Broaddus made a great point

[Jstopper]

It’s one flipping win after 3 losses. People literally go dumb and lose their minds

what does that have to do with him getting credit?

 

[OmerV]

He gets some credit for today's win. Now tell me how today's good win outweighs 9 years of mediocrity?

I don’t think the OP or Broaddus was saying it did.

 

[lockster]

It's Garrett's job to get players ready, he had shown over and over, that for one reason or the other , he will waste our seasons. Starting wrong players, hiring wrong sub coaches, game day decisions, rewarding bad play, bad game plans, not taking responsibility when he's at fault, allowing the same bad plays to be run over and over again regardless of results, not having players ready, not discipline players on the field when they need it, etc. Let's just move on to someone else who is better in all these categories, even if just slightly, because Jason just doesn't have what it takes as a when. When he gets one part right, he evens it out by sucking in another area! All our coaches should have to earn a job, just as the players are suppose to do. Our coaching staff sucks I know what! At least the patriots are proactive n their approach, even if cheating is part of it, rather than just waiting for a wheel to fall off before you fix it!

 

[Howboutdemcowboys31]

I don’t think the OP or Broaddus was saying it did.

& I’m not saying he shouldn’t get some credit for today. He should. But we’re 7-7. He’s won nothing in 9 years. Anything short of a Super Bowl and he has to go. His hot seat shouldn’t be any less hot because of one game

 

[Proof]

It’s one good win. Even if you give Garrett credit for today’s win, the rest of this miserable season overshadows it x1000000. Compound that x10 years, yeah... today doesn’t change my mind on Garrett whatsoever

careful, you might look like a clown for not absolving this buffoon of his decade of futility after the first good game in a month.

 

[OmerV]

Yep, I do hate Garrett, its not blind either, I can promise you that

Why hate? Why can’t some people just accept he isn’t the right man for the job instead of creating a personal grudge in their mind? Garrett isn’t intentionally trying to lose games or acting out of spite or malice. The decision to let him go should have nothing to do with emotion or some imagined personal affront. It should be a calm, level headed, unemotional and we’ll considered decision based on what will help the team get better.

 

[mmohican29]

I'm more angry with him after this win because all I see is lost potential this year.

Exactly. If the team plays lights out in Philly, defeats SF or Sea in WC round and loses in GB or Min- all you have is a Jason Garrett caliber club that paid for it's terrible losses later rather than sooner.

This team has to win the NFC Title or he is gone.

 

[OmerV]

& I’m not saying he shouldn’t get some credit for today. He should. But we’re 7-7. He’s won nothing in 9 years. Anything short of a Super Bowl and he has to go. His hot seat shouldn’t be any less hot because of one game

thats all Broaddus and the OP were saying as well. Neither suggested this win wiped the slate clean.

 

[Redsfan_83]

Here's the thing...whatever we did today worked wonders. Don't think for a minute that the Iggles aren't watching tape, and will adjust their plans accordingly. Where our coaches fall short for the last 10 years is not putting out the same game plan as they just did. We adjusted to how we knew the Rams would attack, and it worked. Great coaches keep this going, and don't fall into the trap of thinking the ship has righted itself, because it hasn't after just one game

 

[unionjack8]

Why hate? Why can’t some people just accept he isn’t the right man for the job instead of creating a personal grudge in their mind? Garrett isn’t intentionally trying to lose games or acting out of spite or malice. The decision to let him go should have nothing to do with emotion or some imagined personal affront. It should be a level headed, unemotional decision based on what will help the team get better.

I'm not the one that has to make that decision, I'm a fan, fans are ALL about emotions, it's what makes us fans.....we love, hate, sometimes st the same time, but that emotional drug is why we keep on coming back.

 

[OmerV]

I'm not the one that has to make that decision, I'm a fan, fans are ALL about emotions, it's what makes us fans.....we love, hate, sometimes st the same time, but that emotional drug is why we keep on coming back.

Irrational emotion and illogical thoughts aren’t requirements for fandom. Neither are fabricated grudges and imagined personal affronts.

It is, believe it or not, possible to ride the emotions over games and seasons and still be fair minded and level headed.

 

[morat1959]

He gets some credit for today's win. Now tell me how today's good win outweighs 9 years of mediocrity?

This!

 

[Gangsta Spanksta]

Bryan broaddus on the postgame show made an excellent point. He said if you can blame the head coach for every loss but after every win it’s because of the players then you clearly are speaking from blind hatred of the head coach. By no means am I a fan of Garrett but some of y’all are looking like clowns with your takes on him

We've known Garrett for a long time. We should know if he is a good coach or bad one by now. What exactly did he do, today, that you feel he deserves credit for?

 

[Big D]

I'm more angry with him after this win because all I see is lost potential this year.

 

[kskboys]

Bryan broaddus on the postgame show made an excellent point. He said if you can blame the head coach for every loss but after every win it’s because of the players then you clearly are speaking from blind hatred of the head coach. By no means am I a fan of Garrett but some of y’all are looking like clowns with your takes on him

The real clowns are the ones who come to conclusions after 1 game instead of considering both the season and the body of work.

 

[dogunwo]

Jason Garrett outcoached whiz kid Sean McVay. Oh that's sounds ridiculous? Well stop saying coach X outcoached Garrett when they lose.

 

[Gangsta Spanksta]

Your opinion is completely invalid then if you cannot set aside the hate to have fair analysis

Many people think that some of those years were despite of garrett. For instance romo calling his own plays. Is the notion of the talent overcoming bad coaching completely out of the realm of possibilities?

 

[Pantone282C]

Lots of shots being taken with hollow points.

 

[TwoDeep3]

This guy hates Garrett.

 

[OmerV]

Many people think that some of those years were despite of garrett. For instance romo calling his own plays. Is the notion of the talent overcoming bad coaching completely out of the realm of possibilities?

Romo called audibles at the line of scrimmage just like other QBs.