Dak Prescott vs Patrick Mahomes in their last 50 starts

[Cowboys5217]

It's all in perspective....

Yep. Consistent turnovers are the sign of a choke artist. He's also fumbled in the playoffs.

Mahomes simply doesn't lose the football in crunch time while Dak is a guaranteed pick in playoff games.

Dak has a rate of 1 per playoff game while Mahomes has a rate of 1 per 7 playoff games according to these charts.

This is why comparing Dak to Mahomes makes people look foolish who do it.

 

[Motorola]

Dak having the best rookie QBR in history was pretty a compelling case for ROTY...

As good 1631 rushing yds was that year, it wasnt record setting... unlike Dak's achievement.

Also take into account Prescott was a 4th-round draft pick (as opportunity to Elliott selected in the 1st \ going no.4 overall), who was listed as the 3rd-string QB during training camp and preseason before the injuries to Moore and Romo.

 

[NotForLong]

True. Here is the link to NFL.com's story on the award: https://www.nfl.com/news/cowboys-jason-garrett-wins-coach-of-the-year-honors-0ap3000000782760

One difference between Jason Garrett's story (posted by the league) and Dak Prescott is the latter's questioned legitimacy for winning Rookie of the Year over Ezekiel Elliott. That article's perspective mirrors the sub-discussion that entered into this Prescott-themed thread. It is the reason why I posted the article, which was relevant to the time that the award was originally presented.

I did not think of posting a Garrett story into a Prescott thread. It is doubtful it shall divert from the thread topic but it has been inserted now.

Good for you. Garrett should have never got coach of the year and Prescott never should have gotten Rookie of the year

 

[iceberg]

great/ now name one franchise that will take prescott over mahomes.

 

[Rockport]

Yep. Consistent turnovers are the sign of a choke artist. He's also fumbled in the playoffs.

Mahomes simply doesn't lose the football in crunch time while Dak is a guaranteed pick in playoff games.

Dak has a rate of 1 per playoff game while Mahomes has a rate of 1 per 7 playoff games according to these charts.

This is why comparing Dak to Mahomes makes people look foolish who do it.

You haters are so easy. Dak was 2nd best last year in TD to INT ratio

https://www.statmuse.com/nfl/ask?q=best+touchdown/+interception+ratio+from+a+qb+2023

 

[Rockport]

great/ now name one franchise that will take prescott over mahomes.

 

[DallasEast]

Good for you. Garrett should have never got coach of the year and Prescott never should have gotten Rookie of the year

Lol @ “good for you”

 

[tyke1doe]

I fail to see the relevance of this comparison.

 

[zrinkill]

I fail to see the relevance of this comparison.

It is the Jerry Appreciation society's way of saying Dak is as good as Mahomes without acually saying Dak is as good as Mahomes.

This is the way that they think.

 

[zerofill]

lol @ people still putting Dak in the same sentence as Mahomes.

 

[GINeric]

Zeke won the rushing title by over 300 yards. THREE. HUNDRED. YARDS.

When Zeke left and our running game was the weakest it's been in years..... Dak managed to become an All-Pro and MVP candidate. He's not elite, but that's pretty difficult to do, being a one dimensional offense.

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

I missed those little stat about playoff wins and losses. And stat on Super Bowls.

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

lol @ people still putting Dak in the same sentence as Mahomes.

Blasphemy!
It is like comparing maples to orchids.

 

[GimmeTheBall!]

There’s not a team in the league that would take Prescott over Maholmes even the Cowboys, so what does it matter? It just means that there’s something more to the latter than the former.

Cowboys, Raiders and Falcons would.
We and they are tha stupid, old fellow.

 

[gtb1943]

When Zeke left and our running game was the weakest it's been in years..... Dak managed to become an All-Pro and MVP candidate. He's not elite, but that's pretty difficult to do, being a one dimensional offense.

One single vote for MVP. and then craps the bed in the playoffs
yeah sure

 

[gtb1943]

Cowboys, Raiders and Falcons would.
We and they are tha stupid, old fellow.

Gotta think the Browns might too

 

[GINeric]

One single vote for MVP. and then craps the bed in the playoffs
yeah sure

If it was .05 percent of a vote.... its still a vote due to the production.

And yep, he crapped the bed in the playoffs.... so did the defense and coaching staff. It's funny how they get left out of the bed crapping conversation.

This isn't tennis, golf or boxing. One player doesn't lose a game that consists of three units.

 

[kskboys]

Good for you. Garrett should have never got coach of the year and Prescott never should have gotten Rookie of the year

Prescott was purely a bus driver his rook season.

