Unfortunately if there’s only a handful of less of Top 5 QB’s at any given time the rest of the league must attempt to build around a lesser type QB.
I hear what you’re saying but I’d argue most teams who found their future Franchise QB with 1st round pick would consider it a success. He doesn’t have to be a HOF caliber just because he was a top 3 pick.
There’s going to be various opinions but I’d bet most could agree on more than we wouldn’t.Sorry, but I think that there are far too many outside influences involved to accurately determine if a QB is truly a "HOF caliber QB" or not.
With all due respect, the list of those rare birds who deserve such advanced adoration would be extremely limited, as you seem to suggest.
Since1994 Jerry Jones has proven as long as he is owner, GM, and defacto Head Coach you will never have a championship team with or without a Hall of Fame Caliber QB.
If your aunt had balls , she’d be your uncle
Correct and instead we have a donkey as a qb instead of a HOFer
This front office has not idenity.....other than the ability to make money. You are spot on about coaching. McCarthy is a coach who was OUT of football all together. Not saying he is a bad coach....but with a front office that is average....simply a good coach is not nearly enough. A good but not great QB (Eli Manning, Russell Wilson)....you need a much better front office with an identity...and a much better coaching staff (but it would take a front office with an identiy to pick the right coach)
Can’t win squat with average front office, above average qb, and average head coach. It’s just not good enough.
Depends how rest of his career played out. One Ring might not be enough.
Yep. We have multiple donkeys in the qb room.
Truth. Some of his critics downplay his career but Jim Plunkett has two Super Bowl rings. He is entering his 31st year of consideration for induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
Dak and the Cowboys have been the perfect storm, at least so far. Dak has had these stretches where he plays at an elite level and looks like a top 3 QB. This gives Jerry justification to both pay him, and then to use him as an excuse for his cheap to nonexistent spending in Free Agency. Then, Dak can't (or at least hasn't thus far) sustain that level of play against elite teams/in the playoffs, and clearly needs more help than this front office is willing to give him. It also hasn't helped that our defense hasn't been able to pick up the slack. Even when they hold SF to 15-25 points, they failed to stop them when the game was on the line or it really mattered. So unfortunately, they will likley pay Dak a large contract and once again rely solely on the draft to put a team around him. By the time certain players develop, others will be past their prime, so unless Jerry is actually willing to go "all in" and take some cap risks in Free Agency, this team is always going to be stuck in purgatory. I think this will be true for any QB, unless we can luck into a Burrow or Mahomes on a rookie deal. Even then the lingering cap hit from whatever deal Dak signs will likely prevent the team from spending what they should. Though, at some point Dak will likely be gone and we'll have a band aid season where we tank with a subpar FA QB and eat all the dead money from these contracts. I just don't think it'll be next year like some of y'all do. They are signing Dak.
That was my point. My original claim was that Tony Romo would be a Hall of Famer today if the Cowboys would have won a SB when he was starting. He's not a top ten. However, if you were to combine his numbers with a championship along with his personal story, it's my opinion that it would have been enough.
Facts mam it's crazy how much our fans are delusional and nonsensical
Obviously NO. Proof is 30 years
6th best shouldn't be in HOF.
