Bucky Brooks: "It's a myth that elite QBs single-handedly carry their teams to wins"

[SteveTheCowboy]

You're right, but since Dak has lost in the post-season every time and never reached the NFCG, we know that Dak is not Mahomes so we should be trying to find someone who is better than what we have.

Hard to do that when the one you have is wanting 20-25% of your salary cap without leading the team anywhere near a Super Bowl.

Now, if Dak wants to play for $25 million, I am all for bringing him back and bringing in competition.

Once the quarterback tops 15% of the salary cap though, they better be reaching the Super Bowl and hopefully winning it.

Its also hard to do when you're not willing to try.....because you *might* fail.
"Fear is the enemy"

 

[thunderpimp91]

So is that the goal? Just win 1 playoff game?

No that's simply the results that we have had the previous three seasons. For a team that has only won one playoff victory in that time period I wouldn't be afraid to move on from Dak, McCarthy, Parsons, or really anyone currently under contract without a generational talent to replace them. I'm not saying you need to blow it up, but I wouldnt fear doing that, especially on a team where the front office wont go out and aggressively look to acquire better players to help the current core.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Who?

Shabazz told me straight up he just doesn’t like him. And like I said I respect for it. Told him at the time I did.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

No that's simply the results that we have had the previous three seasons. For a team that has only won one playoff victory in that time period I wouldn't be afraid to move on from Dak, McCarthy, Parsons, or really anyone currently under contract without a generational talent to replace them. I'm not saying you need to blow it up, but I wouldnt fear doing that, especially on a team where the front office wont go out and aggressively look to acquire better players to help the current core.

I mean I don’t disagree there. I’ve stated my stance I think our best chance at a conference championship is with this core then a rebuild. But I certainly understand the opposite.

 

[Rockport]

The issue is replacing Dak doesn't have to come with a Mahomes type of player. The question really comes down to what is the ultimate goal. Do I see a random QB coming in and getting this team 12 wins each of the last three season? Probably not. Do I see a random QB coming in and over that same period getting at least 1 playoff win? Absolutely. The results this team has accomplished under Dak is pretty easy to duplicate depending on what we are measuring.

Well if you’re going to replace Dak then you better replace the rest of the team because they’re much more responsible for the playoff failures.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

You don't have to be Mahomes to not fall apart at the first of every game in the playoffs against any team with a winning record

So the goal is just not to fall apart lol? Damn…

 

[Rockport]

You cannot name even one poster who blames Dak entirely for losing any of the playoff games.

Funny how you call people out all the time but now you're suddenly all about the rules.

You're not fooling anybody Rocky ol' pal.

Baiting again?

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Define in your words what personal is then. Don't duck the question, answer it.

First off come at me with respectfully I don’t have to do anything you demand…who the hell are you?

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Baiting again?

He thought you was gonna fall for the bait.

 

[5Stars]

First off come at me with respectfully I don’t have to do anything you demand…who the hell are you?

That's what I thought...keep it alive, keep it alive.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

That's what I thought...keep it alive, keep it alive.

I literally answered the question to someone who asked it far more respectfully then you did why don’t you scroll up?

 

[Rockport]

Hey Daksters, make sure if we win the SB while Dak is QB, you make sure to call it a team win and not just heap praise on Dak for getting the team over the hump.

Well, he’ll probably be the Super Bowl MVP so he’ll get his praise.

 

[Rockport]

First off come at me with respectfully I don’t have to do anything you demand…who the hell are you?

He’s one of the worst posters here. Always bitter. Always hating. Always negative.

 

[zrinkill]

So the goal is just not to fall apart lol? Damn…

Other QB's have won Superbowls not being as good as Mahomes ........ and those QB's did not fall apart at the first of the games.

 

[DallasEast]

Kettles, kettles, kettles. Pots, pots, pots...

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

He’s one of the worst posters here. Always bitter. Always hating. Always negative.

He is. More annoying then Pappy shockingly..

 

[thunderpimp91]

I mean I don’t disagree there. I’ve stated my stance I think our best chance at a conference championship is with this core then a rebuild. But I certainly understand the opposite.

I dont disagree either, despite some of my negativity on here I do believe this is a very good football team, but if you're going to go for it with this group then the front office really needed to be more aggressive this offseason. I just done see how they run it back with this Oline/Dline and expect different results. For that reason I'm open to all possibilities at this point

 

[DallasEast]

NO NAMECALLING!

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

Other QB's have won Superbowls not being as good as Mahomes ........ and those QB's did not fall apart at the first of the games.

Peyton won a ring and had one of the worst performances of his career.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

I dont disagree either, despite some of my negativity on here I do believe this is a very good football team, but if you're going to go for it with this group then the front office really needed to be more aggressive this offseason. I just done see how they run it back with this Oline/Dline and expect different results. For that reason I'm open to all possibilities at this point

Well yeah that opinion was contingent on us going for it. For what they’ve done now? I’ve suggested it was best to rebuild if this is what you are gonna do. At least it was a plan. This isn’t a plan it’s just a look and see approach. And that’s much worse then a rebuild.