Dak 1 out of 3 QBs to make playoffs last 4 out of 6 full or almost full seasons

[Whirlwin]

Well he has a ring and it doesn't matter if he"chokes" or not. He will be in that same category

No because it will be one more year down the road.

 

[Whirlwin]

What about the other 52 players? Were they there too, or just Dak?

No people that don’t like Prescott. They blame it just on him. They forget it’s a team game

 

[CowboysLakerBamaFan]

So he's 1-3 in the playoffs last 6 years?

 

[tomsanders921]

Fail. Division wasn't bad in 2017. Eagles were Super Bowl champions. It wasn't bad in 2018 either... Dak took 2 from the Eagles where everyone thought the Eagles would roll us over. And it certainly isn't bad this year. Fail.

It's been a bad division. This year doesn't count yet. We were 4-1 without Dak anyway.

 

[Nexx]

Dakazoids…

 

[GoCowboysGo]

No people that don’t like Prescott. They blame it just on him. They forget it’s a team game

‘it’s either the ultimate team game or not. I hate these things that say QB McBlah did blah. He didn’t. It’s always a team thing.

 

[CowboyoWales]

Among active QBs only
Have to have been around at least 6 years
Injury year doesn't count


Dak

made playoffs (2016, 2018, 2021, 2022... assuming)
missed playoffs (2017, 2019)
injured (2020)


Rodgers

made playoffs (2016, 2019, 2020, 2021)
missed playoffs (2018, 2022... assuming)
injured (2017)


Brady

made playoffs (2017-2021)
missed playoffs (?.. possibly 2022 but they're still very much in it)



That's it. Elite company. Unless something crazy happens and he misses the playoffs this year, I don't see how the Jones will even think of moving on from him anytime soon.

Certainly not meaning to be picky, but I dont think Dak fits your own criteria....he's only got the play-offs in 3 years (4 games, with his one win).

 

[Yobwocs]

??? I just thought that as the Seahawks got to the SB in 2014 and 2015 then Wilson would have been credited with those years as well. Then again you've set a particular set of criteria....you make the rules.

And Mahomes, he achieves more playoff years in 5 years than Dak has in 6 but he's excluded, I suppose that's because he possibly won more play-off games?

It's last 6 years. I said SIX. Do the math. Wilson is falling hard. I'd rather be in Dak's shoes than Wilson's shoes right now. As for Mahomes, sure you can count him. So that's Dak, Mahomes, Rodgers, Brady, thanks for proving my point.

 

[exciter]

We've also had a historically bad division the past 5 or 6 years....

Uh, bears and lions ain’t exactly been juggernauts do they diminish Rogers accomplishment?

 

[Wangchung83]

How many qbs actually qualify or could have qualified? You can automatically Eliminate Stafford and Goff, no fault of their own, but the lions suck. Goff made three straight playoff, now he has to overcome the worst defense in the league. Not really a fair comparison having to overcome that. Drew Brees, Rothlisberger, etc have retired or went to different teams. Alex Smith made playoff in 4 out his first seasons but is eliminated bc of time frame and no longer active.lol. This is really stretch to say that Dak is elite imho.

 

[CowboyoWales]

You keep throwing names out there without even checking. You’ve been growing three times. Keep trying though

Fail. He was QB2 behind Brady. The methodology used for this empirical piece of research didnt mention playing.

 

[tomsanders921]

Uh, bears and lions ain’t exactly been juggernauts do they diminish Rogers accomplishment?

Please. Lets not try to compare Dak with Rodgers. Dak has what, one or two playoff wins?

Rodgers is an all time great. He's struggled to to get to the Superbowl but he was amazing the year he won it.

 

[5Stars]

No people that don’t like Prescott. They blame it just on him. They forget it’s a team game

But...but...wait for a sec. lol!

You are such a knuckle head...You dance so well around. One time you post that our QB will never win and the Boyz need to find another one, and now? You get so emotional when someone mentions his name? Wow...

 

[Yobwocs]

How many qbs actually qualify or could have qualified? You can automatically Eliminate Stafford and Goff, no fault of their own, but the lions suck. Goff made three straight playoff, now he has to overcome the worst defense in the league. Not really a fair comparison having to overcome that. Drew Brees, Rothlisberger, etc have retired or went to different teams. Alex Smith made playoff in 4 out his first seasons but is eliminated bc of time frame and no longer active.lol. This is really stretch to say that Dak is elite imho.

You either make it or not. Lions sucking or not doesn't mean they make it. Goff lost his job. That's his fault. Stafford had only 1 great year (last year) and now he's back down to the guy he has always been. Brees and Roethlisberger and Smith are retired. You wanna count retired players?

You have to hang onto a starting job. If you were a backup or were benched, it's kinda your own fault or your own Quarterback inabilities. Not seeing how not playing would qualify you.

I'm not saying Dak is elite, btw.

 

[exciter]

Please. Lets not try to compare Dak with Rodgers. Dak has what, one or two playoff wins?

Rodgers is an all time great. He's struggled to to get to the Superbowl but he was amazing the year he won it.

Who was comparing anyone. The comparison was between division level of competition. The lions and bears have been at least as bad as the giants and commodes. The eagles have been better and more consistent than the Vikings.

 

[leeblair]

Among active QBs only
Have to have been around at least 6 years
Injury year doesn't count


Dak

made playoffs (2016, 2018, 2021, 2022... assuming)
missed playoffs (2017, 2019)
injured (2020)


Rodgers

made playoffs (2016, 2019, 2020, 2021)
missed playoffs (2018, 2022... assuming)
injured (2017)


Brady

made playoffs (2017-2021)
missed playoffs (?.. possibly 2022 but they're still very much in it)



That's it. Elite company. Unless something crazy happens and he misses the playoffs this year, I don't see how the Jones will even think of moving on from him anytime soon.

That'll happen when you play in the weakest division in football.
What's bad is that he choked against the Eagles third stringers and lost the division one year.

 

[CowboyoWales]

It's last 6 years. I said SIX. Do the math. Wilson is falling hard. I'd rather be in Dak's shoes than Wilson's shoes right now. As for Mahomes, sure you can count him. So that's Dak, Mahomes, Rodgers, Brady, thanks for proving my point.

But YOUR title states 4 out of 6 seasons. Dak has only made 3 years so the whole premise is void, on grounds of seriously flawed criteria.

 

[CowboyoWales]

You either make it or not. Lions sucking or not doesn't mean they make it. Goff lost his job. That's his fault. Stafford had only 1 great year (last year) and now he's back down to the guy he has always been. Brees and Roethlisberger and Smith are retired. You wanna count retired players?

You have to hang onto a starting job. If you were a backup or were benched, it's kinda your own fault or your own Quarterback inabilities. Not seeing how not playing would qualify you.

I'm not saying Dak is elite, btw.

Sorry, just heard from Matt Ryan, claiming he qualifies on the list....you need to sack your research team.

 

[black label]

How mamy missing superbowls?

 

[CowboyoWales]

Among active QBs only
Have to have been around at least 6 years
Injury year doesn't count

That's it. Elite company. Unless something crazy happens and he misses the playoffs this year, I don't see how the Jones will even think of moving on from him anytime soon.

STOP THE PRESS....Matthew Stafford want's inclusion on the list (or are we not including years when the QB makes the SB)