News: BTB: Tony Romo: The Choke Artist Myth And Elimination Vs. Playoff Hunt Games

dallasfan4lizife

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,535
Reaction score
4,224
Thx Percy... Can you do this for 2nd and 3rd too? Would love too see some kind of graph.

Tony Romo is an above average QB, but he'll break your heart. And so many posters on here suffer from battered woman syndrome. Trying to justify why he isn't even close to part of the problem.
 

ufcrules1

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,652
Reaction score
3,800
Tony Romo is an above average QB, but he'll break your heart. And so many posters on here suffer from battered woman syndrome. Trying to justify why he isn't even close to part of the problem.

There is no doubt Tony deserves some of the blame for our lack of success. He is certainly not blameless. The biggest reason though is who we have running the team. The lack of success was here long before Tony.
 

percyhoward

Research Tool
Messages
17,062
Reaction score
21,861
Tony Romo is an above average QB, but he'll break your heart.
Because that's where your heart is, with this team's pass offense. It's the only part of the team that offers a consistent payoff for the emotional investment required of the fan. In this portfolio, diversification is not an option.
 

tyke1doe

Well-Known Member
Messages
54,310
Reaction score
32,716
There is no doubt Tony deserves some of the blame for our lack of success. He is certainly not blameless. The biggest reason though is who we have running the team. The lack of success was here long before Tony.

If you know your quarterback has Brett Favre-like tendencies, you don't give him the authority of Brett Favre. How hard is that to understand?
Tony Romo needed a young Bill Parcells. He didn't need a Bill Walsh.
He needed someone to keep him under control. Instead, we gave him the offense, and he turned out to be a mini Brett Favre without the championship appearances or the Super Bowl ring.
 

DandyDon1722

It's been a good 'un, ain't it?
Messages
6,386
Reaction score
7,008
Yes, but he is part of the team and touches the ball on every offensive play. He needs to step his game up in the elimination/playoffs. I think we can both agree on that.

Agreed -- I want Tony to carry the team to playoff wins as much as anybody and I also believe he has to be better but he has to at least be put in reasonable positions to do so. Putting up 40 on the Broncos and losing frames a narrative on him that is simply false. I hope we can agree on that.
 

CCBoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
47,009
Reaction score
22,604
Agreed -- I want Tony to carry the team to playoff wins as much as anybody and I also believe he has to be better but he has to at least be put in reasonable positions to do so. Putting up 40 on the Broncos and losing frames a narrative on him that is simply false. I hope we can agree on that.

48 and not a win...
 

ufcrules1

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,652
Reaction score
3,800
Agreed -- I want Tony to carry the team to playoff wins as much as anybody and I also believe he has to be better but he has to at least be put in reasonable positions to do so. Putting up 40 on the Broncos and losing frames a narrative on him that is simply false. I hope we can agree on that.

He looked terrific in that game slashing up Denver but then again so did Peyton slashing up Dallas. Then at the end when needed he made a huge mistake with a wide open Demarco for the easy check down. Now, if you wanna say due to poor coaching/game planning he is at a disadvantage at times, I can certainly agree with that. I also think we have much bigger problems then Romo. Hey, I'm trying to find some middle ground with ya Don.
 

ufcrules1

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,652
Reaction score
3,800
If you know your quarterback has Brett Favre-like tendencies, you don't give him the authority of Brett Favre. How hard is that to understand?
Tony Romo needed a young Bill Parcells. He didn't need a Bill Walsh.
He needed someone to keep him under control. Instead, we gave him the offense, and he turned out to be a mini Brett Favre without the championship appearances or the Super Bowl ring.

No doubt. I think another year or 2 with Parcells would have made Romo a much better QB/ student of the game and his career...especially elimination/playoff games would have looked a whole lot better.
 

percyhoward

Research Tool
Messages
17,062
Reaction score
21,861
If you know your quarterback has Brett Favre-like tendencies, you don't give him the authority of Brett Favre. How hard is that to understand?
Tony Romo needed a young Bill Parcells. He didn't need a Bill Walsh.
He needed someone to keep him under control. Instead, we gave him the offense, and he turned out to be a mini Brett Favre without the championship appearances or the Super Bowl ring.
He's definitely on the risky side of average, but nothing approaching Eli for example.
 

percyhoward

Research Tool
Messages
17,062
Reaction score
21,861
No doubt. I think another year or 2 with Parcells would have made Romo a much better QB/ student of the game and his career...especially elimination/playoff games would have looked a whole lot better.
Just remember 0-67.
 

DandyDon1722

It's been a good 'un, ain't it?
Messages
6,386
Reaction score
7,008
quote="ufcrules1, post: 5599931, member: 32557"]He looked terrific in that game slashing up Denver but then again so did Peyton slashing up Dallas. Then at the end when needed he made a huge mistake with a wide open Demarco for the easy check down. Now, if you wanna say due to poor coaching/game planning he is at a disadvantage at times, I can certainly agree with that. I also think we have much bigger problems then Romo. Hey, I'm trying to find some middle ground with ya Don.[/quote]

No, I know dude we're good.

From my perspective there have been a lot of games where he just should've never been in a position to have to make a throw like that to win the game and then to be honest there were other times that he made bad decisions and we lost.

But -- I simply cannot grasp the "animosity" towards him when chances are we will have to be very bad (draft pick) or very lucky to get that kind of production out of the next quarterback of the team we all love when he retires. Shouldn't we enjoy it now while we at least have a chance with him?
 
Top