 

[Traye1]

Better yet, compare their playoff record. You know, performance when it actually matters

Yup, but while you're up to it, see how the respective defenses played in those games. In fact, KC's defense won KC a title in this t year's Superbowl. Although both have had performances worthy enough to win championship games, has Dak's or did Romo's defensive cohorts perform when it really mattered to help close games? IJS... It's true, defense wins championships because they are the ones who "PROTECT" and "PRESERVE" victory when the going gets tough.

Romo vs Seahawks in 2007 17/29/1TD/ 0 INT 189 yards Matt Hasslebeck 18/36/2TD/ 2 INT...Boys lost 21-20
Romo Vs Giants Romo 2008 18/36/1TD/ 1 INT 201 yards Eli Manning 12/18/2TD 0 INT 163 yards...Boys lost 21-17
In 2010 Romo and the Cowboys were blown out 34-3 by the Vikings....I guess Romo didn't score 35 so we lost.
Romo vs Packers in 2015... 15/19/2TD/ O INT 191 yards Aaron Rogers 24/35/3TDs 0INT 316 yards...Boys lose 26-21 but remember Dez Caught IT!!!

Dak Prescott vs. Packers 2017 24/38/3TDS/ 1INT 302 Yards...Aaron Rogers 28/43/2tds/ 1 INT...355 yards Boys lose 34-31...altho they were being miserably held in this game, defense could not protect or preserve victory in closing moments, btw...unlike KC this year.
Dak Prescott vs L A Rams 2018...20/32/1TD/ 0INT 266 yds...Jared Goff 15/28/0TDS / 0 INT 186 yards....Boys loss 28-20 but remember Dak couldn't stop the run this game, he gave up 273 yards on the ground...lol
Dak Prescott...Vs. 49ers...2022 23/43/1TD / 1INT...254 yards...Jimmy Garoppolo 16/23/0TDS/ 1 INT 172 yards...Boys lose 23-17
Dak Prescott Vs 49ers...2023...23/37/1td/ 2INT...206 yards....Brock Purdy 19/29/)TDS / O INT 214 yards...Boys lose 19-12 heartbreaker, Pollard knocked out.
Dak Prescott Vs Packers...2024...anyone with sense knows...the whole team stunk...something emotional was going on with this team on this day, (Quinn's pending departure) who knows but they ALL SUCKED!

Again...my personal conclusion is yes, we've had well enough qb performances to win multiple playoff games in the past, but DEFENSE WINS CHAMPIONSHIPS!!!

 

[Traye1]

Pappy and mountain are sharpening their nails....

Yup, but while you're up to it, see how the respective defenses played in those games. In fact, KC's defense won KC a title in this t year's Superbowl. Although both have had performances worthy enough to win championship games, has Dak's or did Romo's defensive cohorts perform when it really mattered to help close games? IJS... It's true, defense wins championships because they are the ones who "PROTECT" and "PRESERVE" victory when the going gets tough.

Romo vs Seahawks in 2007 17/29/1TD/ 0 INT 189 yards Matt Hasslebeck 18/36/2TD/ 2 INT...Boys lost 21-20
Romo Vs Giants Romo 2008 18/36/1TD/ 1 INT 201 yards Eli Manning 12/18/2TD 0 INT 163 yards...Boys lost 21-17
In 2010 Romo and the Cowboys were blown out 34-3 by the Vikings....I guess Romo didn't score 35 so we lost.
Romo vs Packers in 2015... 15/19/2TD/ O INT 191 yards Aaron Rogers 24/35/3TDs 0INT 316 yards...Boys lose 26-21 but remember Dez Caught IT!!!

Dak Prescott vs. Packers 2017 24/38/3TDS/ 1INT 302 Yards...Aaron Rogers 28/43/2tds/ 1 INT...355 yards Boys lose 34-31...altho they were being miserably held in this game, defense could not protect or preserve victory in closing moments, btw...unlike KC this year.
Dak Prescott vs L A Rams 2018...20/32/1TD/ 0INT 266 yds...Jared Goff 15/28/0TDS / 0 INT 186 yards....Boys loss 28-20 but remember Dak couldn't stop the run this game, he gave up 273 yards on the ground...lol
Dak Prescott...Vs. 49ers...2022 23/43/1TD / 1INT...254 yards...Jimmy Garoppolo 16/23/0TDS/ 1 INT 172 yards...Boys lose 23-17
Dak Prescott Vs 49ers...2023...23/37/1td/ 2INT...206 yards....Brock Purdy 19/29/)TDS / O INT 214 yards...Boys lose 19-12 heartbreaker, Pollard knocked out.
Dak Prescott Vs Packers...2024...anyone with sense knows...the whole team stunk...something emotional was going on with this team on this day, (Quinn's pending departure) who knows but they ALL SUCKED!

Again...my personal conclusion is yes, we've had well enough qb performances to win multiple playoff games in the past, but DEFENSE WINS CHAMPIONSHIPS!!!