeper than coaching.

 

[Diehardblues]

And your use of the term "losing season" wasn't done intentionally to suit your own narrative?

Come on now...

That’s what we do here is present our arguments. Using facts to support them is Debate 101

 

[Stash]

True. That’s not his fault Jerry is a fool.

Also doesn't make him good at or deserving of the job he has.

"It's all connected."

 

[Stash]

That’s what we do here is present our arguments.

As long as you're honest about it.

 

[RS12]

This thread is hilarious. What his record is versus: 1) Teams with a winning record. 2) rookie coaches 3) win or go home games. I think you will find that paints a truer and much uglier picture.

 

[CowboyRoy]

But we had Bill with no better results. Our problem goes deeper than coaching.

Bill was a horrid coach by the time he got here. I hated Bill almost as much as I hate Garrett.

 

[TwistedL0g1k]

And clearly, you'll use any excuse to absolve Jason Garrett of any and all blame for anything that affects the record and performance of this team.

Maybe you're Jerry Jones in disguise?

And clearly you'll use any excuse to absolve the Front Office of any and all blame for anything that affects the record and performance of this team.

Maybe you're Jerry Jones in disguise?

See how pointless that type of logic is? In my posts, I've said over and over again, that I am not a big Garrett fan, and that he has indeed made many mistakes. He was however, presented with a compromised roster.

 

[Diehardblues]

As long as you're honest about it.

I’m brutally honest but I’m relentless in arguing my position and presenting my narrative which usually represents my beliefs.

 

[TwoDeep3]

Garrett's record of breakdown.....here I fixed it for you.