It's not Dak's fault, that's your agenda....my point is it's highly unlikely we can win with him taking 17% of the CAP....Example1 - 2023, we had everything inc a better allround roster than we can build in the next 3 years.
We do overpay (and we extend everyone): Weve paid Top QB, joint top WR.....top Guard, Tyron and Tank and Diggs overpaid ... the problem is that all of those players have for whatever reason come up short (injury, form, connection, lack of leadership).
no, not my agenda. unlike most Dak haters, I don't think there is a singular point of failure. there are many and they contribute in different ways and Dak contributes a lot.
So many needs, due in part to an Offense where Dak needs EVERYTHING to perform. and the defective ability to evaluate including Dak, a QB, with so many needs and composure issues that he can't perform in play-offs.
I tend to disagree. you are now over exagerating quite a bit. wether you like it or not, we were 12-5. three years in a row. people say hey we just beat up on bad teams, but then you do the analysis and see heck, almost every team is similar. so we were good enough to get into post season, but not good enough to advance in the playoffs. so playoffs are an issue and even in the playoffs, Dak under performed, but do you think the defense performed? do you think the other players came through? GB loss was embarassing. but it wasn't just Dak, this whole team choked. not just a single point of failure. does Dak carry majority of the burden? yes. he is the QB, it goes with the territory, but every QB needs help.
what's your point?
That Purdy is better than Dak.
again? what's the point? why the comparison?
Because cowherd offered the comparison and that’s what this thread is about.
'Mahomes wouldn't win here'???? The very fact that he doesn't need a stacked Receiving room, can function without a dominant O:Line and out of the pocket, can identify more than one progression and extend plays, his running ability... and finally and probably most importantly, he is able to keep composure and lead his team when clocks ticking and he needs to produce.
Paying Dak two mega contracts are the two dumbest things this team has ever done
I'd say to a degree that Mahomes wouldn't win here is true. Yes I agree he can function with a lot less, but I suspect that the dysfunction and insanity would simply be too much to overcome even for him. And I'd say that about any of the best QB's in the league.
Pretty sure not having QB ruins every chance you have of winning a title.
Jerry would find a way to ruin mahomes in Dallas. trust me
so should Purdy be paid more? will paying Purdy handicap them from making moves.
Yes, especially during the latter years, however, it's yet to see whether he can raise his game to make up for the loses.....Dak proved he couldnt do it, certainly blame Jerry, but the reality is he was part culpable for the three play-off loses, not the only fault, but clearly not the answer.
during the latter years. what about during the earlier years...
But as you mentioned the early years of Purdy's contract he'll be surrounded by that stronger roster and in such circumstances then there's an argument they should go for it. Dak on the other hand hasnt got the roster and now after the injury and acceptance that a lot of the players havent developed as required we arent in a place to compete. Not all Dak's fault, but that doesnt detract from the fact that it's highly unlikely and throwing money and CAP on a forlorn roster and hope.
